Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever.

Moderators: tsherkin, nate33, Doctor MJ, penbeast0, rrravenred

User avatar
Kobe2ndFiddle
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,545
And1: 1
Joined: Oct 18, 2011

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#16 » by Kobe2ndFiddle » Sun Mar 11, 2012 7:20 pm

PippenAintEasy wrote:
Kobe2ndFiddle wrote:McHale
Barkely
Malone
Garnett
Duncan (yes he's a PF)


so which one of these guys is Dirk better than ? I'll wait all day.

Mchale easily. Barkley maybe. Malone, probably not.

is this a joke ?

I am now starting to realize that any superstar who wins a championship in this era will become GREATLY overrated. Even my favorite player has fallen victim to the media and fans overrating him to high heavens.


This bullshh has to stop immediately, Dirk is not better than ANYONE I listed, at all.
User avatar
Bertrob
RealGM
Posts: 20,504
And1: 1,492
Joined: Sep 08, 2011
Location: Free Clinic
 

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#17 » by Bertrob » Sun Mar 11, 2012 7:20 pm

richboy wrote:He probably just forgot KG. I would say that Dirk is in the conversation. He has a strong case to be pretty much equal to KG in his career. Many people have KG as the second best PF ever. I would take Dirk over Malone. IMO Karl Malone the most un clutch player in league history maybe. I might take him over Barkley as well.


:o Does him not being clutch, a term that is subject to anyone's interpretation, cancel out his massive career achievements?
User avatar
Chocobanana
Lead Assistant
Posts: 4,733
And1: 210
Joined: Dec 16, 2011
 

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#18 » by Chocobanana » Sun Mar 11, 2012 7:23 pm

so he had
1)bird
2)duncan
3)Havlicek
4)Baylor
5)Erving
6)Pettit
7)Malone
8)Barkley
9)Nowitzki
and has dirk just jumping the last 3. if he leadfrogs 3 more, doesnt that put him at 3rd best?
User avatar
Jeff23
Lead Assistant
Posts: 4,961
And1: 225
Joined: Apr 14, 2010

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#19 » by Jeff23 » Sun Mar 11, 2012 7:23 pm

5DOM wrote:
Kobe2ndFiddle wrote:McHale
Barkely
Malone
Garnett
Duncan (yes he's a PF)


so which one of these guys is Dirk better than ? I'll wait all day.


McHale?


Agreed.

There is just no way Dirk is better than KG, Barkley or Malone.
User avatar
Kobe2ndFiddle
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,545
And1: 1
Joined: Oct 18, 2011

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#20 » by Kobe2ndFiddle » Sun Mar 11, 2012 7:24 pm

the fact that Dirk was referred to as a "bust" early on in his career should disqualify him from even being mentioned in the top 3.
User avatar
Sedale Threatt
RealGM
Posts: 23,234
And1: 1,559
Joined: Feb 06, 2007
Location: Clearing space in the trophy case.

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#21 » by Sedale Threatt » Sun Mar 11, 2012 7:26 pm

Kobe2ndFiddle wrote:the fact that Dirk was referred to as a "bust" early on in his career should disqualify him from even being mentioned in the top 3.


What difference does that make? He's been an elite player for 12 years now.
JF5 wrote:Real fans don't cry about refs.


http://wtfismikewearing.tumblr.com/
User avatar
Chosen01
RealGM
Posts: 17,098
And1: 531
Joined: May 08, 2009

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#22 » by Chosen01 » Sun Mar 11, 2012 7:28 pm

Doctor MJ wrote:In other words, Simmons doesn't really think like a logical, rational analyst...which we already knew. He's still funny.
richboy
RealGM
Posts: 23,980
And1: 876
Joined: Sep 01, 2003

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#23 » by richboy » Sun Mar 11, 2012 7:28 pm

PippenAintEasy wrote:
Kobe2ndFiddle wrote:McHale
Barkely
Malone
Garnett
Duncan (yes he's a PF)


so which one of these guys is Dirk better than ? I'll wait all day.

Mchale easily. Barkley maybe. Malone, probably not.


Can't put Mchale. He doesn't pass at all. He the greatest post player in league history. I'm not sure that is good enough to get him the number 2 spot.
"Talent is God-given. Be humble. Fame is man-given. Be grateful. Conceit is self-given. Be careful." John Wooden
Blame Rasho
Global Mod
Global Mod
Posts: 36,383
And1: 3,299
Joined: Apr 25, 2002

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#24 » by Blame Rasho » Sun Mar 11, 2012 7:28 pm

Sedale Threatt wrote:
Kobe2ndFiddle wrote:the fact that Dirk was referred to as a "bust" early on in his career should disqualify him from even being mentioned in the top 3.


What difference does that make?


I know...

Kobe was air balling threes vs the Jazz as a 19/20 year old... that thus eliminates him from greatness discussion using your logic.

I don't agree with Simmons, but his logic is just as bad if not worse than him. At least Simmons is at least articulate in his points instead of the hey look at me and what I say.
It is illogical to use logic on an illogical person.
Solution...use even more illogical logic to trump their logic.
Things I have learned on the general board this week
The Spurs are semi tanking and aren't interesting in repeating.
User avatar
Kobe2ndFiddle
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,545
And1: 1
Joined: Oct 18, 2011

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#25 » by Kobe2ndFiddle » Sun Mar 11, 2012 7:30 pm

Sedale Threatt wrote:
Kobe2ndFiddle wrote:the fact that Dirk was referred to as a "bust" early on in his career should disqualify him from even being mentioned in the top 3.


What difference does that make? He's been an elite player for 12 years now.

Garnett has been elite since 99', has a championship like Dirk, an MVP like Dirk plus a DPOY.

The only case you can make for Dirk over Garnett is FMVP. Dirk is not a top 2 PF, no way in hell.
User avatar
Sedale Threatt
RealGM
Posts: 23,234
And1: 1,559
Joined: Feb 06, 2007
Location: Clearing space in the trophy case.

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#26 » by Sedale Threatt » Sun Mar 11, 2012 7:34 pm

Kobe2ndFiddle wrote:Garnett has been elite since 99', has a championship like Dirk, an MVP like Dirk plus a DPOY.

The only case you can make for Dirk over Garnett is FMVP. Dirk is not a top 2 PF, no way in hell.


I'm not trying to make a case for him over Garnett. Duncan (who I consider a center), Malone and very probably Barkley either. But McHale? He was not on Dirk's level, especially when longevity is taken into account.

Besides, I want to hear the logic of why Dirk, because he struggled as a 20-year-old rookie playing in a foreign country, should be automatically excluded from the discussion.
JF5 wrote:Real fans don't cry about refs.


http://wtfismikewearing.tumblr.com/
Balki-B
Sophomore
Posts: 176
And1: 11
Joined: Nov 29, 2010

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#27 » by Balki-B » Sun Mar 11, 2012 7:35 pm

Kobe2ndFiddle wrote:McHale
Barkely
Malone
Garnett
Duncan (yes he's a PF)


so which one of these guys is Dirk better than ? I'll wait all day.


Although Barkely and Malone are statistically in the discussion, they are also both automatically disqualified because they've never won a ring. You can argue the absurdity of this, but in comparing players you have to look at distinguishing categories like championship rings to further separate the best of the best. This leaves us with:

McHale
Garnett
Duncan
Nowitzki

McHale has multiple championship rings, but at the very best was second banana to Bird. Garnett, although dominate for years statistically, will never be regarded as the leader of the championship Celtics. Dirk was alpha on his club, has had years of 50 win seasons in Dallas and has played in 2 finals with one finals MVP to boot. Ba-da-bing, ba-da-boom, that's how you get to Diggler at number 2.
User avatar
dyukcs
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,076
And1: 478
Joined: Jun 20, 2010

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#28 » by dyukcs » Sun Mar 11, 2012 7:36 pm

Simmons has made his case for this elsewhere, he's not saying Dirk is now the 2nd best PF, but that Dirk will probably produce at this level for a few years and career wise will be in the mix. Dirk has been the best playoff performer out of Barkley, Malone, and KG (not just counting the championship run), is the most efficient scorer of the bunch, and seems like he'll beat Barkley and KG for longevity. Obviously you can make cases for each of those guys over Dirk, but it's not so ridiculous.
richboy
RealGM
Posts: 23,980
And1: 876
Joined: Sep 01, 2003

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#29 » by richboy » Sun Mar 11, 2012 7:37 pm

bertrob wrote:
richboy wrote:He probably just forgot KG. I would say that Dirk is in the conversation. He has a strong case to be pretty much equal to KG in his career. Many people have KG as the second best PF ever. I would take Dirk over Malone. IMO Karl Malone the most un clutch player in league history maybe. I might take him over Barkley as well.


:o Does him not being clutch, a term that is subject to anyone's interpretation, cancel out his massive career achievements?


Karl Malone to me is one of the most overrated players in league history. Him being not clutch is just the icing on the cake of what is a career of overrated play. People have a tendency to forget history. The Utah Jazz were often a first round and out playoff team because of Malone. So for me this isn't close. Karl Malone is a great player who had a really long prime. Dirk is one of the most difficult covers in league history. When he is going I have no clue who can guard him. Karl Malone is a better version of Amare.
"Talent is God-given. Be humble. Fame is man-given. Be grateful. Conceit is self-given. Be careful." John Wooden
User avatar
Kobe2ndFiddle
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,545
And1: 1
Joined: Oct 18, 2011

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#30 » by Kobe2ndFiddle » Sun Mar 11, 2012 7:37 pm

Sedale Threatt wrote:
Kobe2ndFiddle wrote:Garnett has been elite since 99', has a championship like Dirk, an MVP like Dirk plus a DPOY.

The only case you can make for Dirk over Garnett is FMVP. Dirk is not a top 2 PF, no way in hell.


I'm not trying to make a case for him over Garnett. Duncan (who I consider a center), Malone and very probably Barkley either. But McHale? He was not on Dirk's level, especially when longevity is taken into account.

Besides, I want to hear the logic of why Dirk, because he struggled as a 20-year-old rookie playing in a foreign country, should be automatically excluded from the discussion.

The post were I mentioned his "bust" monicker, was just an overzealous remark by me, I'm in disbelief by Simmons comment still lol.

but as long as we can agree that Dirk is not top 2 then that is fine.
User avatar
JordansBulls
RealGM
Posts: 48,436
And1: 1,290
Joined: Jul 12, 2006
Location: HCA (Homecourt Advantage)

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#31 » by JordansBulls » Sun Mar 11, 2012 7:38 pm

Doctor MJ wrote:In other words, Simmons doesn't really think like a logical, rational analyst...which we already knew. He's still funny.

What do you mean? Have you read his book at all?
Image
"Talent wins games, but teamwork and intelligence wins championships."
- Michael Jordan
Tubal
Rookie
Posts: 1,055
And1: 37
Joined: Apr 12, 2011

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#32 » by Tubal » Sun Mar 11, 2012 7:43 pm

i.e.

"Gee, Grantland sucks and readership is really falling. I better write something controversial so some of the forums pick it up and I get more hits".
Doctor MJ
Senior Mod
Senior Mod
Posts: 33,835
And1: 3,500
Joined: Mar 10, 2005
Location: Treys are for Kicks!
     

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#33 » by Doctor MJ » Sun Mar 11, 2012 7:44 pm

JordansBulls wrote:
Doctor MJ wrote:In other words, Simmons doesn't really think like a logical, rational analyst...which we already knew. He's still funny.


What do you mean? Have you read his book at all?


I mean that he tends to think top down too much. One end result that could have happened differently through no fault of the player in question causes massive changes in how he ranks a player. That's ridiculous. Any player comparison that doesn't seek to disentangle the performance of a player from that of the rest of his team is simply doing it wrong. It's essentially taking the real rankings and then throwing dice to mix them up.
richboy
RealGM
Posts: 23,980
And1: 876
Joined: Sep 01, 2003

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#34 » by richboy » Sun Mar 11, 2012 7:45 pm

Doctor MJ wrote:In other words, Simmons doesn't really think like a logical, rational analyst...which we already knew. He's still funny.


Actually I think Simmons historical knowledge of basketball is really impressive. Of course KG fans hate Bill Simmons. Mainly because he said that 20 years from now stat guys are going to try to convince that KG was better than Duncan. He was wrong because they have already started. When in reality KG may not have been better than Dirk. The idea of Dirk going down as second best is not crazy. Especially if he plays another 5 good years and found a way to get another title. Even 1 more trip to the finals.
"Talent is God-given. Be humble. Fame is man-given. Be grateful. Conceit is self-given. Be careful." John Wooden
RichardsRival3
Banned User
Posts: 7,263
And1: 1
Joined: Feb 23, 2010

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#35 » by RichardsRival3 » Sun Mar 11, 2012 7:45 pm

JordansBulls wrote:
Doctor MJ wrote:In other words, Simmons doesn't really think like a logical, rational analyst...which we already knew. He's still funny.

What do you mean? Have you read his book at all?


I think he means, if it can't be found in a box score, then it isn't logical or rational.

Return to Player Comparisons