RealGM

Buddy in my league offered me Vick for Mendhenhall straight up, would you do it.

I got Romo and Kolb as my quarterbacks right now and my running back depth is pretty decent.

right now I got McFadden, Mendenhall, Beanie Wells as my 3 runningbacks I play each week and on my bench I got Brandon Jacobs, and Mark Ingram.

Not really counting on Ingram but I figured that If i lose Mendenhall and gain Vick I can plug Beanie as my number 2 back and Jacobs as my flex let me know what you think.

That leaves you thin at RB and you have two QB's that are going to put up points. Not sure I'd do it although it is tempting.

If you do want to do it since he offered try to get him to take a QB back, I'm sure he already has a good one if he's offering Vick but you don't need 3 and get depth at WR or a lower tier RB that can be used in bye weeks or in favorable matchups.

MetroDrugUnit wrote:That leaves you thin at RB and you have two QB's that are going to put up points. Not sure I'd do it although it is tempting.

If you do want to do it since he offered try to get him to take a QB back, I'm sure he already has a good one if he's offering Vick but you don't need 3 and get depth at WR or a lower tier RB that can be used in bye weeks or in favorable matchups.

I agree, make it a 4 player deal and send a QB his way, if you dont you will just drop Kolb and get nothing for him. I would try to get another RB if I was you. If u can drag the trade out through this week so u can keep Mendenhall since he plays Indy this week.