Page 9 of 14
Re: Fire John Schneider / Or the Analytics Staff and Above Now... just fire somebody for this!
Posted: Sat Oct 7, 2023 11:48 pm
by Randle McMurphy
Ranger One wrote:Man this Astros/Twins game was so fun to watch! Imagine actually hitting homeruns in the postseason! what a feeling!
Other teams have hitters who pull fastballs.
Re: Fire John Schneider / Or the Analytics Staff and Above Now... just fire somebody for this!
Posted: Sun Oct 8, 2023 12:20 am
by Ranger One
Randle McMurphy wrote:Ranger One wrote:Man this Astros/Twins game was so fun to watch! Imagine actually hitting homeruns in the postseason! what a feeling!
Other teams have hitters who pull fastballs.
Wouldnt surprise me if there was a team wide mandate that came down from the FO at the beginning of the season to condition our hitters to only hit the ball exclusively to the opposite field. Its probably why everyone was constantly late on every fastball and why we saw so many popouts.
Re: Fire John Schneider / Or the Analytics Staff and Above Now... just fire somebody for this!
Posted: Sun Oct 8, 2023 12:31 am
by Randle McMurphy
Raps in 4 wrote:And this is why Rogers can get away with a **** product. Upvoted comments from homers on Reddit:
Shapiro and Atkins have put together a consistent playoff team after only a 3 year complete rebuild. The’ve also breathed new life into the stadium so things are booming on the business side. Baseball is hard. They overdid the analytics for sure on the pitching side but 18 other teams would have killed to be in this position.
very nice Rosie thanks for your input! anyway...
One day I hope Rosie learns to be embarrassed by the articles she vomits up
Jfc another article like this? Stop being a victim. Baseball is a product, if it’s not for you anymore then stop watching it
That last comment has been regurgitated by casual fans all season. Rogers loves to hear it.
I never go on Reddit, but I just went to read it now and it's hard to believe an entire collection of this fanbase could be so out of touch with reality. A great many were praising Ross for apparently being honest/specific/direct today. Bizarre stuff.
Re: Fire John Schneider / Or the Analytics Staff and Above Now... just fire somebody for this!
Posted: Sun Oct 8, 2023 12:50 am
by polo007
Ross Atkins discusses Toronto Blue Jays playoff exit, controversial decision to pull Berrios early in Game 2 - TSN.caToronto Blue Jays general manager Ross Atkins spoke to the media on Saturday about Toronto's early exit from the playoffs, the controversial decision to pull Jose Berrios early in Game 2 and what the future might look like for the team.
Re: Fire John Schneider / Or the Analytics Staff and Above Now... just fire somebody for this!
Posted: Sun Oct 8, 2023 12:54 am
by Randle McMurphy
Sportsnet still hadn't posted the whole press conference (unsurprisingly). Glad somebody did.
Re: Fire John Schneider / Or the Analytics Staff and Above Now... just fire somebody for this!
Posted: Sun Oct 8, 2023 1:55 am
by Randle McMurphy
Even Shi is taking shots at this guy now. Unusual times.
Re: Fire John Schneider / Or the Analytics Staff and Above Now... just fire somebody for this!
Posted: Sun Oct 8, 2023 2:24 am
by linery88
Re: Fire John Schneider / Or the Analytics Staff and Above Now... just fire somebody for this!
Posted: Sun Oct 8, 2023 2:34 am
by Randle McMurphy
The fact that Shi is writing such articles suggests to me he’s been given the go ahead to do so from someone higher on the Rogers/Blue Jays food chain than Ross Atkins…
Re: Fire John Schneider / Or the Analytics Staff and Above Now... just fire somebody for this!
Posted: Sun Oct 8, 2023 3:11 am
by GameChannel
Shatkins must go. These clowns have been around far too long with nothing to show for it. And they should take Shneider with them too. We need an old school manager and a capable front office
Re: Fire John Schneider / Or the Analytics Staff and Above Now... just fire somebody for this!
Posted: Sun Oct 8, 2023 3:30 am
by Potential
Re: Fire John Schneider / Or the Analytics Staff and Above Now... just fire somebody for this!
Posted: Sun Oct 8, 2023 4:57 am
by Los_29
Atkins needs to be shown the door. That is not someone you want running the team.
Re: Fire John Schneider / Or the Analytics Staff and Above Now... just fire somebody for this!
Posted: Sun Oct 8, 2023 5:14 am
by Quattro
I never thought I’d live to see the day when I hate a Blue Jays GM more than JP Ricciardi but here we are…
Re: Fire John Schneider / Or the Analytics Staff and Above Now... just fire somebody for this!
Posted: Sun Oct 8, 2023 6:50 am
by johanliebert
The Ivy League grads aka analytic departments are above Atkins. Both he and Schneider are making it clear for you guys.
Re: Fire John Schneider / Or the Analytics Staff and Above Now... just fire somebody for this!
Posted: Sun Oct 8, 2023 12:09 pm
by Fairview4Life
They aren’t above Atkins. There is just a fundamentally broken organizational communication structure and/or one of Schneider or Atkins is a lying liar who lies.
Re: Fire John Schneider / Or the Analytics Staff and Above Now... just fire somebody for this!
Posted: Sun Oct 8, 2023 12:13 pm
by Fairview4Life
I also don’t think Shatkins have done a terrible job. The Jays rebuilt quickly after 2016 and have been winning at a pretty decent pace. I think they could have done a better job, and previously I would have said “when hiring managers” but now I guess it’s more “when hiring managers and then they should not give them specific and immutable instructions for how to manage every game”. But Atkins in particular needs to go after that nonsense, and I’d also dump Schneider for just being bad even if it was in the service of following orders. These are not irreplaceable cogs in the machine.
Re: Fire John Schneider / Or the Analytics Staff and Above Now... just fire somebody for this!
Posted: Sun Oct 8, 2023 1:00 pm
by dafan590
Blue Jays need to get rid of Shapiro, Atkins and Schneider.
Do you guys have any suggestions on who should replace them?
Re: Fire John Schneider / Or the Analytics Staff and Above Now... just fire somebody for this!
Posted: Sun Oct 8, 2023 3:02 pm
by johanliebert
Fairview4Life wrote:They aren’t above Atkins. There is just a fundamentally broken organizational communication structure and/or one of Schneider or Atkins is a lying liar who lies.
They’re above all Gm’s and managers. I’ve said this for years and my source is a former pro. You can be skeptical about atkins but Schneider? Lol he’s a puppet like any manager.
Re: Fire John Schneider / Or the Analytics Staff and Above Now... just fire somebody for this!
Posted: Sun Oct 8, 2023 3:17 pm
by C Court
This is what I discovered from podcasts and articles written by Jays beat media, who are universally critical of Atkins.
Atkins is correct in that he does 'not' attend Schneider's pre-game planning meetings. But, Atkins has a front office representative attend every pre-game meeting on his behalf.
Does anyone really believe that Atkins has no input into what the front office employee says at Schneider's meeting or that Atkins is not de-briefed after the meeting - particularly in a win or go home play-off game?
As well, Atkins meets with Schneider after every game. Does anyone believe that Atkins didn't bring up the Berrios/Kikuchi strategy after losing game one?
Schneider says that it was an organizational decision, even though the coward Atkins says it was the manager's decision.
Who ya' gonna believe?
Re: Fire John Schneider / Or the Analytics Staff and Above Now... just fire somebody for this!
Posted: Sun Oct 8, 2023 3:22 pm
by johanliebert
I was a conspiracy theorist for stating games were mapped out by the nerds when Montoyo was here. I see this board has come around to that next is knowing they have more power than Gm’s
Re: Fire John Schneider / Or the Analytics Staff and Above Now... just fire somebody for this!
Posted: Sun Oct 8, 2023 6:20 pm
by LBJKB24MJ23
C Court wrote:This is what I discovered from podcasts and articles written by Jays beat media, who are universally critical of Atkins.
Atkins is correct in that he does 'not' attend Schneider's pre-game planning meetings. But, Atkins has a front office representative attend every pre-game meeting on his behalf.
Does anyone really believe that Atkins has no input into what the front office employee says at Schneider's meeting or that Atkins is not de-briefed after the meeting - particularly in a win or go home play-off game?
As well, Atkins meets with Schneider after every game. Does anyone believe that Atkins didn't bring up the Berrios/Kikuchi strategy after losing game one?
Schneider says that it was an organizational decision, even though the coward Atkins says it was the manager's decision.
Who ya' gonna believe?
You, and most of the speculative fans here, have pretty much 0 evidence of such accusations of blaming 1 person.
Until or when the truth comes out, let’s see what the organization does in the off-season in terms of improving this ugly offense. They obviously need fine tuning of their analytics and the conclusions they are coming up with to warrant that change.
It seems that both Schneider and Atkins are back next year so I hope both improve in all aspects. We are not in control so why be negative. lol