Superfans: Knicks vs. Knicks

[Capn'O]

Ok, ok. It's obvious. Nobody can beat the superteam. They are impenetrable and indestructible force of extreme awesome. So we have to get creative here. Who would win in a game of Knicks... against the Knicks?!

The FIVE rules to this poll are as follows:

1. Five five minute quarters. 25 minutes. That's right. I said five quarters.
2. All players are in their prime.
3. Five on five game. No bench. No substitutions.
4. No coach. Pickup game.
EDIT RULE FIVE: Self called games. No refs. Ball don't lie.

Now, keep in mind, this is a game of fives. This is important... somehow.

Who wins? The heady, spread the floor, passers or the explosive, athletic, offensive onslaught with Tyson manning the post?

Discuss!

[Grinditout]

So these are what threads are like when we're winning games....interesting

[rdogg1026]

This forum is crazy after primetime wins.

[nykballa2k4]

Basically this means you can play physical. Kidd gets to foul people as much as he wants. Basically "street ball" games go to the bigs with the best post game and guards with the most ability. Mello would be guarded by Rasheed (in his prime) with Camby on Stat and Vak on Chandler. Yeah team 2 and it's not that close

[Capn'O]

Basically this means you can play physical. Kidd gets to foul people as much as he wants. Basically "street ball" games go to the bigs with the best post game and guards with the most ability. Mello would be guarded by Rasheed (in his prime) with Camby on Stat and Vak on Chandler. Yeah team 2 and it's not that close

Oh word good rule. No REFS. Self called.

[ibraheim718]

You don't think stuporman can be one of the newer posters?

[Capn'O]

You don't think stuporman can be one of the newer posters?

He could be. But he had a pretty distinctive style. Was he waived at one point?

[BOOMbip]

D

[JustCame]

Replace Prigs with JR..or at least Brewer.

[NYK_Lampe]

What is the point of the 5 five minute quarters other than being different for the sake of being different?

[Jstarks3]

we dont even know what shumps prime is

[TheGarden]

we dont even know what shumps prime is

Jordan+Kobe+LeBron+Magic+Carmelo+Kidd+Payton+Isiah+Rodman+Penny-Bird

[BOOMbip]

we dont even know what shumps prime is

Jordan+Kobe+LeBron+Magic+Carmelo+Kidd+Payton+Isiah+Rodman+Penny-Bird

Wait.... -Bird? I see what you did there...

[Jstarks3]

we dont even know what shumps prime is

Jordan+Kobe+LeBron+Magic+Carmelo+Kidd+Payton+Isiah+Rodman+Penny-Bird

you forgot Wade

[j4remi]

Prime Kidd with Sheed and Camby...that's terrifying.