Top 10 QB's

[bluejerseyjinx]

Top 10 QB's heading into 2025...project yours. These are the QB's I would most want on my team that contribute to winning...

I'm leaving rookies off mine...but you can add them.

1. Patrick Mahomes
2. Josh Allen
3. Lamar Jackson
4. Jayden Daniels
5. Jordan Love
6. Joe Burrow
7. Justin Herbert
8. Jalen Hurts
9. CJ Stroud
10. Bryce Young / Drake Maye / Trevor Lawrence

Based on contributing to winning, this is what I came up with after thinking about it for a day;

1. Showtime Mahomes. ( I mean, who wins more the past 8 years or so).
2. Joe Burrow. (Only QB in AFC that has beaten Mahomes in a playoff game besides Brady).
3. Josh Allen. ( Can't get by Mahomes in the biggest games but at least makes a couple AFC Championship games. Some can make a case that the coach
and teammates let him down in all but one of those situation).
4. Jaylen Hurts. ( Played in 2 super bowls, winning one. Pained me to post this one).
5. Matt Stafford. ( Besides Hurts, he is the only QB with a chip besides Hurts since Brady retired).
6. Lamar Jackson. ( When it comes to a regular season QB, is there a better one than Jackson and Mahomes).
7. Goff. ( This is where I have to put him if we are talking about winning. Got Rams to a super bowl and came up short last year. yes he played bad in
the NFC championship game, but come on guys, 9 starters where out on defense and he had to play from behind the whole game).
8. Jayden Daniels. ( Can't ignore what I witnessed from him last season).
9. C.J. Stroud. ( This is where I put CJ over some that may be more deserving in other's eyes. But at least I can say he has a playoff win under his belt
at a young age which is more than I can say about Dak Herbert).
10. Brock Purdy. ( What can I say. His numbers speak for themselves).

2 months later my list remains pretty much the same except two changes. Dropping out Jayden Daniels and Brock Purdy mostly due to injury and putting in Drake Maye and Jordan Love.

[Cactus Jack]

For me it goes back to his Giants days. Who actually got him his big contract? And who lead that team to the playoffs. Giants say Daniel Jones and paid him. Some say it was all Saquon Barkley. Similar here with the Colts. Who is the true MVP of that team, the QB play of Jones? Or is it Jomathan Taylor?

Jones is #4 overall in passing yardage with 13 passing TDs. It isn't like he is just handing it off to Taylor and not doing anything. Granted, Taylor is obviously a huge part of why that offense is #1 overall.

Jones sat behind Darnold last season & got to learn from one of the best. I guess if anyone deserves credit for his resurgence it's Sammy.

[Cactus Jack]

2 months later my list remains pretty much the same except two changes. Dropping out Jayden Daniels and Brock Purdy most due to injury and putting in Drake Maye and Jordan Love.

Stroud & Purdy shouldn't be anywhere near a top 10 list.

[bluejerseyjinx]

2 months later my list remains pretty much the same except two changes. Dropping out Jayden Daniels and Brock Purdy most due to injury and putting in Drake Maye and Jordan Love.

Stroud & Purdy shouldn't be anywhere near a top 10 list.

I believe Stroud will have a better second half of the season but really can't argue the point you are about to make. My top 7 remains the same but I can be flexible with the bottom 3.

[Cactus Jack]

2 months later my list remains pretty much the same except two changes. Dropping out Jayden Daniels and Brock Purdy most due to injury and putting in Drake Maye and Jordan Love.

Stroud & Purdy shouldn't be anywhere near a top 10 list.

I believe Stroud will have a better second half of the season but really can't argue the point you are about to make. My top 7 remains the same but I can be flexible with the bottom 3.

Stroud hasn't played well since his rookie season. He's been an average to below average starter.

[azcatz11]

2 months later my list remains pretty much the same except two changes. Dropping out Jayden Daniels and Brock Purdy most due to injury and putting in Drake Maye and Jordan Love.

Stroud & Purdy shouldn't be anywhere near a top 10 list.

I believe Stroud will have a better second half of the season but really can't argue the point you are about to make. My top 7 remains the same but I can be flexible with the bottom 3.

Please update the bottom 3 by EOD

[bluejerseyjinx]

Stroud & Purdy shouldn't be anywhere near a top 10 list.

I believe Stroud will have a better second half of the season but really can't argue the point you are about to make. My top 7 remains the same but I can be flexible with the bottom 3.

Please update the bottom 3 by EOD

I'm working on it. Much to consider.

[bluejerseyjinx]

Stroud & Purdy shouldn't be anywhere near a top 10 list.

I believe Stroud will have a better second half of the season but really can't argue the point you are about to make. My top 7 remains the same but I can be flexible with the bottom 3.

Stroud hasn't played well since his rookie season. He's been an average to below average starter.

I know. But every time I see a Houston game their O-line is just putrid. Seems they don't give him a chance half the time.

[El Turco]

For me it goes back to his Giants days. Who actually got him his big contract? And who lead that team to the playoffs. Giants say Daniel Jones and paid him. Some say it was all Saquon Barkley. Similar here with the Colts. Who is the true MVP of that team, the QB play of Jones? Or is it Jomathan Taylor?

Jones is #4 overall in passing yardage with 13 passing TDs. It isn't like he is just handing it off to Taylor and not doing anything. Granted, Taylor is obviously a huge part of why that offense is #1 overall.

Jones sat behind Darnold last season & got to learn from one of the best. I guess if anyone deserves credit for his resurgence it's Sammy.

Poor Daniel Jones is going to end up a bridge qb again

[El Turco]

2 months later my list remains pretty much the same except two changes. Dropping out Jayden Daniels and Brock Purdy most due to injury and putting in Drake Maye and Jordan Love.

Stroud & Purdy shouldn't be anywhere near a top 10 list.

Purdy would be a top 3 QB if he played Seahawks every game

[bluejerseyjinx]

Stroud & Purdy shouldn't be anywhere near a top 10 list.

I believe Stroud will have a better second half of the season but really can't argue the point you are about to make. My top 7 remains the same but I can be flexible with the bottom 3.

Please update the bottom 3 by EOD

After thinking about it. Dropping Stroud, Purdy and Daniels. Putting Maye, Mayfield and Love in the top 10. That will do. That's my current top 10.

[QB_Eagles]

After thinking about it. Dropping Stroud, Purdy and Daniels. Putting Maye, Mayfield and Love in the top 10. That will do. That's my current top 10.

Oh, how the turn tables...

1. Josh Allen
2. Patrick Mahomes
3. Lamar Jackson
4. Joe Burrow
5. Jalen Hurts
6. Jayden Daniels
7. Brock Purdy
8. Justin Herbert
9. Baker Mayfield
10. Jared Goff

Baker Mayfield and Dak Herbert,

[El Turco]

Drake Maye truther checking in. Where are we slotting him this season and moving forward?

Potential to be top 5, I like what I am seeing. He has great control of his arm strength, makes deep balls look so easy.

Probably borderline top ten right now.