Post#4 » by J.Kim » Wed Aug 25, 2010 9:47 pm
I'm not exactly sure how accurate that Yahoo article is 100% correct in pinning the entire blame upon the Florida Marlins. I hate to take the side of Jeffrey Loria here but to laud Jeffrey Loria of contributing "only" $155 million (approximately 25% of the cost; not accounting for future value of the debt) and not contributing an extra $50 Mil is laughable.
That Yahoo article isn't looking at the present value of the bonds, but rather the future nominal value of the bonds, assuming a 40-year bond with an interest rate of approximately 4.11% (I'm not exactly sure what the interest rate is, but I worked backwards from the $2.4 Billion total cost to taxpayer amount). Of course the nominal cost to the taxpayer is going to be substantial... they wrote a 40-year bond for christ's sakes! Even if Jeffrey Loria did contribute that extra $50 Mil, the Miami-Dade county and the City of Miami would still have to take out a $429M bond, and the nominal future value of that amount is still $2.1 Billion!
Still further, even if Loria went half-sies on the stadium construction amount (That seems reasonable, since you would assume that a Stadium is really a joint venture between the city and the person that owns the team) Miami-Dade would still have $317M to make up for its share, and taking out a bond with a similar interest rate and length, it'd still be $1.59 Billion!
For crying out loud. This is just a case of where a great business man **** over an entire city because its city councillors were too stupid (and not to mention completely fiscally irresponsible spending taxpayers money in these ways) to figure out that the nominal cost would be astronomical regardless of how much Jeffrey Loria contributed because of length of the bond taken out and the interest rate amounts. It sure as hell didn't help that interest rates and borrwing rates sharply declined after, making the opportunity cost that much more astronomical.
I really hate to be defending Jeffrey Loria like this because there's all sorts of other issues that I hate about him, but to point the blame for the nominal cost to the taxpayer solely on Jeffrey Loria seems ridiculous.
Edit: Just to add on, I just gotta say how stupid it is of the City Councillors to not do a complete due diligence on the Miami Baseball franchise and Jeffrey Loria before entering into this agreement. In any sort of business venture of any sort, you've gotta make sure you've done the due diligence on the other party; especially if you feel that something is up. There's been absolutely no mention of this, and that's why I feel absolutely do not feel sorry for the Councillors (Poor people of Miami-Dade county though....)
Edit 2: I've also got to say this is what's wrong with cities these days. No wonder we hear of so many municipal governments going bankrupt. Fiscal irresponsibility has led to the high-leveraging of cities budgets that we see today. This is just another one of those examples.