Post#8 » by Ed Wood » Tue Apr 17, 2007 8:40 pm
There are a few issues with the walk and strikeout numbers. To summarize, it's possible to be a relatively successful pitcher without managing even an average strikeout rate (meaning K/Inning pitched or per nine innings pitched). Two current examples of pitchers who have at times done so are Chin Ming Wang and Mark Buehrle. Generally pitchers who don't have the inclination or ability to retire batters by strikeout have to be exceptional in other areas in order to survive.
Pitchers who have pronounced ground ball tendencies, that is to say those off of whom many more ground balls are hit than fly balls, and as a result do not surrender very many home runs, can go as far as their infield defense and ability to keep the ball down will carry them. Derek Lowe has managed to be a very solid pitcher doing just that for a while now, and Brandon Webb is a pitcher who combines better strikeout numbers with his heavy sinker to overwhelm opposing batters.
Pitchers with excellent control can also carve out niches for themselves even without the ability to K many batters, though they have perhaps even less margin for error than their worm killing cousins. If a pitcher has great control but unimpressive stuff many major league hitters simply won't allow him to fool them with location and will instead look for mistake pitches while fouling off those offerings that are unattractive but within the strike zone. What's more pitchers who are hittable and also around the zone quite frequently almost always have problems with surrendering an unhealthy number of home runs. Pitching in RFK will help anyone in that regard but even so being consistently up in the strike zone is risky business. Consider this, the recently retired Brad Radke had almost supernatural control, statistically among the top three in the past three quarters of a century. And yet he wasn't an ace, even at his best, and he was susceptible to being hit very hard when his control wasn't absolutely perfect.
It's obviously bad to allow too many hitters to reach base via the base on balls, just consider Daniel Cabrera. If he could keep himself under control he'd be an absolute monster, but he can't and so he hasn't yet even proven himself to be a league average starter.
And, of course, there's the matter of the two in relation to each other. I've already been rambling too long so I'll just repeat that it's fairly important to strikeout significantly more batters than you walk.