Dan Z wrote:MrSparkle wrote:Guys , you can tweak lotto odds all you want. As long as some form of being worse is advantageous, atleast 1-10 teams will take advantage of it.
If you want zero tanking efforts, then you eliminate all weighted odds and have a fair random draw, or eliminate the draft altogether and have open FA recruitment (which would mean teams have to create cap space to make offers to highly prized rookies… so no, Boston and LAL wouldn’t be able to sign Flagg to a huge deal.)
They put rules on every type of contract. Just create a rookie salary structure (maybe tier 1 max, tier 2 mid, tier 3 min) and require atleast 4y team option so that a player can’t sign 1y and leave for Miami.
Bam, presto, done. No more tanking ever again.
An open FA recruitment would be a mess. Instead of tanking there would be teams cutting players (salary) to get enough money to make a bid on a top player. Plus, if the draft didn't exist then there are no trades involving picks. How would that work?
I'm not sure what they can do to stop teams from tanking and agree with you that there's probably nothing that would work. Maybe the same odds for all the bottom 14 teams like DASMACKDOWN suggested? That way a team doesn't need to completely bottom out to have a chance at the number 1 pick.
I don’t understand? Teams can’t just cut big salaries. If there’s a max rookie contract (let’s say $16M, something above MLE so every team obviously can’t put in their bid), it’s a big risk paying that much money for a 19yo.
I think one nice side-effect would be that teams do their homework to recruit the right guy for their future. It’s not like everybody would have their big offer ready for a mystery like Giannis or Kawhi. And while Luka, Zion, Durant, Lebron were exciting for their original franchises at one point or another, look at everything that happened between draft night and today.
We’re in a different era. The draft was great fun into even last decade. Personally I think Lebron & Durant kinda spear-headed the death of it… and the high stakes of today’s big money, and this Luka trade cemented it.
But I am personally more in favor of an even-odds lotto. Worst thing that could happen is some super team defies odds and gets multiple top-5 picks in a row while already winning. In which case, yeah for that team. 10 NBA teams have never won a ring. Random lotto odds atleast help them in the grand scheme of things, as treadmill squads can catchy lucky breaks with much higher odds than in the tank system.