me vs my friend in same league....which team is stronger?

Shady Franchise · Post #1 » by **Shady Franchise** » Sat Jul 28, 2007 9:47 pm

QB1-#25 young
QB2-#144 garcia
QB3-#168 last pick of draft Vick
RB1- #1 LT
RB2-#24 mcgahee
RB3-#49 cadillac williams
WR1-#48.colston
WR2-#72 Branch
WR3-#96 chambers
WR4-#121 hackett
WR5-#145 jarrett
TE1-#73 vernon davis
DST1-#97 dolphins
K1-#120 akers

VS

QB1-#55 hasselbeck
QB2-#66 romo
RB1-#7 gore
RB2-#18 henry
RB3-#31 edge james
RB4-#114 deAngelo Williams
WR1-#42 andre johnson
WR2-#90 galloway
WR3-#103 cotchery
WR4-#138 drew bennett
TE1-#79 cooley
K1-#127 neil rackers
K2-#162 nedney
DST1-#151 cowboys

UrbanLegendMD · Post #2 » by **UrbanLegendMD** » Sat Jul 28, 2007 11:37 pm

Top roster. LDT + Norv Turner = Fantasy Awesomness

Shady Franchise · Post #3 » by **Shady Franchise** » Sun Jul 29, 2007 6:51 pm

its a h2h 12 team.....besides drafting Young so damn early (3rd) round (i was pressured with the 90 seconds :wink:

) what other picks were too early, or a steal?

UrbanLegendMD · Post #4 » by **UrbanLegendMD** » Mon Jul 30, 2007 12:36 am

Caddy as a 3rd RB is a steal. Miami's aging defense will get dropped. Young at 25 will be a huge bust. Look into some QB trades cause it's the position that will plague you the whole year.

Monkeyfeng06 · Post #5 » by **Monkeyfeng06** » Mon Jul 30, 2007 12:51 am

i like the second team better. first time's QB is meh....

UrbanLegendMD · Post #6 » by **UrbanLegendMD** » Mon Jul 30, 2007 1:19 am

Monkeyfeng06 wrote:i like the second team better. first time's QB is meh....

Yeah I looked over the first roster and this guy may suck even with LT on his team.

Shady Franchise · Post #7 » by **Shady Franchise** » Tue Jul 31, 2007 7:28 pm

young/garcia <hasselbeck/romo
garcia was a steal, he'll be starting, hasselbeck is injury prone...I dont see the QB situation that much better

LT/mcgahee/cadillac>>>>gore/henry/james/williams
gore just broke his hand....slow start to season, mcgahee was a bigger steal than cadillac I think with the 24th pick

colston/branch/chambers/hackett/jarrett>>johnson/galloway/cotchery/bennett
Three starting #1 WRs in colston/branch/chambers vs two in Johnson/galloway

vernon davis>cooley
davis's potential alone puts hims ahead, at worst they are =

dolphins DST >> Dallas
Dolphins DST ranked in the top 7 in fantasy sports in all rankings i have seen, dallas ranked 15-19

akers = rackers

I dont see how team two can possibly be better just because of the QB situation team 1 has. Team 1 has a more balanced team.

Shady Franchise · Post #8 » by **Shady Franchise** » Tue Jul 31, 2007 7:32 pm

Plus if you checked the bye weeks like i did for the teams....

romo and hasselbeck have the same by week

i believe gore and henry or gore/edge have the same bye week

all of his starting WR's johnson/galloway/cotchery have the same bye week

...Team 2 is by far in a worse position than team 1

UrbanLegendMD · Post #9 » by **UrbanLegendMD** » Tue Jul 31, 2007 10:20 pm

It's not important. Are you trying to win here? Garcia is 37 and plays for the Bucs. He is no #2, potential #1. Young will have weeks when he puts up very mediocre f#'s. You win with RB's and QB's. Your RB's are dominant, but QB's are questionable. My advice is ship Caddy for a decent QB.

Shady Franchise · Post #10 » by **Shady Franchise** » Wed Aug 1, 2007 5:32 am

It's not important. Are you trying to win here? Garcia is 37 and plays for the Bucs. He is no #2, potential #1. Young will have weeks when he puts up very mediocre f#'s. You win with RB's and QB's. Your RB's are dominant, but QB's are questionable. My advice is ship Caddy for a decent QB.

thanks i appreciate the advice. Last year I had my qbs as vick and eli manning, who were both iratic throughout the season. I also had shaun alexander and we all know what happened to him. Regardless I still made it to the championship game. I dont think im in that much of trouble, but some guy just posted his on the block list and kitna and big ben are listed on it. I'll throw him an offer for kitna.