Mainly I agree with your points about Martinez but you forget that he can also DH. The other point worth remembering is that Varitak, Lowell and Ortiz need rest. A good move by Boston though I was surprised that they didnt get a pitcher. I guess that, like the Yankees, they felt teams were asking for too much.
I expect that we will be competing with Boston on the waiver lines.
quote="Jitpal"]
Duhon2Lee42 wrote:Doesn't really make a difference. Sox got Victor Martinez. What a move.
Hopefully we don't meet the Sox in the playoffs.
Victor Martinez is vastly overrated. Putting him in the lineup hurts them in one way or another. He can play 1st and Catch. Either place they put him, they hurt the defense, significantly. Their defense this year is bad to begin with. If you play him at 1st, move Youkalis to 3rd, the defense at 1st and 3rd is worse and there isn't a huge increase in offensive production, if any, between Lowell and Martinez. He only helps the offense significantly when he plays in place of Varitek, in which case, the defense and game calling is worse. Not to mention that the Red Sox laud Varitek as the heart and soul of the team, which they effectively bench with V-Mart on the field. The deal will help them, especially if he can fill in for Kottaras or whoever they have catching Wakefield these days and on the days that Lowell has to sit. Not a big deal in my opinion.
Hairston on the other hand replaces Cody Ransom. Hairston has more speed and can play more positions. So it's an upgrade, again minimal. On the nice side, he's been pretty hot after the all-star break so far this year.
The other interesting thing is V-Mart's BA and OPS has been in decline every single month from his hot start. Does Fenway revive his well below pedestrian OPS? We will see. -Jitpal[/quote]
We are discussing no small matter, but how we ought to live.
Socrates (399 B.C.)