Page 1 of 2
Where Will Alex Smith Go?
Posted: Sat Feb 2, 2013 9:39 pm
by JustAwesome
With the Super Bowl coming up, more and more people are paying attention to Alex Smith, who has shown a tremendous amount of maturity and professionalism this season after being benched by the San Francisco 49ers. He's already planning on leaving the franchise after the big game. Lots of teams have expressed interest in acquiring the veteran quarterback.
Where do you think he will land? Where should he go?
Re: Where Will Alex Smith Go?
Posted: Sat Feb 2, 2013 11:20 pm
by gswhoops
Well everyone knows what Smith is. He's a great game manager who will play solid, safe, mistake-free football but isn't likely to win too many games on his arm. He should go to a team with a strong running game and solid defense.
I think KC would be a good fit if they decide not to pick a QB with the 1st pick. They'd have a good line, a great RB in Charles and a solid enough D (assuming they add a few pieces). He would make the team respectable again and give them time to groom a QB for the future.
The Jets would also be a good fit IMO. Ryan is coaching for his job and Smith would be a welcome departure from a guy like Sanchez who can't hold on to the football. Minnesota would also be a good fit but I don't think they're ready to move on from Ponder just yet.
Other possibilities: Browns, Eagles, Cardinals.
Re: Where Will Alex Smith Go?
Posted: Sun Feb 3, 2013 12:36 am
by Jake0890
Jagurars, Eagles, Cardinals.
I don't see him fitting in with Andy Reid. Doubt he heads to KC.
Re: Where Will Alex Smith Go?
Posted: Sun Feb 3, 2013 6:44 am
by JustAwesome
Reid normally does the West Coast offense, so that suits Smith just fine. He only opened up the offense a big because Vick had a strong arm. If the Chiefs pick up Smith, then they'll go with a truer version of his offense.
Re: Where Will Alex Smith Go?
Posted: Sun Feb 3, 2013 5:38 pm
by gswhoops
Jake0890 wrote:Jagurars, Eagles, Cardinals.
I don't see him fitting in with Andy Reid. Doubt he heads to KC.
Really? I think Smith would be great in Andy Reid's offense. Emphasis on making short, quick passes with timing and accuracy which is pretty much Smith's best ability. Can move around a little bit, doesn't have to make too many deep throws.
Re: Where Will Alex Smith Go?
Posted: Mon Feb 4, 2013 4:53 am
by JustAwesome
Chiefs can also provide him with a good ground game to prevent him from having to win games with his arms.
Re: Where Will Alex Smith Go?
Posted: Mon Feb 4, 2013 5:31 am
by sprint2thecup
gswhoops wrote:Jake0890 wrote:Jagurars, Eagles, Cardinals.
I don't see him fitting in with Andy Reid. Doubt he heads to KC.
Really? I think Smith would be great in Andy Reid's offense. Emphasis on making short, quick passes with timing and accuracy which is pretty much Smith's best ability. Can move around a little bit, doesn't have to make too many deep throws.
yes, smith could run Reid's offense if he played that way. and he does suck at throwing deep, which is why it will never be enough. i like alex smith, but his best bet if he wants to see more football success is staying on the 49ers as a backup. i'm sure some team will take interest, so he won't have to do that if he doesn't want to.
Re: Where Will Alex Smith Go?
Posted: Mon Feb 4, 2013 2:30 pm
by gswhoops
sprint2thecup wrote:yes, smith could run Reid's offense if he played that way. and he does suck at throwing deep, which is why it will never be enough. i like alex smith, but his best bet if he wants to see more football success is staying on the 49ers as a backup. i'm sure some team will take interest, so he won't have to do that if he doesn't want to.
I would love to keep Alex as a backup, since he's pretty much the ideal backup QB (smart, great team guy, doesn't turn the ball over) but unless he's willing to take a serious pay cut it's not going to happen. Niners have too many other guys to worry about re-signing (Goldson, Anthony Davis, basically our entire D-line) to commit even $5M/yr to a backup QB.
I also think he wants to start, and rightfully so. He's better than a good chunk of the league's starters right now.
Re: Where Will Alex Smith Go?
Posted: Mon Feb 4, 2013 3:41 pm
by Icness
I think he either winds up in Oakland or KC, with JAX as the wild card
Re: Where Will Alex Smith Go?
Posted: Mon Feb 4, 2013 4:49 pm
by Nolan
KC seems like the best fit, but it all depends on what they do with the 1st overall pick.
Re: Where Will Alex Smith Go?
Posted: Mon Feb 4, 2013 5:24 pm
by Higga
Cardinals need a vet QB who can get the ball to Fitzgerald.
Re: Where Will Alex Smith Go?
Posted: Tue Feb 5, 2013 4:57 am
by JustAwesome
As much as the Niners would love to have someone like Smith as a backup quarterback, it's a situation that general managers are going to be wise to avoid. The guy believes that he can still play in this league. Hard to blame him, considering how well he did during the season. He shouldn't be content with a backup role. Allow him to leave.
Re: Where Will Alex Smith Go?
Posted: Tue Feb 5, 2013 7:22 pm
by Blank_Name
Alex Smith + Draft Picks for Revis.
Re: Where Will Alex Smith Go?
Posted: Tue Feb 5, 2013 11:24 pm
by JustAwesome
I don't think draft picks would be needed to make that deal happen. Keep in mind that the Jets desperately need to resolve their QB issue. Also, keep in mind that Revis is coming off of a serious injury and has contract issues. General managers factor that stuff in.
Re: Where Will Alex Smith Go?
Posted: Wed Feb 6, 2013 8:10 am
by LAKESHOW
Send his dumbass to the Chargers. Afterall, hes from San Diego.
Re: Where Will Alex Smith Go?
Posted: Wed Feb 6, 2013 10:24 am
by jr lucosa
I've been thinking the Jaguars would be the most sensible choice. If the Jets offer you Revis for the guy though you take that deal and run.
Re: Where Will Alex Smith Go?
Posted: Wed Feb 6, 2013 3:29 pm
by gswhoops
Blank_Name wrote:Alex Smith + Draft Picks for Revis.

That would be ideal IMO. Revis' cap hit would basically be absorbed by Smith + Rogers (who I assume we would cut, since he'd be absurdly expensive for a #4 CB) so it wouldn't effect our ability to resign guys too much down the road.
Re: Where Will Alex Smith Go?
Posted: Wed Feb 6, 2013 11:33 pm
by JustAwesome
Rogers needs to restructure that contract of his. He's on a good team, and the market isn't exactly begging for him.
Re: Where Will Alex Smith Go?
Posted: Tue Feb 12, 2013 1:37 pm
by gswhoops
Interesting take on how Vick staying in Philly effects the trade market for Smith.
http://www.businessinsider.com/49ers-se ... les-2013-2Right now Smith is the best option (and arguably the only option) on the market for teams in need of a proven veteran QB. More buyers than sellers = price goes up.
Re: Where Will Alex Smith Go?
Posted: Tue Feb 12, 2013 10:13 pm
by JustAwesome
I think it's actually good for the league that Flynn and Smith are going to be on different teams next season. They're quality quarterbacks, and they can help turn a franchise around. Seen far too many games where poor play from the position just made it not worthwhile to even watch.