Rick Barry's Top 50 NBA players

Post #1 » by **HMFFL** » Tue Oct 28, 2008 4:32 pm

9. Dirk Nowitzki, PF, Mavericks

24. Jason Kidd, PG, Mavericks

Link

dirkforpres · Post #2 » by **dirkforpres** » Tue Oct 28, 2008 5:50 pm

At first I was surprised that Josh wasnt on the list, but I cant really think of any players on the list that he is more valuable than... Maybe LaMarcus Aldridge.

Realmavsman · Post #3 » by **Realmavsman** » Tue Oct 28, 2008 6:02 pm

I would not trade normal Josh Howard for:

Hedo Turkoglu
Antawn Jamison
Ben Gordon

Is Tayshaun Prince any better than Josh?

Anyway I would trade "stupid" Josh Howard for any of them. I just hope "Stupid" Josh Howard is gone for good. We only want to see "normal" Josh.

Post #4 » by **HMFFL** » Tue Oct 28, 2008 7:33 pm

Realmavsman wrote:I would not trade normal Josh Howard for:

Hedo Turkoglu
Antawn Jamison
Ben Gordon

Is Tayshaun Prince any better than Josh?

Anyway I would trade "stupid" Josh Howard for any of them. I just hope "Stupid" Josh Howard is gone for good. We only want to see "normal" Josh.

I'd take Hedo Turkoglu over Josh Howard!

It depends on what your wanting because Prince brings it on both ends of the floor. I do feel he needs to do more on offense but its very debatable between him and Josh Howard. Overall I prefer Josh Howard if he plays like he did when he was a All-Star.

JES12 · Post #5 » by **JES12** » Tue Oct 28, 2008 8:44 pm

Howard should be on that list and in front of these players in order of that list:

10) Allen Iverson (compare the stats and watch the game...Howard > Iverson)
20) Shawn Marion (better offense)
21) Vince Carter (much better defender and less injuries)
22) Kevin Martin (better defender)
24) Jason Kidd (he is over-rated...by far, but not quite as much as AI)
25) Shaq (do I need to explain?)
27) Michael Redd (better defender)
28) Tayshawn Prince (need I explain? and LOL at Butler being lower than Prince)
34) Granger (way too foul proned to stay in games)
35) Richard Jefferson (defense)
36) Turkoglu (one year and offense only)
38) Hamilton (way over-rated defender because of the team he is on)
39) Ray Allen (LOL...the only reason he is on this list is because he is in Boston; if he was in OKC, Terry would be above him)
40) Ben Gordon (need I explain?)
41) Rashard Lewis
42) Mike Miller
45) Andre Iguodala (actually, I think they are about the same)
46) Rudy Gay (really...has he surpassed Howard already? Not IMO)
49) Antwan Jamison (defense)
50) Camby (over-rated role players should never be in front of your offensive 2nd option who happens to play defense as well)

I'm surprised Yao was 32. Artest did not make that list. Gilber Arenas should make the list, but not top 30. David West should be higher....and of course, my boy should be on that list.