RealGM

I've been offered two different trades by the same person...

Trade A:

(my) Clinton Portis and Lee Evans for (his) Steve Smith (NY) and Fred Jackson.

I have depth at the RB position with mendenhall/pierre thomas/jacobs/portis/hardesty

Trade B:

(my) Andre Johnson and Pierre Thomas for (his) Ray Rice and Percy Harvin

Standard Scoring 6pts per TD, 1pt for 10 yrds rush/15yrds rec.

I think I take trade A. What do you think?

I'm not sure I take either one...

I chose A as well, I have rice as well but I dont see much out of Harvin, at least consistently, his migrane issue is already a big problem and that issue cause him to miss alot of games last year too.

LApwnd wrote:I chose A as well, I have rice as well but I dont see much out of Harvin, at least consistently, his migrane issue is already a big problem and that issue cause him to miss alot of games last year too.

With sidney rice out for extended time Harvin may put up some nice numbers

^^^not if he's always having his migrane issues, also Minn signed Walker and traded for Camarillo, farve will have a few guys to throw too and just means more work load for AP as well, which is good for me lol.

I might do A

Wouldn't touch B for anything

neither