jnrjr79 wrote:fleet wrote:jnrjr79 wrote:I thought this was a pretty accurate summary of Caleb's performance today in The Ringer:
https://www.theringer.com/2025/09/10/nfl/nfl-week-1-real-not-real-caleb-williams-lions-chiefs-kickoff-dolphins
Caleb’s career evaluation is in context of being a number one overall “generational” talent. If he only is not terrible or average, that’s crushing for the Bears who bypassed 2 years of quarterbacks that are going to be better than not terrible. The Bears never had a quarterback. The opportunity cost of choosing Caleb Williams is significant
I guess I don't see how that's responsive to a specific evaluation of how he performed in his first game under Johnson.
In any event, I don't agree that Caleb has to become a "generational" QB in order for the pick to be successful, but I agree he has to become better than average. He doesn't need to be Tom Brady or Peyton Manning, but he probably needs to be ~Russell Wilson for me to think it all worked out fine. Maybe Philip Rivers? It's kind of an interesting question: who is the least good (but still very good) QB who, if Caleb became as good an NFL player as him, you'd be happy? And that doesn't really mean achievements - obviously there are bad QBs who have won SBs and great QBs who have not, so I'm really talking about just overall QB capability.
EDIT: I see you edited and connected up why you were saying that relative to the article. I don't agree with that criticism at all. The author was just reviewing the performance. It's not his job (unless he wants to) to put it in the broader context of expectations for Caleb. He's just breaking down film on one game.
One other thing I'd add here while I'm at it - I think the people itchy to turn to Bagent after one game (and I'm saying you are doing that) are just nuts. The Bears have invested significantly in Caleb and have to see it through, even if it's painful. It took Josh Allen several years to become Josh Allen and he likely never does if the Bills are impatient.
I need him to score more than 17 points to be happy with him. Even then, watching McCarthy become baby Brady (if he does) is never gonna be an easy swallow. We were supposed to have baby Mahomes. Not terrible is devastating especially for a franchise like the Bears that thought they were finally blessed.