yardbarker

OT - Morey or Colangelo???

Moderators: Rhettmatic, Yuri Vaultin, The Duke, 5DOM, itbobby007, Morris_Shatford, Alfred, YogiStewart, j127, darth_federer, DG88

ImageImageImageImageImage

Who's a better GM?

Morey
89
82%
Colangelo
19
18%
 
Total votes : 108

Re: OT - Morey or Colangelo???

Postby Scraptor on Fri Feb 22, 2013 1:54 am

lander wrote:
UssjTrunks wrote:
billy_hoyle wrote:So Morey takes a 6 game over .500 team trades the starting backcourt (Lowry + Martin), drops a solid starting PF (Scola) and turns them into a 6 game over .500 team and he's a genius? Right....


The point is that he acquired an MVP-level franchise player. That should be the goal of every team. This is a star-driven league, and getting that superstar is by far the hardest part of building a contender.


MVP level really? Harden is as good as Durant? Lebron? Rose? Kobe?

Really. Wow.




Win shares:
1. Durant
2. LBJ
3. Harden
4. Paul
5. Tony Parker

Harden is definitely having an MVP caliber season.
User avatar
Scraptor
Assistant Coach
 
Posts: 3938
And1: 117
Joined: Nov 17, 2005
Location: 11 champ;ipnsikp[ ringhs

Re: OT - Morey or Colangelo???

Postby Marvin Martian on Fri Feb 22, 2013 2:05 am

This topic should not even exist. But nonetheless, the only good move that BC has made so far is lowry and gay. The rest are extremely poor. I think Fields, Bargs and DD are overpaid for their production and skillset.
Marvin Martian
Rookie
 
Posts: 1096
And1: 25
Joined: Aug 13, 2012

Re: OT - Morey or Colangelo???

Postby Phenomenologist on Fri Feb 22, 2013 2:20 am

lander wrote:
UssjTrunks wrote:
billy_hoyle wrote:So Morey takes a 6 game over .500 team trades the starting backcourt (Lowry + Martin), drops a solid starting PF (Scola) and turns them into a 6 game over .500 team and he's a genius? Right....


The point is that he acquired an MVP-level franchise player. That should be the goal of every team. This is a star-driven league, and getting that superstar is by far the hardest part of building a contender.


MVP level really? Harden is as good as Durant? Lebron? Rose? Kobe?

Really. Wow.


LBJ? No.
Durant? No.
Rose? Definitely.
Last few season Kobe? Quite possibly.

Harden is a top-10 player already and he's 23.
User avatar
Phenomenologist
Veteran
 
Posts: 2866
And1: 61
Joined: May 16, 2008

Re: OT - Morey or Colangelo???

Postby Phenomenologist on Fri Feb 22, 2013 2:25 am

Scraptor wrote: Everything really depends on how good Val can get, and how fast.


Yep...and yet Aaron Gray plays > 0 minutes in his stead during yet another lottery season. smh. fml.
User avatar
Phenomenologist
Veteran
 
Posts: 2866
And1: 61
Joined: May 16, 2008

Re: OT - Morey or Colangelo???

Postby GREY 1769 on Fri Feb 22, 2013 6:50 am

Seriously, who voted for BC?

Morey by a country mile. I love how people thought he was crazy stockpiling young players, picks or players in same position only to turn it around and strike gold. Lin was a risk but he took it and the young players/picks were traded to make the team better. Way better, far sooner. Now that's an accelerated rebuild.
Image
Courtesy of http://www.turbozone.ca/

KEEPERS: Val, TRoss, Amir, Acy, Lowry
GTFOers: BC, Bargs, AA, Casey, Gray, Leo
User avatar
GREY 1769
Analyst
 
Posts: 3437
And1: 88
Joined: Mar 16, 2010

Re: OT - Morey or Colangelo???

Postby Phil A Xiao on Fri Feb 22, 2013 7:09 am

Scraptor wrote:How is this even a debate?

Rockets have a playoff record in the west with the youngest team in the league, a pile of capspace to add more talent, and Morey has never had a losing season.

Raptors are almost the complete opposite: capped out with a bunch of bad contracts, barely any wiggle room to make deals, and no draft pick this year, not to mention we've done this after having how many crappy losing seasons. I mean, we tanked an entire year to draft Terrence Ross. Our starting point guard is going to want a significant raise. And we are paying $21mm to three guys whose roughly 1800 minutes when stretched out over our 55 games works out to about 11 minutes per game from each.

We had a giant opportunity to right this franchise last offseason, and we f**ked the dog, not once, but repeatedly. Lowry and Gay were solid acquisitions, but... what next? Everything really depends on how good Val can get, and how fast.


/Thread

Couldn't have said it better myself.
"One thing about next season, I know for a fact we’ll be in the playoffs. No question. I’ve been saying I hope, but we’re going to make it. We’ve got the talent to do it.
I’m dedicating my summer to that. Period.”
- DeMar DeRozan
User avatar
Phil A Xiao
Junior
 
Posts: 411
And1: 34
Joined: Mar 27, 2012

Re: OT - Morey or Colangelo???

Postby Landomar on Fri Feb 22, 2013 7:19 am

lander wrote:
UssjTrunks wrote:
billy_hoyle wrote:So Morey takes a 6 game over .500 team trades the starting backcourt (Lowry + Martin), drops a solid starting PF (Scola) and turns them into a 6 game over .500 team and he's a genius? Right....


The point is that he acquired an MVP-level franchise player. That should be the goal of every team. This is a star-driven league, and getting that superstar is by far the hardest part of building a contender.


MVP level really? Harden is as good as Durant? Lebron? Rose? Kobe?

Really. Wow.


LeBron is the best player in the NBA. Durant is #2. After that, Harden is playing as well as anyone. He's right up there with Chris Paul, Tony Parker, Dwyane Wade, etc. In fact, I think Harden's numbers this year are better than Rose's were when Rose won the MVP. Keep in mind that Rose did not win that MVP for being the best player in the NBA that year, LeBron still clearly was, even though it was a down year for LeBron...if Harden ever won an MVP, it would probably be a similar "best guy on a team everyone likes" situation. But this season he's put himself up into the top 10 players in the NBA group, and that's basically MVP level to me. Sure, if you threw Harden back onto a team with Durant or LeBron, he'd be a sidekick (like Bosh in Miami), but ANYONE is a sidekick to those guys. We shouldn't knock him for that, Harden's legitimately awesome.
Landomar
Senior
 
Posts: 616
And1: 7
Joined: Jun 15, 2004

Re: OT - Morey or Colangelo???

Postby Fairview4Life on Fri Feb 22, 2013 8:15 am

I like Morey.

On the other hand, he just traded Marcus Morris, the 14th pick from 2 years ago, for a 2nd rounder. He traded a lotto protected 1st round pick for Terrence Williams. He signed Luis Scola to a ~50 million dollar deal just to amnesty him 2 years later. I kind of wonder how we'd all feel about BC doing these things while the team sits in 1st round fodder range for 4-5 years or whatever.

He is good at roster churn, 2nd round picks, and making things happen. His 1st round picks have left a lot to be desired, his free agency signings have been good with Asik, and pretty mediocre for everyone else, and he makes a lot of trades. He is very good at keeping financial flexibility so he can retool whenever he wants without worrying about convincing his owner to pay luxury tax, which is what really distinguishes him from BC (and also not punting 2nd round picks, obviously).
9. Similarly, IF THOU HAST SPENT the entire offseason predicting that thy team will stink, thou shalt not gloat, nor even be happy, shouldst thou turn out to be correct. Realistic analysis is fine, but be a fan first, a smug smarty-pants second.
Fairview4Life
RealGM
 
Posts: 34775
And1: 129
Joined: Jul 25, 2005

Re: OT - Morey or Colangelo???

Postby hillbilly hare on Fri Feb 22, 2013 10:27 am

Fairview4Life wrote:I like Morey.

On the other hand, he just traded Marcus Morris, the 14th pick from 2 years ago, for a 2nd rounder. He traded a lotto protected 1st round pick for Terrence Williams. He signed Luis Scola to a ~50 million dollar deal just to amnesty him 2 years later. I kind of wonder how we'd all feel about BC doing these things while the team sits in 1st round fodder range for 4-5 years or whatever.

He is good at roster churn, 2nd round picks, and making things happen. His 1st round picks have left a lot to be desired, his free agency signings have been good with Asik, and pretty mediocre for everyone else, and he makes a lot of trades. He is very good at keeping financial flexibility so he can retool whenever he wants without worrying about convincing his owner to pay luxury tax, which is what really distinguishes him from BC (and also not punting 2nd round picks, obviously).


You just have to look at the final result of all the moves. Nobody is perfect and nobody ever said Morey was. Mistakes? Definitely. But if it's a mistake to trade Morris in order to make way for Robinson, while also cutting guaranteed salary for next year, then sign me up for those kinds of "mistakes". And forward it to Clownangelo.

The Scola signing was just about right at the time. Amnestying him was undoubtedly tough, but Morey did it for a reason and with a plan in mind. Something Clownangelo rarely has. He cleared cap space and, unlike Colangelo, didn't waste it: he made two extremely creative FA signings with Asik and Lin. You can question Lin over Dragic, but Asik was a fantastic deal. Amnestying Scola also freed up playing time for all their young forwards.

I would add that back when Scola was amnestied I hoped we might take a shot at getting him, as that would've made trading Andrea a bit easier, while taking pressure off Jonas. But our GM was who knows where. We could also draw a parallel to amnestying, say, Andrea last summer, rather than prolonging the long drawn out and painful trade/non-trade embarrassment that the situation has become. I'm sure a lot of us would've been upset, but if our GM then turned around and used that cap space to grab, say, a Harden (looking forward to his max contract) and an Asik (a starting C leading the league in D rebounding) and a Dragic (signing him, rather than dealing a lotto pick for Lowry), then I would've given him his due.

But our GM does nothing of the kind. Or, basically does close to nothing.

As to what Morey has done - and yes, you're only as good as your last rebuild - he has done wonders. Seriously, to suggest otherwise, and to compare the Rockets situation to ours, and to compare him to Colangelo, is ridiculous. They have their All-NBA player and scoring title contender. They have the top D rebounder in the middle and a solid shot-blocker/changer. They have a horde of young prospects and trade assets. They have a ton of cap space next off-season. They are 30-26 in the tougher West, despite a huge roster overhaul. Most of their players are young or very young. They are in a position to move forward with their franchise superstar and add 2 stars next year either thru free agency (20+ in cap space) or trade (several good young prospects).

What do we have in comparison?
User avatar
hillbilly hare
Sixth Man
 
Posts: 1947
And1: 59
Joined: Jan 29, 2011

Re: OT - Morey or Colangelo???

Postby jimmy keys on Fri Feb 22, 2013 10:31 am

The Harden hype is getting out of control. If this guy is the number 1 option on a championship winning team, I'll take you out for a steak dinner.

He's in the 2nd tier of star players putting him anywhere from 8th to 20th. Ignoring the obvious superior players, who would you rather have? Harden or (blank) to build around?

Kyrie? - I'd rather have Kyrie
Curry? - It's debatable IMO, if Curry wasn't an injury risk I'd take Curry hands down.
Love? - A healthy Love takes it easy.
A. Davis? - Still way more potential than Harden.
Wiggins? - I know this is premature, but based on potential alone I'd take Wiggins right now given the choice.
George? - It's closer than you think.

Just to name a few. There are many more guys where you'd have to think hard about. Harden is a 1B/2 kind of guy IMO. Houston needs at least one more player on his level to make any noise in the future.
jimmy keys
Sophomore
 
Posts: 234
And1: 5
Joined: Jan 4, 2009

Re: OT - Morey or Colangelo???

Postby pkiskool on Fri Feb 22, 2013 10:33 am

When Andrew Wiggins rolls into town being the franchise player on another team, and creams us for the L, that's when I quit on this team.
Just imagine that pain.... OTL
Jose > Lowry
Except defense.
User avatar
pkiskool
Pro Prospect
 
Posts: 828
And1: 18
Joined: Oct 13, 2010

Re: OT - Morey or Colangelo???

Postby DatBoiCapspace on Fri Feb 22, 2013 10:49 am

Morey is the better Value finder and asset collector,
BC is the better drafter.
They're both high rollers who prefer to gamble on trades/signings instead of building through the draft like a puss.
Morey has the better market to acquire talent through FA.
BC has owners thatre looser with their wallets.
Morey>BC but BC is not the idiot you all think he is.

/Thread.
DatBoiCapspace
Pro Prospect
 
Posts: 976
And1: 40
Joined: Feb 9, 2013

Re: OT - Morey or Colangelo???

Postby Fairview4Life on Fri Feb 22, 2013 11:09 am

hillbilly hare wrote:They have a horde of young prospects and trade assets.


What young prospects and trade assets do they have, exactly? I like Thomas Robinson, but he's still more potential than actual trade asset at this point, which is why he only managed to get a guy like Patrick Patterson back for him. That's the only real young prospect they have. No one gave a **** about Marcus Morris, and no one gives a **** about Royce White, Terrence Jones, or Donut. What are teams going to trade for those guys? Maybe a late first or 2nd round pick, and nothing for White. Chandler Parsons is excellent value per $, but even he isn't going to net you all that much from another team. No one is trading for Lin.

I'd take Jonas over every single one of those "prospects". Amir is head and shoulders better than all of them, and is only 25. Lowry is better than Lin. Hell, Quincy Acy has shown more in his limited minutes than a guy like Terrence Jones has, but I'm betting you wouldn't consider him to be a part of the Raps "horde" of young prospects.

This is the kind of hyperbole around Morey that I object to. Harden and Asik = fantastic work. The trade and extension for Harden along with signing Asik were bold gambles. Finding Parsons and slotting him in = fantastic work. But they don't have some horde of young prospects that is the envy of the league. They have a bunch of decent young guys that no one else is going to offer much for, but that play hard and work within their system. That isn't a bad thing, but it isn't some cornucopia of riches.
9. Similarly, IF THOU HAST SPENT the entire offseason predicting that thy team will stink, thou shalt not gloat, nor even be happy, shouldst thou turn out to be correct. Realistic analysis is fine, but be a fan first, a smug smarty-pants second.
Fairview4Life
RealGM
 
Posts: 34775
And1: 129
Joined: Jul 25, 2005

Re: OT - Morey or Colangelo???

Postby Rapcity_11 on Fri Feb 22, 2013 11:12 am

jimmy keys wrote:The Harden hype is getting out of control. If this guy is the number 1 option on a championship winning team, I'll take you out for a steak dinner.

He's in the 2nd tier of star players putting him anywhere from 8th to 20th. Ignoring the obvious superior players, who would you rather have? Harden or (blank) to build around?

Kyrie? - I'd rather have Kyrie
Curry? - It's debatable IMO, if Curry wasn't an injury risk I'd take Curry hands down.
Love? - A healthy Love takes it easy.
A. Davis? - Still way more potential than Harden.
Wiggins? - I know this is premature, but based on potential alone I'd take Wiggins right now given the choice.
George? - It's closer than you think.

Just to name a few. There are many more guys where you'd have to think hard about. Harden is a 1B/2 kind of guy IMO. Houston needs at least one more player on his level to make any noise in the future.


Laughable.

Harden is in the 2nd tier, and likely near the top of it. (First being only LBJ and KD)

In his first year as a #1 option, without a Rockets training camp the guy is putting up 26.5/4.8/5.7 on 60.7 TS%, while leading the Rockets on a 44 win pace. Everybody thought the team was going to be in the lottery. They've got the #4 offense in the league as well. AND he's still developing his offensive game.

There is a very, very good chance Wiggins is never as good as Harden is right now.
User avatar
Rapcity_11
Head Coach
 
Posts: 6922
And1: 29
Joined: Jul 26, 2006

Re: OT - Morey or Colangelo???

Postby Rapcity_11 on Fri Feb 22, 2013 11:14 am

Fairview4Life wrote:I like Morey.

On the other hand, he just traded Marcus Morris, the 14th pick from 2 years ago, for a 2nd rounder.


Max cap space, that's why. It's way more valuable for them to have that than Morris. You can't look at moves only in a vacuum.

His 1st round drafting has been solid as well.

Should add that you don't seem to be appreciating how valuable cap-space is for a popular destination like Houston. They also have NO bad contracts. None.
User avatar
Rapcity_11
Head Coach
 
Posts: 6922
And1: 29
Joined: Jul 26, 2006

PreviousNext

Return to Toronto Raptors

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: [SJJ], Aimless Outlook, Consequence, DG88, Dr Octagon, DreamTeam09, Dri3er, Edwardo, elmer_yuck, Garmfay, gerrit4, ghuytro, hankscorpioLA, hsb, IMAN5, Imenutz, Jays343, Joker, LascelleL, marcroboy, monkey, Nothingface, pspot, rapaholic, rapluva, RNsteve, sanity, sauga_raptor, Southward1, Steve Urkel, SuperSant, tarheel06, timdunkit, TorontoRapture, trick, Trilogy, UN-Owen, whysoserious, Wo1verine, Y0DA, youngRAPZ, Zeno