arkuo wrote:daoneandonly wrote:Michaellam1987 wrote:
If you use 1 game or 1 series to define PJ being better than AD, or you would rather keep PJ over AD. Then I really have nothing to say. For me, I prefer having Irving/AD as the clear cut all star level 1/2 punch.
Never said PJ was better, I said Dallas should keep him over AD and there are many reasons why
1. AD's trade value would return much better pieces
2. PJ is closer to Flagg's timeline
3. PJ is more available and a better teammate
4. PJ's new contract will be less expensive, so more flexibility
5. PJ is willing to do anything asked of him, AD is not.
6. West is stacked, Dallas sint going anywhere this year with Ky out. So waste to have AD at his age
The hope is for PJ to give a hometown discount and agree to come off the bench (albeit play the same number of minutes as a starter)
But it all starts with a hometown discount. An ambitious agent who wants $35M per and a starting role destroys all of that.
I think so as well. Let's practice with Flagg and figure things out before really moving on from Gafford or PJ. You never know if Flagg can play 3, 2, or 1 without actually playing single minutes on NBA floor. If you have to make quick decision, then bring back a quick guard defender, spot up threat with playmaking skills. PJ cannot guard random 1 the way DFS has been doing in the past. With 6-7 frame, PJ size issue could affect the effectiveness against playoff opponents. To name a few, PJ is not guarding bigger frontcourt KP, KD, Kawhi very well. Nor is PJ being effective against speedy backcourts such as Ja Morant. PJ is strictly a 3/4. So is Gafford. Gafford is only 6-10. There're quite some matchups Gafford might not be able to perform effectively, says Wemby, Reid, Markkannen...etc.
BTW PJ or Gafford, I lane towards keeping Gafford if the asking price is reasonable. PJ is reductant to Flagg, Marshall, Martin and so on. Against speedy backcourt, the Mavs only have christie and Kyrie. PJ failed the Ja Morant assignment mightily last playoff on both ends actually. To win anything, you have to be able to guard any opponents. That being said, I should say, I would keep Gafford instead since Lively and Gafford have difference in strength. If Flagg is as good as advertised but can't guard speedy backcourt as well, PJ's minutes are limited. You also have Marshall and Martin around for those limited minutes. Then, you'd better get back values sooner than later.