bertrob wrote:
Have not yet seen it yet (buffering it right now) but I am scared now
Let me know what you think.
Moderators: Jeff Van Gully, dakomish23, Capn'O, j4remi, Deeeez Knicks, NoLayupRule, mpharris36, GONYK, HerSports85
bertrob wrote:
Have not yet seen it yet (buffering it right now) but I am scared now
bertrob wrote:Falstaffxx wrote:
I'm switching gears away from Gundam to Fullmetal Alchemist for the moment. I've never seen any FMA, but I thought I should. I'm watching Brotherhood, because that's the one I have and someone told me it's better (dunno if that's true).
It's not necessarily better, just different. It just follows the manga so more people are apt to crown it. But after comparing the two, I do think Brotherhood is better because I didn't like the whole buildup to the ending of the first one. Also you get a better sense of finality. And you can't forget about having Yao Ling and Olivier Mira Armstrong in it. But I also kinda liked Dante, who was an original anime character from the first one. The ending for the first one was also kind of an interesting idea. Brotherhood is the one you should definitely watch, but if you ever have time the first one isn't a bad watch either.Falstaffxx wrote:
For the new stuff...the first episode of Maoyu was a mess...I'll give it another ep to get going, but I'm not feeling optimistic about it.
Have not yet seen it yet (buffering it right now) but I am scared now
Falstaffxx wrote:
Utena has become one of my favorite shows. I just finished the TV series. It's beautiful, weird, intense. I will say I was disappointed by the ending, but that doesn't change the fact that it's an amazing series. I still have the movie to watch, so I'm looking forward to that.
LLJ wrote:Falstaffxx wrote:
Utena has become one of my favorite shows. I just finished the TV series. It's beautiful, weird, intense. I will say I was disappointed by the ending, but that doesn't change the fact that it's an amazing series. I still have the movie to watch, so I'm looking forward to that.
The ending may be a bit less "grand" than one might hope, but thematically it makes total sense, if you look at it from a feminist point of view. Utena inspired Anthy to break out of her emotional and mental bonds and now Anthy will go off into the world and maybe do the same thing Utena did. It's pretty neat if you think about it that way. It's definitely one for the sociology classes.
The Utena movie is one of the most visually gorgeous anime movies ever made, but don't expect too much in the way of additional info on the series.
LLJ wrote:Gender roles and subversion were definitely a big part of the show's themes. Yes, there is the mystical element as well, but it's definitely in part about the idea of living in a society (whether it be patriarchal or whatever) that seeks to shackle you to playing a certain role within society. The whole show is largely symbolic. The big thing about Utena was that what everyone was searching for...was kind of a big lie. They were looking for something that didn't really exist. The ending showed that Akio and everyone else in the Student Council were fools who chose to sequester themselves within a rigid social structure and "game" instead of going out and living life by their own rules. Remember, the show is called Revolutionary Girl Utena. Nobody said the revolution was going to be quick and easy, though.
It also says something about the idea of conforming too. In the show, only 3 characters really chose to challenge the structure of the world and its rules...Utena, Mikage and at the last, Anthy. And they were subsequently kicked out of those worlds...although Anthy left on her own accord. In interviews, the director stated that this was the Catch-22 of being a real, self-thinking individual...if you didn't play by society's rules, then society itself would reject you.
So I think the ending is consistent to its themes. I think the mystical elements were actually purposefully alluring in order to emphasize the rather shallow nature of the Student Council's worldview. If I may stretch the show into a real life analogy a bit, our own society says that to be a successful person, you should get married, have kids, have a well paying job and hopefully one day work your way up to a two-garage home. That's the great "special thing" we seek, because that's what mainstream society says is successful. The people who don't follow this life model have a harder road ahead of them. Utena is saying "Hey, if you want to challenge the status quo, you gotta have the guts to accept being rejected by the world around you. Kudos to you if you can."
Did you watch this online or the DVDs? The DVD sets include these thick 80-100 page booklets featuring essays and interviews with all the staff members. They all have their own ideas about what the show means, but the theme of gender roles, fairy tales, social hierarchy all come up frequently. They're really fascinating reads.
LLJ wrote:I originally though the ending should have been "bigger" as well, but when I add up all the dots, the ending really is the most logical one, and the most faithful to Utena's own ideals. If they went for some grand ending where the transcendent secrets of the world were unlocked, it would have been totally opposite of what Utena stood for, since she didn't want all that. Plus, I think we the audience were trolled a bit as well because now that I think back on it, I feel like all the grander and empty mysticism was actually meant to be questioned. It's like dealing with the devil. They wave all this shiny mystical babble in front of you and ask you just how much you want it, and if you're willing to sacrifice your ideals for it. Utena didn't, and the ending reflects that. Of course, that's just one interpretation. But I think categorizing the show as some nebulous intangible magical...thing...would be both doing it a disservice and at the same time overpraising it.
Maybe you would like the movie ending better. The ending is pretty damned crazy, if nothing else.
I do have some other problems with Utena personally when it comes to some of the minor characters and the pacing (it doesn't hit my top 5 of the 90s) but the ending really isn't one of them. I really do think they stuck to their guns on that one and it works.
As for Evangelion, I am one of the very few who liked the TV ending the best.
bertrob wrote:Falstaffxx wrote:
I'm switching gears away from Gundam to Fullmetal Alchemist for the moment. I've never seen any FMA, but I thought I should. I'm watching Brotherhood, because that's the one I have and someone told me it's better (dunno if that's true).
It's not necessarily better, just different. It just follows the manga so more people are apt to crown it. But after comparing the two, I do think Brotherhood is better because I didn't like the whole buildup to the ending of the first one. Also you get a better sense of finality. And you can't forget about having Yao Ling and Olivier Mira Armstrong in it. But I also kinda liked Dante, who was an original anime character from the first one. The ending for the first one was also kind of an interesting idea. Brotherhood is the one you should definitely watch, but if you ever have time the first one isn't a bad watch either.Falstaffxx wrote:
For the new stuff...the first episode of Maoyu was a mess...I'll give it another ep to get going, but I'm not feeling optimistic about it.
Have not yet seen it yet (buffering it right now) but I am scared now
j4remi wrote:
I think the cool thing about Brotherhood and the original is that they're so different after the first 1/3rd or so of the story (which is also somewhat different in it's own right) that you can watch both without getting bored. HunterXHunter is doing a remake thing but it's the same plot, just much improved animation imo.
QueenzAllDay wrote:Must watch- MAGI. Funny / Adventure type.
Maaaaan what I would give to create my own story.
Falstaffxx wrote:QueenzAllDay wrote:Must watch- MAGI. Funny / Adventure type.
Maaaaan what I would give to create my own story.
Is that a new show that just started, or has it been going on for a while?
Falstaffxx wrote:QueenzAllDay wrote:Must watch- MAGI. Funny / Adventure type.
Maaaaan what I would give to create my own story.
Is that a new show that just started, or has it been going on for a while?
Falstaffxx wrote:By the way LLJ, sorry if I'm overly aggressive with my opinions about anime. I get intense about it.
LLJ wrote:Falstaffxx wrote:By the way LLJ, sorry if I'm overly aggressive with my opinions about anime. I get intense about it.
No problem. To be honest, I get pretty passionate talking about any sort of film or TV series in general, at least the ones I feel are notable.