beeshma wrote:I think Coby is an okay pick. Revisiting the 2019 draft we could have had Cam Johnson, PJ Washington, Tyler Herro, Matisse Thybulle, or Kevin Porter Jr.
All of these players are better than Coby, but let's be honest, none of them are elite players, few have 2-way potential, some have red flags, and...so far none of them project to be an all star.
Sure he was an OK pick given the 5-10, but every pick counts. Kenny Smith said it best in an interview; you know the laziest scouts when they stick to Duke/UNC type super school picks. It was an indirect knock on the Bulls. Not to say you can't find good picks there, but there are always under-the-radar schools to scout... and GarPax sure liked their off-shelf chicken stock. (Strangely enough I can't even remember Bulls taking the more guaranteed NCAA-to-NBA KYU program players - last Calipari pick they took was Rose, I think?)
For me, Coby has followed a very similar trajectory to Lauri and Wendell. I started optimistic, they showed a lot their first 2 months, and then they fell flat and got exposed for poor physicals, IQ and skills at NBA level. Zero creation ability (ok maybe 0.5% in Coby's case). More than anything, just broken physical profiles; Coby is weak as a noodle with no hang-time, Wendell is slow as a mech warrior with the reliability of a Pinto, and Lauri is a lumbering short-armed T-Rex who very mistakingly thinks he's a modern shooting guard. The only pick in the last 9 years (since Jimmy, to be exact) who can remotely hang athletically/physically with a Lebron or Kawhi is Pat Williams.
Bad picks add up, but even 1 Thybulle is better than those 3. Let alone if you went OG, Mikal and Cam. That's a whole lot more trade power and a stronger defensive core; addressing 3D wings is very difficult.
My take since the beginning was Coby needs to be a PG or else he's not worth it. Glad to be patient with him since his value's been nuked since his rookie season, but he has 2 seasons left to make some unrealistic jumps to be worth a typical second contract for a scorer (let's say starting $15m if he improves at his strength: shooting). Reality is Thybulle, Cam and Herro would've been more worthwhile. But no reason to feel sorry. Fortunately there are other GMs who love to overpay for mediocre prospects; fortunately we don't have GarPax anymore, who salivated at the opportunities to get Jerian Grant, Payne, and Dunn. I'm hoping Coby can pump his value this year and bring back something good.