Western All Stars vs Eastern All Stars - All Time Matchup

lukekarts · Post #1 » by **lukekarts** » Tue Nov 8, 2011 3:24 pm

West Coast All Stars

Magic Johnson / Steve Nash
Kobe Bryant / Jerry West
Elgin Baylor / Kevin Garnett
Tim Duncan / Karl Malone
Kareem Abdul-Jabbar / Shaquille O'Neal

East Coast All Stars

Oscar Robertson / Walt Frazier
Michael Jordan / Dwyane Wade
Julius Erving / Scottie Pippen
Larry Bird / Charles Barkley
Bill Russell / Moses Malone

Note: teams decided using the Top 100 Project List. Where players were debatable selections for each side, I picked based on appearances in each conference (e.g. Charles Barkley, 1073 games total, 610 in Philly = East).

Who wins?

215paperboy · Post #2 » by **215paperboy** » Tue Nov 8, 2011 3:36 pm

wilt > russell and malone
and why no iverson ?

mademan · Post #3 » by **mademan** » Tue Nov 8, 2011 5:23 pm

The backcourts are comparable, and can be argued either way. But West destroys the East in the frontcourt.

Zasterror · Post #4 » by **Zasterror** » Tue Nov 8, 2011 6:04 pm

The West's big men overtakes the East easily but the backcourt of MJ/Oscar/Wade/Dr. J are too much for the West to match. A wash

mademan · Post #5 » by **mademan** » Tue Nov 8, 2011 6:24 pm

Zasterror wrote:The West's big men overtakes the East easily but the backcourt of MJ/Oscar/Wade/Dr. J are too much for the West to match. A wash

Magic/Kobe/West are no scrubs. And it's arguable they're better than the East guards.

ThunderDan9 · Post #6 » by **ThunderDan9** » Tue Nov 8, 2011 8:18 pm

I don't know, I like the East. Not that they are better, but they would be a fantastic team to cheer for. What an intriguing starting 5! It would be fun to watch.

MarJJMar · Post #7 » by **MarJJMar** » Tue Nov 8, 2011 9:49 pm

Zasterror wrote:The West's big men overtakes the East easily but the backcourt of MJ/Oscar/Wade/Dr. J are too much for the West to match. A wash

Magic> Oscar
Nash> Frazier
Kobe< Jordan
West> Wade

MVPS
Magic 3, Nash 2, Kobe 1, West 0
Jordan 5, Oscar 1, Frazier 0, Wade 0

I will take the Western Conference backcourt.

That Nicka · Post #8 » by **That Nicka** » Tue Nov 8, 2011 11:30 pm

JustCame · Post #9 » by **JustCame** » Wed Nov 9, 2011 12:25 am

MarJJMar wrote:
Zasterror wrote:The West's big men overtakes the East easily but the backcourt of MJ/Oscar/Wade/Dr. J are too much for the West to match. A wash

Magic> Oscar
Nash> Frazier
Kobe< Jordan
West> Wade

MVPS
Magic 3, Nash 2, Kobe 1, West 0
Jordan 5, Oscar 1, Frazier 0, Wade 0

I will take the Western Conference backcourt.

MVPs mean NOTHING. >_<

Darain · Post #10 » by **Darain** » Wed Nov 9, 2011 3:01 am

JustCame wrote:
MarJJMar wrote:
Zasterror wrote:The West's big men overtakes the East easily but the backcourt of MJ/Oscar/Wade/Dr. J are too much for the West to match. A wash

Magic> Oscar
Nash> Frazier
Kobe< Jordan
West> Wade

MVPS
Magic 3, Nash 2, Kobe 1, West 0
Jordan 5, Oscar 1, Frazier 0, Wade 0

I will take the Western Conference backcourt.

MVPs mean NOTHING. >_<

FMVP
Magic 3, Nash 0, Kobe 2, West 1
Jordan 6, Oscar 0, Frazier 0, Wade 1

Advantage West