RealGM

Rate each other teams, just post your team then what you think it gets for a rating out of 10 and then hopefully other will rate it as well. I will start with mine.

Wilson Ramos Was-C
Eric Hosmer KC-1B
Robinson Cano Sea-2B
Josh Donaldson Oak-3B
Jonathan Villar Hou-SS
Adam Jones Bal-OF
Alex Rios Tex-OF
Yoenis Cespedes Oak-OF
Michael Cuddyer Col-1B,OF
Alfonso Soriano NYY-OF
Nolan Arenado OAK-3B
Christian Yelich MIA-OF
Will Middlebrooks BOS-3B
Yan Gomes CLE-C

Pitchers
Max Scherzer Det SP
Mike Minor Atl SP
Ryu LAD SP
Doug Fister WASH SP
Hiroki Kuroda NYY SP
Chris Archer TB SP
Ervin Santana ATL SP

Chad Qualls HOU RP
Joakim Soria TEX RP

2 Utility and 2 Relief Spots

I give myself a 7/10, I obviously missed on the relief pitchers and am deciding if i should just abandon saves. Our league is W's, ERA, K's, Whip, Saves

That team seems pretty weak with the hitting. I'll give it a 4/10.

Ya i guess you're probably right, hopefully they outperform. It is also a 12 team league for whatever that is worth. Better than last year when i was relying on Pedro Alvarez and Adam Dunn to provide my team with power.

Good thread. If I were you I would never give up on saves. They can be had throughout the season if you pay attention closely to the attrition that occurs. I like your starting pitching but you might be slightly weak on the power categories on hitting. If Adam Jones can hit with the same kind of power he did last year and Cespedes improves you might be okay but thats where I'd focus. I'll go 6/10.

I'm in a 12 team typical 5x5 league as well. How do you think I"ll stack up against the other 11 teams? What are my greatest weaknesses?

C: Wilin Rosario
1B: Chris Davis
2B: Jose Altuve
SS: Everth Cabrera
3B: David Wright
OF: Justin Upton
OF: Allen Craig
OF: Mark Trumbo
Util: Brandon Belt
BENCH: Dee Gordon
BENCH: Khris Davis

SP: Yu Darvish
SP: Stephen Strasburg
SP: Danny Salazar
SP: Sonny Gray
SP: Josh Johnson (DL)
SP: Tyson Ross
RP: Jonathan Papelbon
RP: John Axford
RP: Latroy Hawkins
RP: Chad Qualls

Wanted some opinions on my offense:

C: Yan Gomes
1B: Brandon Belt
2B: Brad Miller
SS: Jean Segura
3B: Anthony Rendon
OF: Yoenis Cespedes
OF: Adam Eaton
OF: Kole Calhoun
Util: Emilio Bonifacio
Util: Matt Adams
BENCH: Christian Yelich
BENCH: Evan Gattis

Looks like you have alot of guys who play their home games in pitchers park. That's the type of thing I try to avoid in fantasy baseball.

Quality real life baseball players though.

10 team 5x5

Wieters
Gonzo
Dozier
Bryant/Harrison
Tulo
J Upton
Dickerson
Revere/Melky/Pederson/Alvarez

King Felix
Cueto
DeGrom
Ventura
Wacha
Jose Fernadez
Odorizzi
Keuchel
Pomeranz
Alvarez
Gausman
Betances
Rondon

Thoughts?


Sent from my iPhone using RealGM Forums mobile app