NecessaryEvil wrote:I saw Caleb/Bowers as a Pat/Travis type duo eventually. Looks like I woulda been spot on.
![]()
![]()
except for, ya know, the mahomes part
Moderators: HomoSapien, dougthonus, Michael Jackson, Tommy Udo 6 , kulaz3000, fleet, DASMACKDOWN, GimmeDat, RedBulls23, AshyLarrysDiaper, coldfish, Payt10, Ice Man
NecessaryEvil wrote:I saw Caleb/Bowers as a Pat/Travis type duo eventually. Looks like I woulda been spot on.
![]()
![]()
dice wrote:NecessaryEvil wrote:I saw Caleb/Bowers as a Pat/Travis type duo eventually. Looks like I woulda been spot on.
![]()
![]()
except for, ya know, the mahomes part
Dresden wrote:panthermark wrote:Heck, take a look at MHJ and McBride in Arizona (McBride went to the Pro-Bowl as a TE. Similar numbers to Brock).
Then look at Nabors in NY.....170 targets! Also went to the Pro-Bowl. (He clearly led the Giants in targets!)
Look at Brian Thomas Jr and his targets (133)! Went to the Pro-Bowl. He more than doubled the #2 player on the Jags for targets.
You start going down the list of 1st round WR's (except Ricky...who got shot), it is a damn shame how much Rome got shafted.
Xavier Worthy had 98 targets, 2nd on the Chiefs behind Kelce.
Xavier Legette had 84 targets, that led the Panthers.
Only Poles can answer as to why KA wasn't moved at the deadline to a contender while this team was in a tail spin because of all the 1st round pass catchers that were not shot in the off-season, only our guy managed to be 3rd on his respective team in targets....and that incudes our TE being completely forgotten about. The rookies that were 2nd in targets on their teams (MHJ and Worthy) were 2nd to TE's that went to the Pro-Bowl!!!! All of them (minus Rome and Ricky) were the #1 WR options.
I think there's a lot of reasons why Rome saw fewer targets, but it's hard to blame it Keenan Allen not being moved. For one thing, Allen seemed to have the best chemistry with Caleb. So why would you trade your rookie QB's favorite target when he's struggling so badly to begin with? another reason might be that the Bears O line was so poor last year and Rome might have been running more deep routes, which Caleb didn't have time for. Another reason might be that Rome just didn't get open as often- that was one knock on him coming out of college- his inability to get separation.
Also the Bears offense as a whole was one of the worst in the league, so ran fewer plays, and fewer pass plays.
Rome may have been unique in that he was drafted top 10 but was WR3 on his team. I don't know how many WR's in the past 10 years went into a situation like that. The thinking obviously was to give Caleb a lot of targets. Turned it that having targets wasn't the issue- it was having enough time to throw. Plus a crappy offense by Waldron.
In any case, I don't see how Rome "got shafted". If that applies to anyone, it was Kmet, and it was to his credit that he never complained about that one bit. Rome willl get his opportunities this year. Let's see what he makes of them.
Dresden wrote:One interesting thing is that the Bears have not signed anyone to be Caleb's backup. I don't know if that's because they like Bagent, or if he was signed to a guaranteed contract that makes it tough to move on from him. Will be interesting to see if they draft anyone at that position in the later rounds.
Almost Retired wrote:Dresden wrote:One interesting thing is that the Bears have not signed anyone to be Caleb's backup. I don't know if that's because they like Bagent, or if he was signed to a guaranteed contract that makes it tough to move on from him. Will be interesting to see if they draft anyone at that position in the later rounds.
I read on some website that Brett Rypien was hanging around Halas Hall, with speculation he'd be added as QB3 if he couldn't arrange a roster spot elsewhere. I think Bill Zimmerman wrote an article about it in Windy City Gridiron a week ago or so.
panthermark wrote:Dresden wrote:panthermark wrote:Heck, take a look at MHJ and McBride in Arizona (McBride went to the Pro-Bowl as a TE. Similar numbers to Brock).
Then look at Nabors in NY.....170 targets! Also went to the Pro-Bowl. (He clearly led the Giants in targets!)
Look at Brian Thomas Jr and his targets (133)! Went to the Pro-Bowl. He more than doubled the #2 player on the Jags for targets.
You start going down the list of 1st round WR's (except Ricky...who got shot), it is a damn shame how much Rome got shafted.
Xavier Worthy had 98 targets, 2nd on the Chiefs behind Kelce.
Xavier Legette had 84 targets, that led the Panthers.
Only Poles can answer as to why KA wasn't moved at the deadline to a contender while this team was in a tail spin because of all the 1st round pass catchers that were not shot in the off-season, only our guy managed to be 3rd on his respective team in targets....and that incudes our TE being completely forgotten about. The rookies that were 2nd in targets on their teams (MHJ and Worthy) were 2nd to TE's that went to the Pro-Bowl!!!! All of them (minus Rome and Ricky) were the #1 WR options.
I think there's a lot of reasons why Rome saw fewer targets, but it's hard to blame it Keenan Allen not being moved. For one thing, Allen seemed to have the best chemistry with Caleb. So why would you trade your rookie QB's favorite target when he's struggling so badly to begin with? another reason might be that the Bears O line was so poor last year and Rome might have been running more deep routes, which Caleb didn't have time for. Another reason might be that Rome just didn't get open as often- that was one knock on him coming out of college- his inability to get separation.
Also the Bears offense as a whole was one of the worst in the league, so ran fewer plays, and fewer pass plays.
Rome may have been unique in that he was drafted top 10 but was WR3 on his team. I don't know how many WR's in the past 10 years went into a situation like that. The thinking obviously was to give Caleb a lot of targets. Turned it that having targets wasn't the issue- it was having enough time to throw. Plus a crappy offense by Waldron.
In any case, I don't see how Rome "got shafted". If that applies to anyone, it was Kmet, and it was to his credit that he never complained about that one bit. Rome willl get his opportunities this year. Let's see what he makes of them.
I wanted him moved because the chemistry was irrelevant.
He was brought in Mooney left. It made perfect sense at the time of the trade, but we lucked into Odunze being at #9.
Early on, KA was hurt and even when he came back, the team was out of synch and not getting W's.
I don't care if KA was CW's favorite target if the team was still losing and CW was still struggling. In the end, him being here didn't really help. His favorite target produced 744 yards and had one of the lowest catch percentages on the team even though he was a possession WR.
Moore, Rome, and Kmet (and Swift and Rosch and Scott) are all younger, and have longer contracts. Those are the guys that needed the reps and chemistry for this upcoming season. If it would have been a situation like Fields/Moore where CW/KA was the best QB combo in the league, or the Bears would have been winning games, then I would not have wanted him traded at the deadline.
KA probably won't even be here in 2025, which in the end makes trading for him, coupled with not moving him, a bust of a move and a waste of a 4th.
As for Odunze getting the shaft, that was really in the context of all the other rookie pass catchers drafted in the 1st round, but yes, Kmet got screwed as well. Lowest targets since his rookie season.
Dresden wrote:Fields on why he signed with the Jets over the Steelers:
“I think, No. 1, coach (Aaron) Glenn,” Fields told newyorkjets.com reporter Ethan Greenberg. “I’ve played against him early in my career. I know how passionate he is about the game, the way he coaches, the way his players play. So I think that was the biggest thing for me. And just the opportunity, the fans, of course, the city. When you win here, there’s no better place to win. Those reasons are ultimately why I ended up here.”
I thought Tomlin was generally considered a coach that players loved to play for so it is a bit surprising Justin seemed to prefer Aaron Glenn over Tomlin. Of course, Fields did get benched last year by Tomlin, so there's that.
NecessaryEvil wrote:dice wrote:NecessaryEvil wrote:I saw Caleb/Bowers as a Pat/Travis type duo eventually. Looks like I woulda been spot on.
![]()
![]()
except for, ya know, the mahomes part
3500 passing yards
500 rushing
The worst OC in football, one who didn’t even watch film with his rookie
The worst head coach in football, situationally and every other way
Hell, those fools didn’t even utilize Kmet.
Caleb and Brock, in Chicago, with atleast a competent coaching staff would of fed families
sco wrote:Dresden wrote:Fields on why he signed with the Jets over the Steelers:
“I think, No. 1, coach (Aaron) Glenn,” Fields told newyorkjets.com reporter Ethan Greenberg. “I’ve played against him early in my career. I know how passionate he is about the game, the way he coaches, the way his players play. So I think that was the biggest thing for me. And just the opportunity, the fans, of course, the city. When you win here, there’s no better place to win. Those reasons are ultimately why I ended up here.”
I thought Tomlin was generally considered a coach that players loved to play for so it is a bit surprising Justin seemed to prefer Aaron Glenn over Tomlin. Of course, Fields did get benched last year by Tomlin, so there's that.
The way I see this. First, Fields has to hold a grudge for being benched last season despite winning play. Also, IMO, Fields isn't stupid going to a team with the lowest QB expectations in the NFL.