Post#488 » by MrSparkle » Sun Aug 30, 2020 5:47 pm
While I agree police needs reform, I wish BLM was also talking about K-12 education reform. Long post but as a part-time educator here's my out-the-box but feasible idea for Chicago:
Education: Sounds crazy but I think there needs to be more incentive to work. I think the traditional idea of sending kids to school for 8 hours a day and having them listen to lectures, it needs to end, and we need to go to a more Eastern/old-school style of pay-your-dues-to-learn. OK- I don't mean like some sort of repressive totalitarian dystopian society. But I do mean, bring trade skills back to schools. Wood-working, auto repair, building mini homes, sowing clothes, cooking, plumbing, landscaping/gardening - these are actually really high-value skills. I seriously think that there should be training programs with certificates that 14-18 year olds can apply for, and if they get them, I think they should be allowed to earn a good wage building furniture, fixing cars, sheds and shacks, etc. - and they should actually apply for the job with a resume based on their training grades. Leave it at part-time (20hr max). Call me absolutely insane, but that puts money in kids' pockets in a safe vetted job with skills they are interested in that the community needs. If a job is less coveted, making the pay higher.
Throw in computer programming, research (geology, biology), available for very ambitious kids - there's a lot of grunt work in those fields. Make high school more career-oriented instead of general education. The traditional school is not working. If you are an aspiring musician, have programs to record jingles and records, provide background music at lunch-time for fellow students, play at assemblies and recess. And get paid. Yes - get paid for your service as 14-18yo.
Seriously- I know it sounds absurd, but I don't think it is. Your tax dollars would literally be getting diverted back into students' hands. And it would be a competitive and incentive based program, so you're not just throwing a flat $15 wage towards kids who slack.
Now, I realize this sounds like a recipe for disaster (having kids with $500-1000 of disposable income a month.. aka drugs...), but the parallel thing you do, you also make financial planning a total normal part of the curriculum. So you start talking about retirement savings, paying for college, investment (whose eyes don't light up when you talk about putting money in an account and making more money without doing anything). And make this business curriculum a pretty big part of it all, so that kids are getting educated on how to use their money, not just spending it at the convenience store and on weed (or worse). Also, yes - government taxes these student salaries.
Meanwhile, you still have science, math, English and social studies class, but you don't have them 1-2 hours every day. You integrate them into these other classes, and for the short attention-spans, you make the math/science classes more like 15-30 minute hyper focused lessons.
IMO you really need to get the economic and educational wheels moving. As a part-time teacher, I've seen how both wealthy and low-income districts work. Rich kids are set-up for financial success from their parents, not just with a direct credit line, but also just in terms of learning how to work, save money. How many black kids get to caddy for golfing executives during high school? I guess MJ's kids.
I know this all sounds insane, but I can't think of any reason not to get experimental right now with education. It's been 50 years since the Civil Rights act and southside Chicago is still in educational and economic decline. And it's Latino and mixed neighborhoods too. Also you could consider scrapping or severely cutting welfare for families with many kids, because all kids past 14yo can start earning that money.
Now the reason I say all this, is because there is a large percentage of broken parenting. And I don't think it's intentional or malicious, but rather helpless, ignorant, or PTSD. And I know CPS/public school does its best, but just have hundreds of thousands of kids COMPLETELY WASTING about 80% of their weeks for 6-8 crucial years of their life. And then you have a lot of kids getting jobs at McDonalds or hustle-jobs to make money, which does nothing for their career resume.
So it's no surprise that gangs and petty crimes comprise a big part of life. Those seriously are amongst the most appealing things to do in the hood if you don't have great sports or music skills. And then, the aspiring athletes and musicians aren't exactly making money either, they're working hard for a lotto ticket to success.
I know at the moment police brutality is being addressed, and it should be, but it's also clearly getting murky as the nuances of "How could've the cop handled that really tense situation?" can be debated endlessly with no practical resolution.
Yes - police around the country need reform. I think it's probably good that Minneapolis saw a top-down re-build. We'll see if it really is better in 5-10 years. It didn't hurt to try. IMO, CPD doesn't need a total rebuild, and this city has been ahead of police reform because of the tragic Laquan McDonald case that was tried 2 years ago. But as a whole , the Southside of this city needs like a 180 reform in educational and economic policy, and the answer can not continue being to gentrify and displace.
At least locally, in Chicago right now (and Portland), IMO it's swung in the other direction and things aren't making sense anymore. My friend's partner is a young black man and he has white BLM protestors run up to him with both middle fingers up screaming "Don't you hate yourself!!??" We're in a moment of hysteria. To bring it full circle, at the moment crime isn't happening because of the police. Like, that idea doesn't make any sense. At this point, they are accidents happening at the scenes of crimes; maybe they're petty, but you can't shut your eyes and pretend it's a picnic.
You can put all your eggs into this police brutality basket, but it's been a pretty loud message for 5 months straight. It was right to bring it up, and the pressure should continue to reform it around the country. But Chicago and Portland for example, two hot spots, it is now time to integrate the other pressing issues (education, poverty and why are so many young black men even put in the situation of breaking the law). I'm afraid we're not hearing comprehensive or appealing solutions to those problems. Lot of energy is being burnt IMO. Reminds me of the 1% Wall St movement - great idea, started well, went on for a while and became a big deal. Then what? It was an esoteric concept of rich people controlling too much wealth with no practical plan in place - since then, the income disparity has grown much greater.