RealGM

thats right, Im eating crow, putting foot in my mouth, watever analogy you want to use. Ive been the harshest critic of him the last few years, but he really reinvented himself this year and proved me wrong

he carried the SP while no one else stepped up

and i say we bring him back next year

can i get my crow well done plz?

I wouldn't be too hard on yourself. I doubt anyone really saw this coming from the Moose. We'd be wise to bring him back though.

you are not alone pharm. A lot of us were down on moose. He did well this year, far better than expected. He should definately be back next year...

Yup everyone was pretty down on Moose.

I remember how most of us had him pegged as our 6th starter behind Wang, Pettite, Joba, Hughes( ), Kennedy( ).

I'd love to have him back, but I could also see him retiring after a strong year.