Should i do this trade?

CDB · Post #1 » by **CDB** » Wed Sep 12, 2007 4:45 pm

So me and this guy was working on this deal and I was wondering should I do Marvin Harrison for Willis McGahee. Without Harrison I would have Boldin and and Branch and my recivers. Now I have Caddilac Williams and Shaun Alexander as my RB's.

So should I?

And also in that trade should I trade Rex ughman for Jeff Garcia or Chad Pennington (who is most likely not going to play next week). Im leaning towards Garcia.

PistonFan4Life · Post #2 » by **PistonFan4Life** » Wed Sep 12, 2007 5:19 pm

CDB wrote:So me and this guy was working on this deal and I was wondering should I do Marvin Harrison for Willis McGahee. Without Harrison I would have Boldin and and Branch and my recivers. Now I have Caddilac Williams and Shaun Alexander as my RB's.

So should I?

And also in that trade should I trade Rex ughman for Jeff Garcia or Chad Pennington (who is most likely not going to play next week). Im leaning towards Garcia.

I would say no to the first trade. Harrison has too much value to trade straight up for McGahee, at least that my opinion. I think Boldin will be ok, but I'm not so sure how consistent Branch will be, so your better off with Harrison and Boldin in the 1 and 2 spots at WR.

I might do the QB trade. I don't like Grossman at all, I think Pennington will be fine once he is healthy again, but depending on who you have starting I would say all 3 QBs are backups in fantasy so its not a big deal to trade Rex for either one of those QBs.

CDB · Post #3 » by **CDB** » Wed Sep 12, 2007 5:31 pm

what about a counter trade of Grosman and Harrison for Pennington, Mcgahee and a filler.

QB - Palmer, Garcia, Pennington
WR - Calvin Johnson, Greg Jennings, Jason Avant, Anthony Gonzalez, Joe Jurevicius
RB - McGahee, Marion-Barber, Deshaun Foster, Jamal Lewis
TE - Gates, Dallas Clark

What filler should I go with?

BTW Peyton Manning is my #1 QB

ChronicKerr · Post #4 » by **ChronicKerr** » Wed Sep 12, 2007 6:36 pm

i would try to get one of his WR's in return as filler since you'd be giving up your best WR. Do you play three or two WR's each week?

CDB · Post #5 » by **CDB** » Wed Sep 12, 2007 8:52 pm

well I just did a deal
Ughman, Harrison, Michael Turner and Williams

for

McGahee, Pennington, Jamal Lewis, Greg Jennings

Wizards2Lottery · Post #6 » by **Wizards2Lottery** » Wed Sep 12, 2007 10:02 pm

CDB wrote:well I just did a deal
Ughman, Harrison, Michael Turner and Williams

for

McGahee, Pennington, Jamal Lewis, Greg Jennings

You got raped

b_roy7 · Post #7 » by **b_roy7** » Wed Sep 12, 2007 11:49 pm

Gilbert0Arenas wrote:-= original quote snipped =-

You got raped

No kidding. One of the best recievers for 2 average RB's..

theonlyeastcoastrapsfan · Post #8 » by **theonlyeastcoastrapsfan** » Thu Sep 13, 2007 2:05 am

I'm thinking of offering C. Benson and Steve Smith for Plaxico and Roy Williams. Good move, I have a surplus of Backs and want to shore up my recieving lines up of Calvin Johson, Brandon Marshall, Cotchery and Ronald Curry, and Smith. We play two back and three receivers each week.

CDB · Post #9 » by **CDB** » Thu Sep 13, 2007 3:01 am

b_roy7 wrote:-= original quote snipped =-

No kidding. One of the best recievers for 2 average RB's..

My RB lineup now looks like this: Alexander, McGahee, Lewis, Adrian Peterson.

And I also needed to get rid of Grosman.

Post #10 » by **sunshinekids99** » Thu Sep 13, 2007 3:08 am

See if there is any weak team in RB's. Maybe you can package Willis and Grossman for a better option at QB.