Devin Hester or Josh Cribbs?

[bourneuf]

Hester has recently said that he would prefer to return kicks instead of being a full time WR. So who would you rather?

[Roger Murdock]

Cribbs. Hes a better kick returner, worse punt returner, and one of the best coverage special teamers as well as a top flight gadget player.

[CentralQB5]

Id rather have Cribbs, Hester had one stand out year and hasnt done a thing since then. Cribbs seems to be pretty consistant every year

[Zebulon]

Cribbs does more, is stronger, and more likely to break tackles.

[dropshot001]

i take cribbs, especially after seeing what he can do out of the wildcat.

[Huuminh]

Actually teams have been kicking away from Cribbs for weeks now as well. Cribbs has certaintly reached the level of elite return man in this league.