RealGM

I think this has been done, but anyway I'll continue on with it. How would you rank all 32 Head Coaches in the league?

1. Jeff Fischer
2. Mike Shanahan
3. Bill B.
4. Mike Holmgren
5. Andy Reid
6.Tony Dungy
7. Lovie Smith
8. John Fox
9. Brian Billick
10. Sean Payton
11. Marvin Lewis
12. Eric Mangini
13. Joe Gibbs
14. Jack Del Rio
15. John Gruden
16. Herm Edwards
17. Tom Coughlin
18. Mike Nolan
19. Mike McCarthy
20. Marv Levy
21. Wade Phillips
22. Gary Kubiak
23. Rod Marinelli
24. Scott Linehan
25. Mike Tomlin
26. Lane Kiffin
27. Brad Childress
28. Romeo Crenel
29. Ken Wisenhunt
30. Bobby Petrino
31. Cam Cameron
32. Norv Turner

1. Tony Dungy
32. Herm Edwards

1. Bill Belichick
2. Jeff Fisher
3. Andy Reid
4. Tony Dungy
5. Mike Shanahan
6. Mike Holmgren
7. John Gruden
8. Brian Billick
9. Eric Mangini
10. Sean Payton
11. John Fox
12. Marvin Lewis
13. Gary Kubiak
14. Mike Nolan
15. Lovie Smith
16. Jack Del Rio
17. Wade Phillips
18. Joe Gibbs
19. Mike McCarthy
20. Scott Linehan
21. Dick Jauron
22. Rod Marinelli
23. Mike Tomlin
24. Lane Kiffin
25. Brad Childress
26. Romeo Crennell
27.Tom Coughlin
28. Ken Wisenhunt
29. Bobby Petrino
30. Cam Cameron
31. Herm Edwards
32. Norv Turner

I'd take BBJs list.

Everyone else >>> Tom Coughlin

1.Jeff Fisher
2.Tony Dungy
3.Mike Holmgren
4.Mike Shanahan
5.Brian Billick
6.Andy Reid
7.Bill Belichick
8.John Fox
9.Lovie Smith
10. Eric Mangini
11.Jon Gruden
12.Joe Gibbs
13.Mike Tomlin
14.Mike Nolan
15.Jack Del Rio
16.Marvin Lewis
17.Gary Kubiak
18.Wade Phillips
19.Mike McCarthy
20.Brad Childress
21.Dick Jauron
22.Sean Payton
23.Romeo Crennell
24.Lane Kiffin
25.Rod Marinelli
26.Scott Linehan
27.Ken Wisenhunt
28.Bobby Petrino
29.Tom Coughlin
30.Herm Edwards
31.Cam Cameron
32.Norv Turner

tony dungy must be in top 3 in my opinion.

Why is that?

1. Bill Belichick
2. Mike Shanahan
3. Brian Billick
4. Jeff Fisher
5. Tony Dungy
6. Mike Holmgren
7. Andy Reid
8. Jon Gruden
9. Mike McCarthy
10. Mike Tomlin
11. John Fox
12. Wade Phillips
13. Sean Payton
14. Gary Kubiak
15. Mike Nolan
16. Eric Mangini
17. Joe Gibbs
18. Lane Kiffin
19. Ken Whisenhunt
20. Scott Linehan
21. Herm Edwards
22. Marvin Lewis
23. Tom Coughlin
24. Jack Del Rio
25. Lovie Smith
26. Dick Jauron
27. Rod Marinelli
28. Bobby Petrino
29. Brad Childress
30. Cam Cameron
31. Romeo Crennel
32. Norv Turner

Edit--too much love for Nolan, not enough for McCarthy

Looks to me like there is no consensus #1, but Norv Turner is definately the consensus #32. LOL.

Really... have people forgotten about Wade Phillips and Buffalo?

Dallas is good, but I don't trust Wade Phillips...He should be lower IMO...

J.Kim wrote:Really... have people forgotten about Wade Phillips and Buffalo?

Dallas is good, but I don't trust Wade Phillips...He should be lower IMO...

He's the perfect guy for that team though. Perhaps he learned from his mistakes. Once upon a time most everyone in Cleveland laughed out loud at New England for hiring Belichick after his disastrous run with the Browns.

Not that I'm saying...I'm just saying...

J.Kim wrote:Really... have people forgotten about Wade Phillips and Buffalo?

Dallas is good, but I don't trust Wade Phillips...He should be lower IMO...

Eh, everybody from #10 down is interchangeable on my list.

J.Kim wrote:Really... have people forgotten about Wade Phillips and Buffalo?

Dallas is good, but I don't trust Wade Phillips...He should be lower IMO...

i think he's a little overly criticized, he has a winning record as a coach (i think over 12 games too) and has made the playoffs with 2 teams (granted he's 0-3 in the playoffs) but i can understand why you'd question him after shocking everyone with replacing flutie w/johnson

but maybe thats the homer in me, plus as long as Jason Garrett keeps calling the shots on offense I can't complain.

I really want to hear everyone's reasoning on why Norv Turner is a consensus #32.

I don't disagree, but is it just that he has failed to use the best player in football the right way, or is it something else?

^I think it's the first reason.

gunnabdaschwab09 wrote:I really want to hear everyone's reasoning on why Norv Turner is a consensus #32.

I don't disagree, but is it just that he has failed to use the best player in football the right way, or is it something else?

I think its because hes a proven loser. He sucked with the Redskins, sucked with the Raiders and now doing the same with the talented Chargers.

Hes just not a HC. It might be my bias because I've hated him ever since he started coaching the Skins. IMO, an absolute tool on the sidelines and a terrible locker room manager. He does a terrible job of keeping the locker room united.

Icness wrote:1. Bill Belichick
2. Mike Shanahan
3. Brian Billick
4. Jeff Fisher
5. Tony Dungy
6. Mike Holmgren
7. Andy Reid
8. Jon Gruden
9. Mike McCarthy
10. Mike Tomlin
11. John Fox
12. Wade Phillips
13. Sean Payton
14. Gary Kubiak
15. Mike Nolan
16. Eric Mangini
17. Joe Gibbs
18. Lane Kiffin
19. Ken Whisenhunt
20. Scott Linehan
21. Herm Edwards
22. Marvin Lewis
23. Tom Coughlin
24. Jack Del Rio
25. Lovie Smith
26. Dick Jauron
27. Rod Marinelli
28. Bobby Petrino
29. Brad Childress
30. Cam Cameron
31. Romeo Crennel
32. Norv Turner

Edit--too much love for Nolan, not enough for McCarthy

Billick at three?

icness, why do you have lovie smith at 25?