sipclip wrote:Johnstarks wrote: #1 bench seems kinda absurd. Lyles isn't there yet and exum and burcs are both question marks
I'm not sure why you would think that is absurd. Mack is one of the best backup pg's in the league. Burks is one of the best backups sg's. Johnson of the best backup sf's. Lyles while not a finished product is definitely a solid stretch 4. Diaw is a great backup big and Withey is one of the better backup centers in the league. That isn't even mentioning Exum who could be really good. Who do you think has a better bench?
Mack was arguably the worst player in the entire nba prior to the jazz trade so I'm gonna need more than 25 games before I rank him as the best backup pg in the league. Statistically he was ranked dead last according to a few metrics.
Ido like exam and Burks to register as net positive players first before I crown the jazz best bench in the league. It's definitely got a lot of potential but a little early to anoint best bench.
Now, when evaluating benches I think my parameters are a little different than that articles. I'm not lining them up to play 5 on 5 vs the MONSTARS. I'm thinking how does this bench fill roles in a playoff series when minutes are scarce and efficient production is at a premium.
You want a well rounded bench that complements your roster and adequately fills in for a suspension, injury, foul trouble, off performance, or optimizes a lineup vs a specific opponent or matchup.
So I don't care as much about 10th man vs 10th man since 90% of your bench production will come down to your 6th thru 8th man in the playoffs when rotations shorten. That's where teams like the Pistons have it wrong they went all pokemon and tried to collect them all instead of landing 1-2 great bench players.
I'd like to see a bench that addresses the following in order of importance:
1) a guy who can handle playmaking and initiate offense when the lead guard sits
2) big man who can handle smaller lineups and moves well enough laterally to defend the pnr
3) 3pt shooters
4) defensive stoppers
5) scorers
#1 is the most important which is why you see guys like ginobili, harden, and to a lesser extent iggy sent to the bench so they can essentially function as a backup pg by running the offense when the lead guard sits. You don't want to go through a cold stretch in the dead zone near end 1q/3q and beginning of 2q/4q.
#2 is important because you don't want a traditional big man who comes in and compromises your defense immediately. Look at how a guy like kanter can swing a series when he comes in and immediately gives up a barrage of open 3 pointers.
#3) 3 pt shooting should be obvious you want guys who can space the floor effectively so you can let your best offensively talent run the show while other starters rest.
#4) It's nice to have the option to throw a one dimensional defender in there to change up looks if an opponent is hot or at the end of quarters and buy minutes for your starters
#5) Scoring should typically be the least important as they just aren't dependable enough and often can't get their shots vs the increased defensive focus in the playoffs
It's a little hard to evaluate benches this early since so many of them got raided but just as an example I'd rather have gsw bench with iggy, livingston, west on it than the entire collection of scrubs Detroit put together. I think denver bench is pretty loaded. I really like simmons/anderson to break out in sas this year. Portland has a pretty deep bench of nba talent. Utah certainly has potential. 76ers could be the best bench in the league depending on how nba ready everyone is. Celtics have a great regu large season lineup bench but I'm not sure it's a playoff bench.
Ultimately, id probably take portland or golden state for proven But I bet sas ends up in the top 3 I'm pretty high on anderson and simmons this year they look ready to breakout as stars