RealGM

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2AADxslzVD8[/youtube]

Manning
Rodgers
Ryan
Brees
Stafford
Romo
Rivers
Brady
Luck
Newton
Wilson
Kaepernick

Off the top of my head in no particular order are better. So no, he's not.

I feel he got screwed by the 49ers and is better than Aaron Rodgers

tbennett5438 wrote:I feel he got screwed by the 49ers and is better than Aaron Rodgers

Epic troll post.

Maybe.... but i credit Andy Reid with the Chief's success more than Alex Smith.

Andy Reid has been known as a quarterback coach. Reid's failure in Phily comes from the fact that he is a horrible defensive coach and not able to bring in a good defensive coordinator.

I think Reid can make the 20th best QB look like the 10th best QB.

trwi7 wrote:Manning
Rodgers
Ryan
Brees
Stafford
Romo
Rivers
Brady
Luck
Newton
Wilson
Kaepernick

Off the top of my head in no particular order are better. So no, he's not.

he's better than romo & rivers : romo has a 20-19 record over the last 3 years & rivers has a 19-20 record while alex smith has a 26-5-1 record

He is not a top 10 QB, he is a game manager.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk - now Free

trwi7 wrote:

tbennett5438 wrote:I feel he got screwed by the 49ers and is better than Aaron Rodgers

Epic troll post.

Lol, nah man I'm for real. I feel if the roles has been reversed, Smith would have a better career than Rodgers. Smith went though five OC's in five years, while Rodgers sit back behind Favre and was on a better team.

i'd probably take him for the vikings

Disabled Sports wrote:

trwi7 wrote:Manning
Rodgers
Ryan
Brees
Stafford
Romo
Rivers
Brady
Luck
Newton
Wilson
Kaepernick

Off the top of my head in no particular order are better. So no, he's not.

he's better than romo & rivers : romo has a 20-19 record over the last 3 years & rivers has a 19-20 record while alex smith has a 26-5-1 record

One day people will look past individual record in a **** team game. What a glorious day that will be.

trwi7 wrote:

Disabled Sports wrote:

trwi7 wrote:Manning
Rodgers
Ryan
Brees
Stafford
Romo
Rivers
Brady
Luck
Newton
Wilson
Kaepernick

Off the top of my head in no particular order are better. So no, he's not.

he's better than romo & rivers : romo has a 20-19 record over the last 3 years & rivers has a 19-20 record while alex smith has a 26-5-1 record

One day people will look past individual record in a **** team game. What a glorious day that will be.

Same thing happens when comparing all time great qb's, all about super bowls


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk - now Free

Alex Smith is the prototype game manager. You look up game manager in the dictionary, you'll see a picture of Alex Smith. He's perfect for the Chiefs this year: rely on the run and let your dominant D win games. But that kind of team NEVER wins Super Bowls(unless your D is a best of all time candidate like the 85 Bears or 00 Ravens).

Also Andy Reid is a hell of a football coach. Dude always gets the most out of his QBs. I'm glad he's not in the NFC East anymore.

Jim harbaugh got him in shape before Reid, Reid just followed the suit kept him as a mistake free, minimal risk qb.

I think not having a big target going to haunt Smith come playoffs, many point saints game as a proof that he can win in playoffs but while he played good, that game wouldn't have been won if Vernon didn't have a helluva game

Sent from my HTC One using RealGM Forums mobile app

Higga wrote:Alex Smith is the prototype game manager. You look up game manager in the dictionary, you'll see a picture of Alex Smith. He's perfect for the Chiefs this year: rely on the run and let your dominant D win games. But that kind of team NEVER wins Super Bowls(unless your D is a best of all time candidate like the 85 Bears or 00 Ravens).

I agree with 90% of this, but I do think it's possible to win a SB with Alex Smith at the helm. I don't think the Chiefs are there yet though, they need a reliable short/intermediate range safety valve target for Smith and perhaps some upgrades along the offensive line.

fine. hes 10th place.