RealGM

1. Gwynn CF
2. Hart RF
3. Hardy SS
4. Fielder 1B
5. Braun 3B
6. Hall LF-(sub Jenks/Mench)
7. Estrada C
8. Weeks 2B -(sub Hall)
9. Pitcher

1. Hart RF
2. Hardy SS
3. Fielder 1B
4. Braun 3B
5. Jenkins LF
6. Hall CF
7. Estrada C
8. Counsell 2b
9. Pitcher

If Weeks is healthy put him 2nd and slide everyone else down in the lineup. And once Hall heats up move him back to 5 hole

vs RHP

Hart RF
Hardy SS
Braun 3B
Fielder 1B
Jenkins LF
Hall CF
Estrada C
Weeks 2B

vs LHP

Hart RF
Hardy SS
Braun 3B
Fielder 1B
Hall CF
Mench LF
Estrada C
Weeks 2B

Hart
Hardy
Gwynn
Braun
Fielder
Weeks
Gross
Estarda


4 shure 4 shure

deep throat wrote:1. Gwynn CF
2. Hart RF
3. Hardy SS
4. Fielder 1B
5. Braun 3B
6. Hall LF-(sub Jenks/Mench)
7. Estrada C
8. Weeks 2B -(sub Hall)
9. Pitcher

Mine would be
Hart RF
Hardy SS
Braun 3B
Fielder 1st
Jenks LF
Gwynn CF
Estrada C
Weeks 2nd
Pitcher
Trade one year wonder boy Hall for good pitcher.

1 ) Gwynn
2 ) Hardy
3 ) Braun
4 ) Fielder
5 ) Hart
6 ) Weeks (When Healthy)
7 ) Jenkins
8 ) Estrada
9 ) GALLARDO

My dream team:

1. CF Gwynn
2. 2B Weeks
3. SS Hardy (amazing fastball hitter, sees lots of them in front of Fielder)
4. 1B Fielder
5. LF Hall
6. 3B Braun
7. RF Hart
8. C Estrada
9. Pitcher

Starting rotation:
Sheets
Capuano
Suppan
Gallardo
Vargas

Key Bullpen guys:
Villanueva
Bush
Shouse (against lefties)
Wise
Turnbow
Coco
I like Spurling too
Capellan/Dessens should be used sparingly

The love that Gwynn gets on this board is astonishing.

1.Hart-Lf
2. Weeks-2B
3. Hardy- SS
4. Fielder- 1B
5. Braun- 3B
6. Jenkins- Rf
7. Hall-Cf
8. Estrada-C
9. Pitcher

trwi7 wrote:The love that Gwynn gets on this board is astonishing.

Agreed.

Hart
JJ
Braun
Prince
Hall
Jenks/Mench
Weeks
Estrada

trwi7 wrote:The love that Gwynn gets on this board is astonishing.

And the love Billy Boy is getting is astonishing also. All that money for a .255 ang, 6 homers and 20 RBI. Now thats earning your pay. Look out . St. Louis is knocking on the door. He looks crappy at the plate
right now. You think the Brewers would have learned their lesson after Jenkins.

At least hall has a track record of great success (high five!) in the majors. Gwynn has about 30 AB's of success and a mediocre minor league track record.

I cant stand Gwynn. He had a great 3 game stretch and everyone fell in love with him. Hart and Hall must play everyday.
1.Hart RF
2.Hardy SS
3.Braun 3B
4.Fielder 1B
5.Hall CF
6.Estrada C
7.Jenkins LF
8.Weeks 2B

I think the only two spots that should be a constant are Hardy at 2, Fielder at 4. The rest...I don't know, spin a wheel, see what happens

Ayt wrote:At least hall has a track record of great success (high five!) in the majors. Gwynn has about 30 AB's of success and a mediocre minor league track record.

Are you kidding me? One year of hitting 35 homers is a great track record? If you ask me Billy must of use roids last year, because his high was 17 the year before. He will be lucky to hit 17 this year at the rate he is going. Who are you kidding? Great success.
A career .265 hitter. Career .321 OBP Career .471 SLG%
Wow.

msiris wrote:-= original quote snipped =-

Are you kidding me? One year of hitting 35 homers is a great track record? If you ask me Billy must of use roids last year, because his high was 17 the year before. He will be lucky to hit 17 this year at the rate he is going. Who are you kidding? Great success.
A career .265 hitter. Career .321 OBP Career .471 SLG%
Wow.

At least Bill Hall can hit homers. Gwynn could only dream of hitting 35 HR's in his career. And let me know when Gwynn averages a .792 OPS at any point in his career.

trwi7 wrote:-= original quote snipped =-



At least Bill Hall can hit homers. Gwynn could only dream of hitting 35 HR's in his career. And let me know when Gwynn averages a .792 OPS at any point in his career.

I have not said I am a big Tony fan. I would rather see someone totally different. Someone who is more consistant than Billy.

msiris wrote:-= original quote snipped =-

I have not said I am a big Tony fan. I would rather see someone totally different. Someone who is more consistant than Billy.

Like who? Like it or not Hall is our best option.

Gwynn-Cf
Hardy-SS
Bruan-3rd
Prince-1st
Estrada-C
Hall-Lf
Weeks-2nd
Hart-Rf
Pitcher

I like both Hall and Gwynn.

1. Hart
2. Hardy
3. Gwynn/Hall (platoon Hall plays 2 than Gwynn plays 1)
4. Fielder
5. Braun
6. Jenkins/Mench (platoon Jenkins plays 4 than Mench plays 1)
7. Estrada
8. Counsel
9. Pitcher

At least for now till Weeks gets back.