Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever.

Moderators: tsherkin, nate33, Doctor MJ, penbeast0, rrravenred

User avatar
JordansBulls
RealGM
Posts: 49,117
And1: 1,399
Joined: Jul 12, 2006
Location: HCA (Homecourt Advantage)

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#31 » by JordansBulls » Sun Mar 11, 2012 7:38 pm

Doctor MJ wrote:In other words, Simmons doesn't really think like a logical, rational analyst...which we already knew. He's still funny.

What do you mean? Have you read his book at all?
Image
"Talent wins games, but teamwork and intelligence wins championships."
- Michael Jordan
Tubal
Rookie
Posts: 1,055
And1: 37
Joined: Apr 12, 2011

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#32 » by Tubal » Sun Mar 11, 2012 7:43 pm

i.e.

"Gee, Grantland sucks and readership is really falling. I better write something controversial so some of the forums pick it up and I get more hits".
Doctor MJ
Senior Mod
Senior Mod
Posts: 34,370
And1: 3,786
Joined: Mar 10, 2005
Location: Treys are for Kicks!
     

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#33 » by Doctor MJ » Sun Mar 11, 2012 7:44 pm

JordansBulls wrote:
Doctor MJ wrote:In other words, Simmons doesn't really think like a logical, rational analyst...which we already knew. He's still funny.


What do you mean? Have you read his book at all?


I mean that he tends to think top down too much. One end result that could have happened differently through no fault of the player in question causes massive changes in how he ranks a player. That's ridiculous. Any player comparison that doesn't seek to disentangle the performance of a player from that of the rest of his team is simply doing it wrong. It's essentially taking the real rankings and then throwing dice to mix them up.
richboy
RealGM
Posts: 24,094
And1: 953
Joined: Sep 01, 2003

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#34 » by richboy » Sun Mar 11, 2012 7:45 pm

Doctor MJ wrote:In other words, Simmons doesn't really think like a logical, rational analyst...which we already knew. He's still funny.


Actually I think Simmons historical knowledge of basketball is really impressive. Of course KG fans hate Bill Simmons. Mainly because he said that 20 years from now stat guys are going to try to convince that KG was better than Duncan. He was wrong because they have already started. When in reality KG may not have been better than Dirk. The idea of Dirk going down as second best is not crazy. Especially if he plays another 5 good years and found a way to get another title. Even 1 more trip to the finals.
"Talent is God-given. Be humble. Fame is man-given. Be grateful. Conceit is self-given. Be careful." John Wooden
RichardsRival3
Banned User
Posts: 7,263
And1: 1
Joined: Feb 23, 2010

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#35 » by RichardsRival3 » Sun Mar 11, 2012 7:45 pm

JordansBulls wrote:
Doctor MJ wrote:In other words, Simmons doesn't really think like a logical, rational analyst...which we already knew. He's still funny.

What do you mean? Have you read his book at all?


I think he means, if it can't be found in a box score, then it isn't logical or rational.
Doctor MJ
Senior Mod
Senior Mod
Posts: 34,370
And1: 3,786
Joined: Mar 10, 2005
Location: Treys are for Kicks!
     

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#36 » by Doctor MJ » Sun Mar 11, 2012 7:46 pm

Tubal wrote:i.e.

"Gee, Grantland sucks and readership is really falling. I better write something controversial so some of the forums pick it up and I get more hits".


meh, site traffic shows no glaring signs off continual falloff, and Simmons has done an excellent job of hiring a talented team of writers. I mean heck, he's got Sebastian Pruiti working for him, and Pruiti knows 100x as much basketball as he does.

This is just the stuff Simmons writes from time to time.
Doctor MJ
Senior Mod
Senior Mod
Posts: 34,370
And1: 3,786
Joined: Mar 10, 2005
Location: Treys are for Kicks!
     

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#37 » by Doctor MJ » Sun Mar 11, 2012 7:47 pm

RichardsRival3 wrote:
JordansBulls wrote:
Doctor MJ wrote:In other words, Simmons doesn't really think like a logical, rational analyst...which we already knew. He's still funny.

What do you mean? Have you read his book at all?


I think he means, if it can't be found in a box score, then it isn't logical or rational.


You think poorly then.
C-izMe
Banned User
Posts: 6,689
And1: 15
Joined: Dec 11, 2011
Location: Rodman's Rainbow Obamaburger

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#38 » by C-izMe » Sun Mar 11, 2012 7:48 pm

Top Two
Duncan
Garnett
------------
Next could be in any order these guys:
Malone
Mchale (argument for second greatest if he wasn't injury prone)
Dirk
Barkley

I personally have them ranked
Malone
Dirk
Mchale
Chuck
User avatar
DuckIII
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 49,258
And1: 7,633
Joined: Nov 25, 2003
Location: On my high horse.
     

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#39 » by DuckIII » Sun Mar 11, 2012 7:49 pm

If you are going to say Bird is a 4, then Duncan and Bird are clearly 1 and 2.

After that, the rankings get highly debatable. I wouldn't have Dirk 3rd, but I can't say it would be ridiculous to put him there.

P.S. I'd have Garnett over all of those guys except Bird and Duncan. And he wasn't even on Simmons' list. Which further illustrates the point about how tight it is with power forwards.
RichardsRival3
Banned User
Posts: 7,263
And1: 1
Joined: Feb 23, 2010

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#40 » by RichardsRival3 » Sun Mar 11, 2012 7:50 pm

Doctor MJ wrote:
RichardsRival3 wrote:
JordansBulls wrote:What do you mean? Have you read his book at all?


I think he means, if it can't be found in a box score, then it isn't logical or rational.


You think poorly then.


Yea, you think Deng is the Bulls' MVP, and I am the one who thinks poorly? LMAO.
mysticbb
Banned User
Posts: 8,205
And1: 698
Joined: May 28, 2007
Contact:
   

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#41 » by mysticbb » Sun Mar 11, 2012 7:51 pm

Balki-B wrote:Although Barkely and Malone are statistically in the discussion, they are also both automatically disqualified because they've never won a ring.


Swap Malone or Barkley with McHale. Do you think the Celtics would have won even one championship less with either Karl Malone or Charles Barkley instead of McHale on the team? I would argue that they would have been improved with such a move. And that's what should be evaluated when we are talking about players, not some rings someone won, because the circumstances were good for him. Brian Cardinal did not become a better player, only because he now has won a championship. Neither did Dirk Nowitzki or Jason Kidd.

Karl Malone played great basketball, had a huge impact even really late in his career. Charles Barkley was probably the best offensive power forward ever, that should count for something. Look at how they played basketball and how much of an impact the individual players had on that, not at championships won.

Imagine Nowitzki suffers more than just a minor injury to his finger in the first game of the finals last year, imagine he had suffered a broken wrist and would have been out. No championship for the Mavericks. What would be the argument here? Would Nowitzki now be a worse player? The logic behind the "ring argument" is completely absurd, given the fact that it is influenced by circumstances a lot. Putting someone like McHale ahead of Barkley or Malone, because McHale won some rings as a 2nd/3rd fiddle is just wrong.
User avatar
mihail_petkov
Sophomore
Posts: 202
And1: 121
Joined: Jun 23, 2011

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#42 » by mihail_petkov » Sun Mar 11, 2012 8:05 pm

Dirk is too overrated after the championship.
User avatar
Therapist
Sophomore
Posts: 116
And1: 0
Joined: Mar 08, 2012

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#43 » by Therapist » Sun Mar 11, 2012 8:06 pm

mihail_petkov wrote:Dirk is too overrated after the championship.


Dirk was too underrated before his championship.
User avatar
Kobe2ndFiddle
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,545
And1: 1
Joined: Oct 18, 2011

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#44 » by Kobe2ndFiddle » Sun Mar 11, 2012 8:08 pm

Therapist wrote:
mihail_petkov wrote:Dirk is too overrated after the championship.


Dirk was too underrated before his championship.

MVP voting says you're wrong.
User avatar
Therapist
Sophomore
Posts: 116
And1: 0
Joined: Mar 08, 2012

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#45 » by Therapist » Sun Mar 11, 2012 8:09 pm

Kobe2ndFiddle wrote:
Therapist wrote:
mihail_petkov wrote:Dirk is too overrated after the championship.


Dirk was too underrated before his championship.

MVP voting says you're wrong.


Come on now.. You're gonna sit there and have Kobe in your username and use MVP voting as a metric to measure someone's abilities?
richboy
RealGM
Posts: 24,094
And1: 953
Joined: Sep 01, 2003

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#46 » by richboy » Sun Mar 11, 2012 8:13 pm

mysticbb wrote:
Balki-B wrote:Although Barkely and Malone are statistically in the discussion, they are also both automatically disqualified because they've never won a ring.


Swap Malone or Barkley with McHale. Do you think the Celtics would have won even one championship less with either Karl Malone or Charles Barkley instead of McHale on the team? I would argue that they would have been improved with such a move. And that's what should be evaluated when we are talking about players, not some rings someone won, because the circumstances were good for him. Brian Cardinal did not become a better player, only because he now has won a championship. Neither did Dirk Nowitzki or Jason Kidd.

Karl Malone played great basketball, had a huge impact even really late in his career. Charles Barkley was probably the best offensive power forward ever, that should count for something. Look at how they played basketball and how much of an impact the individual players had on that, not at championships won.

Imagine Nowitzki suffers more than just a minor injury to his finger in the first game of the finals last year, imagine he had suffered a broken wrist and would have been out. No championship for the Mavericks. What would be the argument here? Would Nowitzki now be a worse player? The logic behind the "ring argument" is completely absurd, given the fact that it is influenced by circumstances a lot. Putting someone like McHale ahead of Barkley or Malone, because McHale won some rings as a 2nd/3rd fiddle is just wrong.



Who is Malone running PNR with on the Celtics. Lets not ignore the fact Malone was being fed by one of the greatest point guards in league history. Are the Celtics going to run 50 PNR with Malone when they have Bird and Parish as well.

Just to note if you ask Charles Barkley he would say Kevin Mchale is better than him and Karl Malone.
"Talent is God-given. Be humble. Fame is man-given. Be grateful. Conceit is self-given. Be careful." John Wooden
User avatar
narmerguy
Lead Assistant
Posts: 4,860
And1: 1,948
Joined: Dec 27, 2010

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#47 » by narmerguy » Sun Mar 11, 2012 8:19 pm

Gosh everyone is on Dirk's nuts after he wins one championship. Suddenly his fadeaway is God's gift to basketball but he's had that shot for years and somehow teams seemed just fine beating him. The dude had a good run, I agree, awesome job, phenomenal player.

Better than Duncan? Wtf. Better than KG? Let's consider offense and defense here. Dirk has been historically great on only one side of the ball. But whatever, I know in three years no one will be mentioning Dirk in this conversation because everyone's going to be on to whoever else the last championship winner was.
Image
User avatar
dice
RealGM
Posts: 22,428
And1: 4,303
Joined: Jun 30, 2003
Location: chicago

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#48 » by dice » Sun Mar 11, 2012 8:21 pm

Therapist wrote:
Kobe2ndFiddle wrote:
Therapist wrote:Dirk was too underrated before his championship.

MVP voting says you're wrong.


Come on now.. You're gonna sit there and have Kobe in your username and use MVP voting as a metric to measure someone's abilities?

he's not suggesting the MVP votes are an indicator of ability. he's saying that MVP votes are a measure of media respect. and by that criteria, dirk was not underrated before winning a title

dirk has been elite or near-elite offensively and poor in all other areas of the game
barkley was even better offensively and an excellent rebounder
malone was also better offensively, a strong rebounder and good defensively, playing at an all-star level 'till age THIRTY-SEVEN

dirk's ring does not bridge the gap between him and barkley, let alone him and malone. and the fact that dirk coasted early in the season after winning a ring does not lead me to believe he's ever gonna get there

malone
barkley
dirk
http://www.kiva.org
better than charity
User avatar
Therapist
Sophomore
Posts: 116
And1: 0
Joined: Mar 08, 2012

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#49 » by Therapist » Sun Mar 11, 2012 8:23 pm

dice wrote:he's not suggesting the MVP votes are an indicator of ability. he's saying that MVP votes are a measure of media respect. and by that criteria, dirk was not underrated before winning a title

dirk has been elite offensively and poor in all other areas of the game


I can't say that Dirk isn't poor in all other areas of the game but he won the MVP award because he was the best player on the best team. I just didn't know that anyone really puts much thought into it (the voters) as to who gets the award. So I guess I don't consider it as a measure of media respect moreso as a here's your reward for having the best record.
Tubal
Rookie
Posts: 1,055
And1: 37
Joined: Apr 12, 2011

Re: Bill Simmons now ranks Dirk the 2nd greatest PF ever. 

Post#50 » by Tubal » Sun Mar 11, 2012 8:23 pm

1. Malone
2. Barkley
3. Duncan (gets extra points for 4 rings)
4. KG
5. Dirk

I think Duncan gets overrated because he lead some talented Spurs teams. He's a career 20/11 guy.

Return to Player Comparisons