Skin Blues wrote:Most fastball/slider guys that throw that kind of heat and pump 4-seamers up in the zone to get whiffs have high hard-contact rates anyway. His is really not that bad in context, although when he was at his peak it was a lower (closer to 30% rather than the current 37%). His BABIP, though, has gone from .309 for his career to .382 this season (.556 since the trade, along with a 50% HR/FB - facing the heart of the lineup, twice apiece, against two of the top teams in the league will do that). So while the increased hard contact rate might not be bad luck, the results of those batted balls (and the batters he's been put up against since we got him) have most certainly been bad luck. The optics of it, though, are obviously bad, even if they're inconsequential. Acquire a guy, he's not immediately a superstar he was expected to be, and people freak out that the FO has no idea what they're doing. It's Grichuk all over again.
He certainly isn't a 6+ ERA pitcher. However, it's not largely bad luck; he has gone from a .270 xwOBA from 2015-2017 to a .345 mark this season. His slider isn't the same, and one could infer that the lack of movement on the slider has made it easier for hitters to punch both the slider and fastball.