RealGM

How do you all see it shaking out - now that the Jays have made the surprising signing of Melke Cabrerra, and assuming the Miami trade goes through?

1. Reyes SS
2. Cabrerra LF
3. Bautista RF
4. E.E. 1B
5. Lawrie 3B
6. Rasmus CF
7. J.P. C
8. Boni DH
9. Izturis 2B

1. Reyes
2. Cabrera
3. Bautista
4. Encarnacion
5. Lind/DH
6. Lawrie
7. Rasmus
8. Arencibia/D'arnaud
9. Izturis/2B

There is a guess.

As it is right now:

Reyes
Melky
Bautista
EE
Lawrie
Rasmus
Arencibia
Lind/Davis platoon
Boni/Izturis

1. Reyes (SS)
2. Bonifacio (DH)
3. Bautista (RF)
4. Encarnacion (1B)
5. Cabrera (LF)
6. Lawrie (3B)
7. Rasmus (CF)
8. Arencibia/D'arnaud (C)
9. Izturis (2B)

IMO, this team has so much power, that we really don't have to go with a conventional DH. Playing Reyes and Bonifacio at the top of the line-up would be a nightmare for opponents. It would mean a lot for fastballs for Bautista and co.

This is a championship calibre line-up.

If Bonifacio can return to 2011 form I'd definitely have him in the 2 hole and Melky will fit nicely at 5.

torontoaces04 wrote:1. Reyes (SS)
2. Bonifacio (DH)
3. Bautista (RF)
4. Encarnacion (1B)
5. Cabrera (LF)
6. Lawrie (3B)
7. Rasmus (CF)
8. Arencibia/D'arnaud (C)
9. Izturis (2B)

IMO, this team has so much power, that we really don't have to go with a conventional DH. Playing Reyes and Bonifacio at the top of the line-up would be a nightmare for opponents. It would mean a lot for fastballs for Bautista and co.

This is a championship calibre line-up.

This is what you go with IMO. You keep speed on the basepaths at the top of the lineup and watch the chaos that unfolds as Bautista and Edwin rake.

wow this is a monster team.... i remember those garbage days with wells/glaus..hahaha were so beast now, only if adam lind can return to form that can add another dimension to this

Question for someone who's watched more Marlins baseball than myself...

Who is the better defender in CF, Rasmus or Bonifacio?

torontoaces04 wrote:Question for someone who's watched more Marlins baseball than myself...

Who is the better defender in CF, Rasmus or Bonifacio?

i dont know but i do know rasmus is a great center fielder and he has the power bat too

torontoaces04 wrote:Question for someone who's watched more Marlins baseball than myself...

Who is the better defender in CF, Rasmus or Bonifacio?

Rasmus.

torontoaces04 wrote:Question for someone who's watched more Marlins baseball than myself...

Who is the better defender in CF, Rasmus or Bonifacio?

Don't really know, but my money would be on Rasmus considering he is one of the best in the league.

Hopefully they keep JP and then Buck as backup, wanna see JP hit 20-30 hr with this lineup as a 7-8 hitter

Travis can earn his keep, Buck an JP can always be traded later - as we saw last year injuries happen, especially catchers

1. Reyes (SS)
2. Lawrie (3RD)
3. Bautista (RF)
4. Edwin (1ST)
5. Cabrera (LF)
6. Rasmus (CF)
7. Lind (DH)
8. JP (C)
9. Bonifacio (2nd)

Bench: izturis, Davis, D'arnaud. Cooper

Ideally Boni and Izturis share time at 2B/being a utility player and then the DH issue is solved by trading for or signing either Lind's replacement or someone who can platoon with Lind (ie. Gomes.)

1. Reyes
2. Boni
3. Bautista
4. Cabrera
5.Encarnacion
6.Lawrie
7.Rasmus
8. Arencibia
9. Izturis

AA is telling us fans to sit back and enjoy

Trade JPA and Lind for anything. Both these guys are below average players at their position. Arencibia is a liability defensively and Lind is a liability offensively. I'd be fine with Buck/Wilson to start the season, with D'Arnaud eventually taking over.

Reyes
Cabrera
Bautista
Encarnacion
Lawrie
Rasmus
D'Arnaud
Lind's replacement
Izturis

Mad-Eye Moody wrote:Trade JPA and Lind for anything. Both these guys are below average players at their position. Arencibia is a liability defensively and Lind is a liability offensively. I'd be fine with Buck/Wilson to start the season, with D'Arnaud eventually taking over.

Reyes
Cabrera
Bautista
Encarnacion
Lawrie
Rasmus
D'Arnaud
Lind's replacement
Izturis

Buck sucks now. Sad thing is he is still better than JP. Wow.

http://www.fangraphs.com/statss.aspx?pl ... position=C

http://www.fangraphs.com/statss.aspx?pl ... position=C

Scientifically speaking, the bench has improved by 573.89%.

wow....this line up is so disgusting..lol.....im reading all the hate comments on mlb.com from other team fans...they think blue jays fans are overating players..hahaha

Agreed. I'd package JP up with a reliver and a youngster for another DH bat