umfan83 wrote:I think its a little ridiculous that no one will give up Asik for Lee. I love Asik too and think he's a good improving player. But you have to get to give. We won't offer our 3rd string center for their starting SG. You have to give to get, and you can't just give them 2 late first round picks and expect them to trade you a young SG with potential. You have to give up from your strength. It's not like we are going to expect him to be a starter or best bench frontcourt player. He's your 4th big man, 5th if Kurt Thomas is on the team.
He's also one of only two who is a true center and the only center with the size to protect the basket against bigger centers.
Personally, I don't think EITHER team NEEDS to make this deal. I've heard the argument that we'll get much better value at SG if we wait until the off season, and if whoever we bring in for Asik is just a marginal upgrade over Brewer/Bogans/Korver... its just not worth giving up on a promising guy with that size and messing with our chemistry right now.
But its disenguous to say he's not ahead of Taj on the depth chart therefore Asik's dispensible which is pretty much what this post states. Taj is as close to being a true NBA center as Asik is to being a true NBA PF. And Asik, for what its worth, has been a major factor for several wins for us which speaks volumes for any rookie... especially as raw as he is.