Paradise wrote:Pistolpete1947 wrote:Paradise wrote:Whitehead is much more talented. He's quicker, more athletic. I don't see why we need to prioritize one over another. Dinwiddie is more of an MCW.
Sent from my iPhone using
RealGM mobile app
Whitehead is turnover prone and a poor shooter.
After the first half-dozen games I see no improvement from him in terms of running the offense despite starting for over 30 games. Dinwiddie runs the offense better even with his limited experience. If he had the opportunity Whitehead has had he'd be light years ahead of him IMO. We need to prioritize because when Lin comes back only one will get the backup minutes. Unless Dinwiddie plays lights out for the next week the backup spot will go to Whitehead. This will be a big mistake for the Net's future.
If you don't agree with me on this just compare their stats so far this year. Dinwiddie's are better even though Whitehead has had tons more playing time than him.
Whitehead is a rookie. A half dozen games when the guy has missed plenty of games as well? Come on man. This is a rebuild. That's not how talent is evaluated. Dinwiddie is a 3rd year guard. I'd hope Dinwiddie looked better than him. We signed him to be the Vasquez replacement. He's been in the league longer despite being only 23.
I'm not going to compare stats because this is a rebuild and both are apart of it. Dinwiddie lost us plenty of chances to win against the Pelicans and finished with 0 points. He's not that good either and while, I'm on board with him as a backup PG prospect. Great size, defensive instincts but the shooting and court vision upside is questionable. Whitehead is definitely has more offensive upside to get better than him.
Sent from my iPhone using
RealGM mobile app
IMO, Lin made a lot of the same mistakes over a season when he was a Houston Rocket. He made some of the same mistakes in the season after. One of these was jumping in the air on a drive with no outlet and turning the ball over. He hardly does that anymore, but it took awhile for him not to.
As a Lin fan, I apply the same standard I applied to Lin to others with little experience. Let the guy play through repeated errors and expect these errors. Look at his upside and let him play through his mistakes.
I don't feel that an approach that talks about anything less than a season or season and a half with a rookie to see less mistakes, is fair. Whitehead may become a top shot blocker, a strong defensive force against 1s and 2s, a guy who can absorb contact and get to the rim and finish, and he's done excellent on getting TOs and executing fast breaks. These areas Dinwiddie is weaker at. And I also find, while neither Dinwiddie or Whitehead have great vision, Whitehead, per their experience, has more potential. Whitehead actually attempts good passes and sees open guys more, he just messes up executing them. That's part of development.
As a Lin fan, I wish to support Whitehead and want to give him the same leeway for making errors as I think Lin should have received under McHale in Houston. It messed Lin up to mess with his minutes and not let him play through those mistakes, it slowed down his development. I think KA is taking the right approach with Whitehead. And really, Whitehead wasn't supposed to play this much. Lin was supposed to play 30 or so mpg, with IW getting the remainder time. He's done OK seeing the situation his been put in.