RealGM

Who would you pick to give the Bucs the best chance at winning? And why?

I think I would go with Jeff Garcia. He has a history of winning and would provide some stability there until Simms can properly take the reigns. He played like a champ last season in Philly, he has a fire that the other QB's on the team don't have yet. I'd go with him for the foreseeable future.

I would have to say Garcia for the time being. If we can go 9-7 this year with him I will be happy. I do feel we need to dump sims and gradkowski after the season and keep garcia as the backup and pick up someone in the first couple of rounds in the draft next season. Simms is not the answer and Bruce def. is not. I also think gruden has lost the team to a point and if we lose kiffin somehow after the season we are screwed.

I voted Garcia as well, Simms is too inconsistent and doesn't fit the typical Jon Gruden mold for a QB.

i like simms...he's really tough...apparently tough to a fault and he would be a great QB, but he needs to get his passes above the line of scrimmage.

he has one of the best deep balls in the game and jus needs to work on his short game and decision making a little bit. i'd love to have simms, caddy, clayton, and alex smith for the next 5 years, so they could grow with each other and make a nice combo of offensive weapons

Jeff Garcia, Chris Simms is inconsistant and he's not fully recovered from last yrs injury.


Garcia
Gradkowski
Simms