I've seen a fair amount of Hill bashing in the game threads lately, so I am going to try to offset it a little by reviving this thread.
The guy is not an All Star, but he is still a very good fit for this team and the best PG we have seen here in a long time. With 10 games left to go in the season, Hill is hanging on to the number 5 spot for PGs on real plus minus and the number 14 spot on PER. Does he occasionally get lit up by younger, quicker point guards? Yes. Does he occasionally have games where he is a no show? Yes. But overall the guy is pretty darn good, pretty darn productive and is a very savvy, veteran player.
I don't want to max Hill due to his age, his seeming nagging injury problems and his average career stats, but I still would really like to re-sign the guy. There is still a chance that teams with money who are not close to sniffing the playoffs may balk on maxing Hill for the reason that he could be over the hill by the time they are ready to make some noise in the playoffs. And all the current, contending playoff teams arguably already have as good or better point guards except for the Spurs and Bucks. I am not sure what those teams' salary situation and top needs are (Tony Parker is signed for another season), but it seems to me that there is still a decent chance that the Jazz can make the most attractive, winning offer for Hill at something quite a bit below max. Go Jazz!