Eric Staal or Matt Duchene?

[imshaw]

Currently in a keeper league and have the choice of trading for either player.
Which would be the better choice between the 2?

[OldNo7]

Staal. Better source of goals, PIM, power play points, short handed points, game winners, shots

[MGD24]

I would rather have Duchene over the long term

[OldNo7]

In real hockey I might agree, I like him a lot. But I think Staal affects more stats in fantasy.

[imshaw]

Thanks guys. The guy ended up retracting Staal and gave me Duchene at a bit of a cheaper price.
What do you think of this?

I trade Semin + 1st round pick next year for Marc Andre Fleury?

We get to keep 5 each year. So right now my top 5 would be...
Crosby
Semin
Toews
Duchene
Lundquist

With Giroux and Gaborik being borderline

What do you guys think?

[OldNo7]

Giroux>>>>>Semin over the long haul. And with only 5 keepers, I wouldnt trade Semin + a 1st for Fleury.

[Huuminh]

Eric Staal is better choice for better goals in hockey..