Obviously the starting pitching spots are pretty obviously 1 guy (except Morrow/Happ), although I ranked by performance rather than current rotational order just so you can think about what's acceptable out of a first, second, etc...
I used ESPN's positional games played numbers to account for how to divide up multi-position players' stats. That means the percentages of a player per for positions are a little warped by mid-game changes, but it's the best solution I could come up with, short of actually scouring each boxscore for the position the player was in for each AB, which would be insane. Also, FIP is an averaged approximation for the relievers and the Morrow/Happ spot, but should be close enough.
Code: Select all
Fld PA OBP SLG OPS
C- 149 346 410 756
1B 153 344 450 794
2B 149 299 355 654
SS 138 250 279 529
3B 140 294 432 727
LF 160 356 515 871
CF 146 308 514 822
RF 147 514 522 937
DH 127 358 449 807
Code: Select all
Ptch IP/G ERA WHIP FIP
SP1 6.7 1.91 1.17 3.04
SP2 5.9 4.17 1.27 3.10
SP3 5.9 5.01 1.48 4.26
SP4 5.0 4.80 1.43 4.67
SP5 4.6 5.01 1.67 4.12
RHR 2.2 5.33 1.59 4.69
LHR 1.0 4.11 1.26 3.28
Obviously our OF is baller, our MI is horrifying and our RHR is the surprising disaster.
If McGowan/Happ/Stroman can start filling the 4th and 5th slots with more than 5IP/game, I think we'll see the relief problem correct, especially with a Janssen return.
I also think, allowing for league-average luck, potential increases from the under performers (Reyes, EE, Dickey) can counter balance the potential slowdowns of the hot hands (OF and Buehrle).
If we could just find someone half serviceable for 2B, honestly at this point Getz with a high .600's OPS might even be enough—although I kind of want to gag when I type that—just not the Goins/Diaz .200/.200/.400 club.