http://bkref.com/tiny/gkYJuSearch criteria: In 2016-17, 5-man lineup, per 100 possessions, in the regular season, playing for the Knicks, requiring Minutes Played >= 36, sorted by ascending Net Points
Purpose of this postis to make informed decisions on FA and draft based on what actually worked for the team this year..and what didn't.
Out of 14 total lineups that met the above criteria, some observations:
9/14
C. Anthony | C. Lee | J. Noah | K. Porzingis | D. Rose 395.6 MP -6.7 Net PTS
Basically, the Jackson 5 was a failure, but we all knew that. Some type of shake up is required.
2/14
C. Anthony | J. Holiday | J. Noah | K. Porzingis | D. Rose 37.1 MP +20.5 PTS
So there's a shakeup. Move Holiday in there for Lee and viola, big time point shift. Should Holiday be considered for a 5th starter role? Lee has a favorable contract. Maybe there's a deal to be made there.
3/14
C. Anthony | C. Lee | J. Noah | D. Rose | L. Thomas 71.5 MP +16.8 Net PTS
Melo at the 4. People were screaming for it this year. Not Jeff obvioulsy. This lineup would need Rose to be replaced by someone with a similar skillset (or re-signed). I really don't know what Jackson is thinking of doing because he did speak well of Rose, but I expect him to play it smart and draft a PG who would replace him in this lineup.
14/14
C. Anthony | C. Lee | K. O'Quinn | D. Rose | L. Thomas 68.7 MP -11.9 PTS
Swap out KOQ for Noah and the lead goes away. If there's an asset to be had for him, I'd take the offer seriously.
13/14
C. Anthony | W. Hernangomez | C. Lee | K. Porzingis | D. Rose NYK 171.8 MP -9.6 Net PTS.
Disaster. 2 C's, a PF and 2 guards. Great lineup in the 70s. Gotta point the finger strait at Hornacek here, especially with so many MP. 2nd most of any unit!
6/14
C. Anthony | C. Lee | K. Porzingis | D. Rose | L. Thomas NYK 108.6 MP +7.0 Net PTS
Melo at the 4, KP at the 5. It worked pretty well. Only unit to play over 100 minutes together and end up with a positive rating. I wonder how much better it would have worked with Holiday in there instead of Lee.
1/14
W. Hernangomez | J. Holiday | B. Jennings | M. Kuzminskas | K. Porzingis 44.8 MP +26.1 Net PTS
The bench was the best overall unit, which we all knew. They actually flowed and there was a heirarchy around KP. Jennings sought him out every play. Rose and Melo weren't there to ball-stop. Replace Jennings with Rubio somehow and maybe you've got something. It's not like Jennings shot that well this year, so you're not losing that.
From what I can see, KOQ and Lee should be made available. Each should be able to fetch something. Holiday needs to be a priority signing.
Rose..that's a toughie. It all depends on market value tbh. If somebody offers him a lot of coin then best of luck. If he takes very low end starter money..maybe with a 2nd year PO. A below market deal for a PO 2nd year is fair. He'll get a better deal than low money + team option. Happens all the time. Replacing him is probably going to be more expensive than it's worth this year, most likely. Noah is already an albatross contract. George Hill and Jrue Holiday can very easily become one too. SnT Rose for Rubio? That's a smart move imo.
Start Rubio/Holiday/Thomas/Melo/KP, go from there.
I think one BIG fix that can be made is that nobody outside of Melo and KP are guaranteed starters. Everyone else has to earn their keep. After a losing season, the players have no room to complain about that. And if they do, they're not the players that are conducive to winning. Melo was in the ASG and KP is the future. Everybody else needs to play like their jobs depend on it.
FWIW, I doubt Melo is going anywhere.