DASMACKDOWN wrote:Wingy wrote:CobyWhite0 wrote:
Yeah, if it wasn't for the windup, I'm not sure it's even a foul. He swiped the ball cleanly for sure - and this is coming from a person who irrationally hates Phoenix (the city, and through the transitive process all of its teams) for personal reasons.
I think the windup is ironically what actually made Cam get hit hard in the first place. I think Cam sees the big paw wound up, and then instinctively turns his face away. In turning his face away, he actually moves his head forward into a position to get hit. If Joker just went for a normal swipe, I don't think Cam has time to see it, and react to put his head in the way. That's not saying it's Cam's fault. I think he just reacted naturally to something he saw happening. It was excessive, and deserved a flagrant 1. Flagrant 2, nah. While it wouldn't have changed the series outcome, I'm sure Utah/LAC would've been happy to see Phoenix have to expend energy, and possibly get nicked up in another game, or two.
I think everyone's judgement of the play is clouded because it was Jokic and they wanted to see him out there.
But That was a text book flagrant 2. No question.
You have to remember that is a 7ft 300 pound man going full force swipe across a man half his size. He could have easily broken his nose or worse. The actual intent is irrelevant. He even said he wanted to hard foul out of frustration. He didnt want to hurt him for real but again, its irrelevant. He was probably trying to swipe his hands or arms, but caught his face. That error is the difference between F1 and F2. Everyone knows this.
Is the league soft? Most definitely. But that was still a flagrant 2 in any league. Lets see how Ja Morant talks if it were Shaq going full force swipe across his face and breaks his nose or injures his neck. Will he say he only deserves a F1 then? Certainly not.
If someone hit me like that that would be a fight for real.
Disagree. I’ve watched one night of games since the Bulls season ended, so I don’t personally care if Jokic plays or not, especially already down 0-3.
He made a clear play on the ball. The so-called “follow through” called out by the rules was that of smashing the hell out of...the basketball. The thing players are supposed to swipe at.
Size shouldn’t matter. Bigs are regularly punished for simply being bigger, and that shouldn’t be the case. It’s the act that matters, and to me, it was an F1.
Not just Ja either, Trae Young also questioned the decision. The league’s two brightest young PG stars see the call for the act committed against a PG as rubbish.
Edit: In general, I’m also not one to call things out as “soft” either. Things change, and I don’t yearn for the days of dimwits like Laimbeer.