Grodoboldo wrote:KevinPandawong wrote:PlayerUp wrote:The cons
- He isn't super athletic
- Lacks that speed burst
- Left hand dominant
- Needs to continue working on his handles and turnovers
I feel like Hayes' weaknesses are getting hand-waved too easily, when they seem very troubling for a prospect deemed to be a 'primary ballhandler'.
Athleticism: Hayes in the athletic LNB was a disaster, in the much slower BBL he looked promising. What's his transition going to look like in the NBA?
First step: Coby White could be a lead guard and thrive in the PnR if only he had a first step, but Hayes' is even worse.
Right hand: I wouldn't fault teenage prospects for needing to work on their weak-hand, but again Hayes is being touted as a 'lead guard'/'primary ballhandler' and his proficiency passing with his right hand is abysmal.
Hayes' NBA role to me is as a 3nD guard and tertiary ballhandler, which Haliburton does much much better.
Even though I agree on Hayes weaknesses (though not on the intensity), tertiary ball handler doesn't fit the bill. He's a 19yo main ball handler on a pro league. When comparing him to Hali, who has a much harder time creating his own shot against a set defense, you can see his advantage in P&R situations.
Hali is a very interesting prospect. But when comparing him to Hayes, if I had to guess that one of them would only work as a secondary ball handler, it would be Hali.
I'll plug this awesome in depth analysis of Hayes game that I found on PD Web's (https://www.patreon.com/user?u=24373441) patreon page that addresses these concerns.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1K4pWh6JnouEkE_cwfZRpNV40ncR-DHouWCWJuU6cQ70/edit?usp=sharing
Hali also looks very fragile and his legs are skinny. Hate his form as well but somehow it goes in. They are comparable in many ways but at the end of the day you have to go for upside and Hayes has a bit more upside imo.