Mr B wrote:Archx wrote:Mr B wrote:I’m only posting this trade scenario because I feel like right now anything is possible. I want to keep PJ but this is one that I personally would consider. What do you guys think?
This is basically Cam for PJ trade with a bunch of throw ins.
I think it would be a decent trade for the future but not if you want to win now. Cam is 20yo and would grow with Lively and Flagg. If everyone is healthy, Mavs will have enough defense but will suddenly lack offense and shooting with this trade so it makes no sense for Nico's "win now" objective.
Also, Mavs need a playmaking guard and swapping great role players like PJ for another random wing role player makes no sense. You will have a hard time finding a good replacement for PJ.
The ONLY trade people should be focusing on is the one that involves Gafford. That's the only riddle Nico has to solve... but then again, who am i kidding, this FO is dumb as a brick.
Cam is the reason I do this trade. PJ is eligible for an extension after next season I believe. If they are looking to keep costs down trading for Cam Whitmore and his potential might not be a bad idea. Like you said he’s only 20 years old and could grow with Flagg and Lively. I want them to keep PJ but if a trade is necessary I would consider this one.
As for why does Houston do this? Because PJ is better right now.
Yeah, i mentioned you have 2 scenarios now. You either go with Nico's "win now" or build for the future. But if you go with win now, you cannot have another young guy on the team instead of a proven veteran in PJ. If you trade PJ, you trade AD and Kyrie also. Do a complete rebuild and go from there. That's obviously the most logical choice.
But if you want to compete, you don't trade PJ because it's hardly anyone that can replace him at his value. Keeping PJ is easy if you get rid of Gafford and don't take back any long term salaries.