Valid wrote:sully00 wrote:Valid wrote:Except Iguodala is an elite defender and Turner is...not.
Sorry, but I can't get down with the Turner/Iguodala comparison at all. Iguodala has great value as a defensive stopper alone, and his perimeter jumper is at least bearable. Sure, the book on Iguodala is that he can't shoot, but he has a career TS% of 55.1 percent. Turner's is 48.5 percent.
I personally think some of the excuses being made for Turner are ridiculous.
"He was on a bad team."
"He was in a bad system."
"He was in a bad locker room."
"He was playing with someone who had the same skillset."
The fact of the matter is that if Turner were any good in his first four seasons, none of that should have mattered. Would it have hindered his performance a bit? Sure, but not enough to post the kinds of paltry efficiency numbers he did, and as far as I'm concerned, the system and Iguodala should have had no ill effects on his defense at all. As a matter of fact, Iggy's presence should have helped him defensively.
I'm really rooting for the dude because he has an incredible and heartbreaking life story, but I'm just calling it how I see it. He has not been a good NBA player thus far in his career regardless of all of the extenuating circumstances everyone keeps coming up with here to excuse his poor production.
Iguodala an elite defender now? Explain his game now. For real this conversation is a clown show. Iggy goes to two other teams and is a statistical joke but that doesn't matter Turner had to be better then him in a crap role. How is Iggy a good player now if Turner has never been a good player? It isn't that the guy is Lebron or anything but the fact that it hasn't come easy means he is crap I am sorry that means we need to look in mirror pretty hard about the other guys on the roster.
Sorry, but when hasn't Iguodala been an elite defender? I mean, are you serious with this?
And Iguodala has been a statistical joke? Really? Do you even look at stats before you post stuff like this?
Iggy had a TS% of 57 percent and an eFG% of 54.8 percent last season. He even shot a respectable 35.4 percent from three while shooting a solid 48 percent from the floor.
Defensively, teams averaged 99 points per 100 possessions with Iguodala on the court and 106 with him off the court.
I'm not even a huge Iguodala fan (never have been), but let's call a spade a spade here.
I also don't know why you keep bringing up "other guys on the roster" because that has nothing to do with Turner as an individual player, but if you want to go that route, fine. Jared Sullinger is entering his third year and could make a big leap at the age of 22. Kelly Olynyk was awesome in the second half of last season and is going into his sophomore campaign. Marcus Smart and James Young are extremely talented rookies.
Likening Turner to a lot of the guys on this roster just isn't fair.
Your acting like Turner is 30.
If your can read you would understand I said
"I don't think Turner is quite as good as Iguodala but in 3/4 of a season he did a pretty good impression when he got a hold of that role."
As importantly is that Iguodala in 63 games as a starter in Golden State put up roughly the some production and per 36's as Turner did in IND he is just making 12 mil a season on a 4 year deal. Now that is only getting worse as Iggy is likely going to the bench making 12 mil a year and scoring 9 ppg he is overrated as a defender and is approaching Gerald Wallace production.. The difference between Iggy and Turner hasn't really been on the defensive end it is on the offensive end. Not that Iggy is a great offensive player plenty of poor 3 pt shooting years when it didn't stop him from gunning away and plenty of high turnover years and bad FT shooting but his team played pretty well with him on the floor and a lot of the offense running through him.
Turner has not performed very well offensively and his team hasn't performed well offensively. `That said he hasn't really been in a position for that to be the case. Does that happen in Boston maybe maybe not. But there has just been a big difference between the opportunity that Iggy has had in his career and what Turner has had. Sometimes there is a very good reason for that and that we shall see.