Schad wrote:I can't believe I have to say this again, but:
Kikuchi gets lifted early because he is an accident waiting to happen. He isn't as bad as last year (because he throws strikes now), but he still gives up an alarming amount of hard contact. In close games, being a pitcher than gives up an alarming amount of hard contact is bad, because a one-run lead can turn into a one-run deficit in approximately two pitches, and that is a thing that has happened repeatedly with him.
Meanwhile, our bullpen has been very good. Very good does not mean invincible, however. Very good means that from time to time they will actually give up runs. Last night, they gave up runs. When your offense isn't firing on all cylinders, that's just a thing that will sometimes happen.
I miss the days when this board wasn't filled to the lid with reactionary pissbabies, but alas, those days aren't returning.
You're turning a possibility into a certainty while seemingly ignoring in game performance.
Kikuchi is not at all an accident waiting to happen in a game where he has 8 SO and 5 hits through 5 and a third. Of note, the 5 hits were all singles and some infield hits which implies very little hard contact at all. He is a kind of Jekyll and Hyde kind of pitcher but this game you can argue he was Jekyll/having a good game.
Instead, burning Richards and Swanson early and therefore going eventually to Garcia (who has been a disaster overall this season in high leverage) was the effect of removing Kikuchi early. This was a bad move and deserved all reactions no matter who decides to give a rationale or not.
The only other possibility would have been Schneider going with Mayza instead but for whatever reason, because Garcia was doing better lately, they went with him and it cost the team a run.