Smitty731 wrote:For the Celtics, Rondo is the easy choice. But we know what he is, if he's healthy. So, he only needs to prove he is healthy. Which, of course, he isn't to start the season.
I am split 50-50 on Jared Sullinger and Marcus Smart. Sullinger needs to prove he is a piece worth keeping as the Celtics rebuild. Is he able to step up his game and enter that group of really good PFs? Or is he destined to be a guy whose best fit is a backup big off the bench on a good team? For Smart, he needs to prove he was the right pick. With Rondo out to start the season, Smart should see plenty of minutes to start off with. I know many don't believe he's a PG, so he needs to prove that he is. Or is he a combo guard? Starter or best fit off the bench?
I'll give Smart the benefit of the doubt as a rookie, and I'll pick Sullinger.
I would say Rondo for the Celtics but for a different reason.
I don't really know what he is right now. Yes, he's a very gifted playmaker- one of the best in the league, but the question for him now is this: Once he's healthy, what kind of player is he on the average team with no Hall of Fame teammates, no Hall of Fame coach, and a bunch of average talent to pass to? How much has he worked on that jumper? Has he improved his three point shooting enough to open up the rest of his game so that he can be a respectable scorer? Is he really an elite playmaker, or was that product of the system? There are lots of questions he's going to have to answer.
He is probably the most polarizing PG in the game right now, because there are people who think he will be a top 5 point guard when he gets healthy, and there are others who think he may be a below average starter, and both of them have strong cases. I honestly have no clue where to rank him.