ImageImage

Greatest Blazers Ever: Vote for #4

Moderators: DeBlazerRiddem, Moonbeam

User avatar
Moonbeam
Forum Mod - Blazers
Forum Mod - Blazers
Posts: 10,212
And1: 5,060
Joined: Feb 21, 2009
Location: Sydney, Australia
     

Greatest Blazers Ever: Vote for #4 

Post#1 » by Moonbeam » Thu Jul 30, 2015 8:11 am

The list so far is here.

Project Guidelines:

Spoiler:
1. Each thread will be open for 48 hours. After 48 hours have passed, the thread will close if a single player receives a majority of the votes. If not, the top 2-3 candidates will enter a runoff period of 24 hours. During this period, you may switch your vote to one of the reduced list of candidates if you voted for someone else.

2. When making a formal vote, please include the player's name in bold. This helps me keep track. Please include a justification for your choice. It may be brief, but simply writing the name of your choice will not be a counted vote.

3. You may switch your vote, but please emphasize this in bold.

4. Please only consider each player's performance with Portland.

5. We all have our favorites, and we all have our own criteria. I believe the discussion and learning from this project will be more important than the placement of the individual players.

6. Have fun!


Runoff Guidelines:

Spoiler:
If at the end of 48 hours, no single player has more than 50% of the votes cast, the top 2 candidates will enter a runoff vote.

1. Original votes for one of these 2 players still count.

2. Those who voted for one of the candidates outside of the top 2 must cast a vote for one of the top 2 candidates for their votes to count.

3. Those who did not vote in the first 48 hours are still welcome to vote in the runoff.

4. Anyone is welcome to change his/her vote if swayed by the arguments of others.


Lots of players got votes at #3. I expect another hotly contested fight for #4!
User avatar
d-train
RealGM
Posts: 21,227
And1: 1,098
Joined: Mar 26, 2001
   

Re: Greatest Blazers Ever: Vote for #4 

Post#2 » by d-train » Thu Jul 30, 2015 8:30 am

Terry Porter

Porter was the 2nd best player on the early 90's team that made it to WC finals 3x and NBA championship 2x. Porter wasn't a franchise player but he was a great player on a great team and half one of the all-time best backcourts. Rasheed, Lucas, and Pippen get some consideration but Porter is easily the best choice.
Image
Masterfully
Starter
Posts: 2,295
And1: 1,435
Joined: Jun 04, 2015

Re: Greatest Blazers Ever: Vote for #4 

Post#3 » by Masterfully » Thu Jul 30, 2015 11:49 am

dtrain said most of my points. I'd also add that those amazing teams were not exactly the most mature teams. Terry Porter was the one moving around to keep an even keel. Almost a coach on the floor.

I have seen how some people don't like stats used in this discussion, so I won't bring up all the stats Terry has except one. Win shares to me is the best measuring stick for a player's contributions to his team. Terry has 79.3 regular season WS and 10.3 playoff WS. You won't find another candidate that touches that. For perspective, if you add up every player that played for Portland during Aldridge's 9 years you get a total of 12 playoff WS.
User avatar
Moonbeam
Forum Mod - Blazers
Forum Mod - Blazers
Posts: 10,212
And1: 5,060
Joined: Feb 21, 2009
Location: Sydney, Australia
     

Re: Greatest Blazers Ever: Vote for #4 

Post#4 » by Moonbeam » Thu Jul 30, 2015 11:58 am

Masterfully wrote:dtrain said most of my points. I'd also add that those amazing teams were not exactly the most mature teams. Terry Porter was the one moving around keep an even keel. Almost a coach on the floor.

I have seen how some people don't like stats used in this discussion, so I won't bring up all the stats Terry has except one. Win shares to me is the best measuring stick for a player's contributions to his team. Terry has 79.3 regular season WS and 10.3 playoff WS. You won't find another candidate that touches that.


Don't be shy to discuss stats! I'm a bit of a stats nerd, so I appreciate any statistical comparisons you'd like to make. :)
Masterfully
Starter
Posts: 2,295
And1: 1,435
Joined: Jun 04, 2015

Re: Greatest Blazers Ever: Vote for #4 

Post#5 » by Masterfully » Thu Jul 30, 2015 12:35 pm

Moonbeam wrote:
Masterfully wrote:dtrain said most of my points. I'd also add that those amazing teams were not exactly the most mature teams. Terry Porter was the one moving around keep an even keel. Almost a coach on the floor.

I have seen how some people don't like stats used in this discussion, so I won't bring up all the stats Terry has except one. Win shares to me is the best measuring stick for a player's contributions to his team. Terry has 79.3 regular season WS and 10.3 playoff WS. You won't find another candidate that touches that.


Don't be shy to discuss stats! I'm a bit of a stats nerd, so I appreciate any statistical comparisons you'd like to make. :)


Yeah but for some it appears to be a mark against the candidate. They adopt a "oh a bunch of stats is all you got?" stance. It's probably because we Portlanders love an underdog.

I like stats because it's just raw data without any emotions to complicate things.
User avatar
JasonStern
RealGM
Posts: 12,161
And1: 4,245
Joined: Dec 13, 2008
 

Re: Greatest Blazers Ever: Vote for #4 

Post#6 » by JasonStern » Thu Jul 30, 2015 12:35 pm

this is where I will go with the currently unpopular, but correct, choice and vote LaMarcus Aldridge.

seasons with Portland:
Porter 10
Aldridge 9
Lucas 3.5

playoff series wins as #1 option
Aldridge 1
Porter 0
Lucas 0

All-Star Appearances With Portland
Aldridge 4
Lucas 3
Porter 2

2nd Team All-NBA Appearances With Portland
Aldridge 1
Lucas 1
Porter 0

All-NBA Third Team Apperances With Portland
Aldridge 3
Lucas 0
Porter 0

NBA All-Rookie Appearances With Portland
Aldridge 1
Lucas 0
Porter 0

Franchise Points
Aldridge #2
Porter #3
Lucas outside the top 10

Franchise Rebounds
Aldridge #1
Porter, Lucas outside the top 10

Franchise Blocks
Aldridge #4
Lucas, Porter outside the top 10

Points Per Game With Portland
Aldridge #6 - 19.4ppg
Lucas, Porter outside the top 10

Rebounds Per Game
Lucas 8.7
Aldridge 8.4
Porter outside the top 10

PER
Aldridge 20.3
Lucas, Porter outside the top 10

if Lucas had a longer tenure as a Blazer, or any success as the #1 option when Walton was out, then I could see voting for him. likewise, Porter was never #2 or #3 in the league at his position, and his success was tied to playing with Drexler. hate him for leaving in free agency, but Aldridge had the better career as a Blazer.

see everyone in the Lucas/Porter run-offs.
Image
"Hate all you want. The Bucks will trade Doc Rivers for me."
- Chauncey Billups
Masterfully
Starter
Posts: 2,295
And1: 1,435
Joined: Jun 04, 2015

Re: Greatest Blazers Ever: Vote for #4 

Post#7 » by Masterfully » Thu Jul 30, 2015 1:06 pm

JasonStern wrote:Franchise Points
Aldridge #2
Porter, Lucas outside the top 10


This one is wrong:
Franchise Points
Aldridge #2
Porter #3

And then there's this...
3 pt FGM
Porter #2
Aldridge & Lucas outside the top 10

Assists
Porter #1
Aldridge & Lucas outside the top 10

Steals
Porter #2
Aldridge & Lucas outside the top 10

And some of Aldridge's prowess might be due to this:
Usage Pct
Aldridge #3
Porter outside the top 10
Agenda42
General Manager
Posts: 9,847
And1: 461
Joined: Jun 29, 2008

Re: Greatest Blazers Ever: Vote for #4 

Post#8 » by Agenda42 » Thu Jul 30, 2015 1:09 pm

I'm glad someone else is there to bang the drum for Aldridge, and I'll be joining you on that bandwagon soon.

For me, it's Terry Porter here. Main reason is efficiency -- Porter had impressive efficiency for a PG, while Aldridge was a fairly inefficient scorer as a PF. There's also the matter of sustained team success, which I attribute a significant part of to Porter's ability to keep the team working smoothly.
Brandon-Clyde
RealGM
Posts: 23,352
And1: 5,788
Joined: May 29, 2008
     

Re: Greatest Blazers Ever: Vote for #4 

Post#9 » by Brandon-Clyde » Thu Jul 30, 2015 2:40 pm

Rasheed Wallace- the best player on a title contending team. Had a complete all around game
There are no constraints on the human mind, no walls around the human spirit, no barriers to our progress except those we ourselves erect." -- Ronald Reagan
Run PDX
Pro Prospect
Posts: 967
And1: 452
Joined: Jun 20, 2012
   

Re: Greatest Blazers Ever: Vote for #4 

Post#10 » by Run PDX » Thu Jul 30, 2015 4:59 pm

Can't we just agree that the loser of the run off vote for 3rd gets 4th? I mean, I feel like that is the fairest thing to do.

But, I'll just go ahead and state my vote anyway:

LUKE.
The best power forward the Blazers ever had. And, he would have even better statistics with the team if the ownership weren't so cheap in the early 80s - deciding that they didn't need want to pay Lucas, because they had just drafted Mychal Thompson.
User avatar
d-train
RealGM
Posts: 21,227
And1: 1,098
Joined: Mar 26, 2001
   

Re: Greatest Blazers Ever: Vote for #4 

Post#11 » by d-train » Thu Jul 30, 2015 5:07 pm

Run PDX wrote:Can't we just agree that the loser of the run off vote for 3rd gets 4th? I mean, I feel like that is the fairest thing to do.

But, I'll just go ahead and state my vote anyway:

LUKE.
The best power forward the Blazers ever had. And, he would have even better statistics with the team if the ownership weren't so cheap in the early 80s - deciding that they didn't need want to pay Lucas, because they had just drafted Mychal Thompson.

The majority of people voted for the winner not the loser. And, the people that voted for the winner may not want to vote for the loser.
Image
DavidSterned
Lead Assistant
Posts: 4,999
And1: 4,669
Joined: Feb 18, 2010
         

Re: Greatest Blazers Ever: Vote for #4 

Post#12 » by DavidSterned » Thu Jul 30, 2015 5:34 pm

I'll throw in another vote for Porter. He played way longer with the team than Lucas and had more playoff success than Aldridge.
User avatar
JasonStern
RealGM
Posts: 12,161
And1: 4,245
Joined: Dec 13, 2008
 

Re: Greatest Blazers Ever: Vote for #4 

Post#13 » by JasonStern » Thu Jul 30, 2015 8:10 pm

d-train wrote:Rasheed, Lucas, and Pippen get some consideration but Porter is easily the best choice.


you do realize that the Pippen that played with Portland was a 34 year old averaging a whopping 12ppg that failed to provide veteran leadership when the team needed it most - not the prime Jordan's sidekick people remember him, right?


Masterfully wrote:This one is wrong:
Franchise Points
Aldridge #2
Porter #3


corrected.


Masterfully wrote:And then there's this...
3 pt FGM
Porter #2
Aldridge & Lucas outside the top 10

Assists
Porter #1
Aldridge & Lucas outside the top 10

Steals
Porter #2
Aldridge & Lucas outside the top 10


I completely agree that Porter was/is a better point guard, but even taking that into consideration, Aldridge's collective body of work trumps Porter's.


Masterfully wrote:And some of Aldridge's prowess might be due to this:
Usage Pct
Aldridge #3
Porter outside the top 10


I completely agree that Porter was a role player with Portland whereas Aldridge was a #1 option. in fact, that encouraged me to vote for Aldridge over Porter. I mean, Joel Freeland had a much lower usage rate, but I wouldn't put him above Aldridge because of it.
Image
"Hate all you want. The Bucks will trade Doc Rivers for me."
- Chauncey Billups
Wizenheimer
RealGM
Posts: 36,105
And1: 7,876
Joined: May 28, 2007

Re: Greatest Blazers Ever: Vote for #4 

Post#14 » by Wizenheimer » Thu Jul 30, 2015 9:03 pm

it might be close to 'pick from a hat' time. So, who would be the rest of the candidates for the top-10?

Wicks
Petrie
Lucas
Mychal Thompson
Porter
Kersey
Buck
Rasheed
Pippen
Sabonis
Aldridge
Lillard

did I leave anybody out?

I'm thinking maybe Porter, but that isn't my vote yet
Agenda42
General Manager
Posts: 9,847
And1: 461
Joined: Jun 29, 2008

Re: Greatest Blazers Ever: Vote for #4 

Post#15 » by Agenda42 » Thu Jul 30, 2015 10:04 pm

Wizenheimer wrote:did I leave anybody out?


Some other candidates:

Kiki Vandeweghe was quietly the leader in Blazer ppg and strong in WS48.
Kevin Duckworth was a 2-time all star. Somehow.
Clifford Robinson was statistically much better than I expected/remembered.
Jim Paxson was a freakishly efficient scorer.
User avatar
d-train
RealGM
Posts: 21,227
And1: 1,098
Joined: Mar 26, 2001
   

Re: Greatest Blazers Ever: Vote for #4 

Post#16 » by d-train » Thu Jul 30, 2015 10:25 pm

Wizenheimer wrote:it might be close to 'pick from a hat' time. So, who would be the rest of the candidates for the top-10?

Wicks
Petrie
Lucas
Mychal Thompson
Porter
Kersey
Buck
Rasheed
Pippen
Sabonis
Aldridge
Lillard

did I leave anybody out?

I'm thinking maybe Porter, but that isn't my vote yet

You are missing Rod Strickland and Lionel Hollins. And, you need to remove the stat stuffing losers Sidney Wicks and Geoff Petrie. A dozen players that played winning basketball should be on the list ahead of Wicks and Petrie.
Image
User avatar
d-train
RealGM
Posts: 21,227
And1: 1,098
Joined: Mar 26, 2001
   

Re: Greatest Blazers Ever: Vote for #4 

Post#17 » by d-train » Thu Jul 30, 2015 10:35 pm

JasonStern wrote:you do realize that the Pippen that played with Portland was a 34 year old averaging a whopping 12ppg that failed to provide veteran leadership when the team needed it most - not the prime Jordan's sidekick people remember him, right?

Pippen was past his prime and he was the 2nd best player on a great team. Pippen was about winning. He was often the difference between winning and losing without stuffing a stat sheet.
Image
User avatar
Fitz303
General Manager
Posts: 8,198
And1: 1,839
Joined: Oct 18, 2006
Location: Portland

Re: Greatest Blazers Ever: Vote for #4 

Post#18 » by Fitz303 » Fri Jul 31, 2015 1:51 am

Gimme Porter. Dtrain did a good job explaining in the first post. Lucas is close, along with Sheed and LMA, but this one is Porter for me
DaVoiceMaster
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 20,926
And1: 2,296
Joined: Sep 26, 2003
Contact:
   

Re: Greatest Blazers Ever: Vote for #4 

Post#19 » by DaVoiceMaster » Fri Jul 31, 2015 4:19 am

Terry Porter for reasons mentioned in the #3 thread ... team leader, played both sides of the ball, underrated due to Drexler, and so much more.
DaVoiceMaster
Senior Mod - Trail Blazers
12/27/2017 - 01/03/2018
Norm2953
RealGM
Posts: 16,314
And1: 2,130
Joined: May 17, 2003
Location: Oregon

Re: Greatest Blazers Ever: Vote for #4 

Post#20 » by Norm2953 » Fri Jul 31, 2015 5:09 am

I find it curious Lucas was in a run off for #3 but yet people are now voting for Porter.

I'd still like to vote for Sabas or someone from the last Blazers team to reach the WCF
for key players for the 1977 NBA champions and early 90's teams have been chosen. Sabas
and Pippen were all about winning and less about putting up numbers but Scottie's
is a Bull while Sabas played seven solid seasons only with the Blazers after he arguably
was past his physical peak. Great player who played solid defense, rebounded, set
picks, made great passes, shot well from 3 point line, etc. Entered the HOF as a
Blazer!

I love TP, Lucas and the other guys like Matthews who were strong contributors but they
don't find success without the key players on the teams they played for.

Return to Portland Trail Blazers