RealGM

Playoff games he should have lost but won:
Second playoff game in 2007 vs. Baltimore the year the Colts won the Super Bowl
The last two games of the playoffs this past season(again winning the Super Bowl)
Playoff games he should have won but lost:
2008 vs. Chargers(playing the 16-0 Patriots the following week)

Assuming he loses the games he should have lost, and wins the game he should have won(losing to the 16-0 Patriots the following week), his playoff record would be an embarassing 10-15. Zero Championships. What does this do to his legacy?

Sounds like a bunch of IFs to me. This stuff didn't happen and Manning won those games and those super bowls. And also it sounds like you were arguing with someone about Manning/Brady

i think this thread is embarrassing

no players walks around thinking about any past legacy.

he use to play ball,now he doesnt. Gotta go pick up the kids