DetroitSho wrote:Manocad wrote:Invictus88 wrote:
It's hard.
Earlier this season he was the #1 option and did dominate possessions. They would end as soon as he got the ball as he went iso for long stretches. At first it was out of pure necessity; then there was this weird dichotomy of usage between him and Cade as Cade started to come into his own.
It's pretty much irrefutable that the ball movement significantly improved when he left and our young guys took big steps forward.
The big question is what would happen if he comes back. Do the Pistons largely regress to what they were previously or do Grant and those playing around him adjust with Grant assuming a more peripheral role?
I think either is plausible. I do think that there is significant risk to the Pistons future if it regresses backward. I also think that Grant's trade value is at risk to go way down as well. It's for those reasons I'd prefer if he was traded before he came back.
I do also think that we as a franchise have much more to benefit from this clearly becoming Cade's team and him developing into and playing the prominent superstar role. It's not a guarantee but he's definitely tracking that way.
I think it's also apparent that if that happens then he will get the others on the court involved in the offense. That's just his play style. He is an astronomically better playmaker / distributor than Grant.
While I don't think any of what you wrote is implausible, I will say it completely overlooks the idea that Grant can and is willing to adapt his style of play to benefit the team.
What I'll add is a general comment in the same vein...stop with the BS of "Jerami came here to be THE MAN and there's no way he'd accept a diminished role, blah blah blah." No one knows what Jerami is thinking or will/won't accept or adapt to. Look at it this way--even with Diallo and Bey starting to ramp things up, what's everyone still saying? The team needs another star-level player to team with Cade. Why can't that be Grant? Who says the team can't be successful with a core of Cade, Diallo, Bey, Grant, and a serviceable center, or ultimately even a star center? Cade is already doing his thing, Diallo is too, Bey is still hitting 3's but trying to score more in iso situations and he is NOT as good at it as Grant--PERIOD. So keep Bey doing what he does best, shooting 3's, and keep Grant doing what he does best which is taking guys one on one. Obviously that doesn't mean that's all either of them will do, i.e. Bey's man bodies him up so he takes it to the rack or Grant's man sags off him so he takes a jumper, but I don't think it's ridiculous to assume that a Cade/Diallo/Bey/Grant core isn't capable of putting up their current averages every night while playing together. Now, does that assume Grant may have to swallow some ego and buy into the team concept for the greater good? Sure. But that's required for EVERY high level team these days since more and more the best teams are made up of multiple stars.
Don't forget, "black city, black coach, blah blah blah". You pretty much covered it, nobody's refuting the ball movement has changed...duh. The Warriors ball movement was better whenever Durant was out of the lineup. When you have a guy with iso ability miss significant time and you provide more opportunities to your mostly catch and shoot guys, ummm yeah, ball movement will increase. Those guys generally hot potato the ball if they don't an immediate shot on the catch. Nobody's refuting that it's moved better since he's been out. I'm refuting that he's unwilling or unable to fit into the better ball movement.
You swapped out a guy in Grant who was heavy on iso and inserted the guy that moves without the ball the most of anybody on the team in Diallo. Yeah I'd like to see that guy WITH Grant. Can you imagine if Bey was still shooting the same as he was prior to Grant going down? We wouldn't be having this convo.
Sent from my SM-N975U using
RealGM mobile app
Replying to DetroitSho:
So... with Grant in the lineup prior to injury: ball movement was worse, Bey iso'd more and shot worse.
And then when Grant left, Diallo came in and distributed the ball better, played well off-ball. Bey iso'd less and shot more catch and shoot threes... and shot them better.
This is what I am hearing you say. Just making sure.
Because then why would you want to put Grant back in the lineup at all?
The Durant mention with the Warriors isn't relevant. If Grant shot the ball like Durant then nobody would be having any conversation about anything; because most possessions would end up with made field goal attempts and we'd be winning basketball games.
It isn't a coincidence that Bey started shooting better after Grant went down. There was better ball movement. He didn't to try to get shots off from iso situations as much. He could instead move to an open space and someone on the team would find him. The team was more in rhythm and it's easier to shoot in that type of environment.
Other Notes in reply to Manocad:
While it's fairly reasonable to posit that Grant may adapt his playing style from this point forward to adapt to the growth of the young guys and spread the ball around more, it's completely accurate to say that he was
not doing this up to the point in which he was injured. The difference in ball movement was stark and came instantaneously afterwards. That's the closest to actual data that we have. It can definitely change to go the other way. There's just not precedent for it on the Pistons where it has been stated that he came here to be The Guy.
I haven't really seen much in the way of synergy between Cade and Grant's play styles thus far. That isn't to say that it won't develop in the future. However, if anything it has clashed up until this point. Cade standing around watching while Grant dribbles the ball in isolation for 10 seconds and hoisting up shots isn't synergy.
I don't buy at all the idea that it is a good thing for our team to have Grant constantly taking guys one on one as is stated above. If anything Grant has been a huge letdown in terms of delivering iso baskets this year in the clutch. Rather than have the offense in such situations stagnate I'd much rather have someone like Cade take it and distribute elsewhere after drawing defenders.
Bey wasn't doing what he does best when Grant was on the floor with him. I think there's a direct correlation there in terms of ball movement that allows Bey the freedom to benefit from more passing; instead of devolving into iso ball all of the time.
I don't know if I really have the motivation to go back and forth in a long discussion about this stuff though. I think I've said what I wanted to say. Thanks for reading and responding.