RealGM

standard yahoo stuff

2 rb spots, 3 WR, and 2 W/R

my team:

QB Kurt Warner
WR Chad Johnson
WR Eddie Royal
WR Roy Williams
RB Frank Gore
RB Clinton Portis
TE

W/R Steve Slaton
W/R Rudi Johnson
K Neil Rackers
DEF Baltimore

bench: heath, holt, norwood, rivers, sproles, hilliard

my WR are trash

here is the offer: i give up warner and portis
and get Osullivan, Jones-Drew, Deangelo Williams, and C Chambers

i give up 2 quality starters for some depth at the W/R and WR spot

shoud i do it?

thanks!

U can start Rivers in for Warner, so thats not bad.


I am a die-hard Jags fan, and i am unsure about MJD. This week they play Denver (sucks vs run), and they should be getting their starting center back, and another lineman in a few weeks. Deangelo williams will never have another game like last week, and Chambers is a question mark.

And thats Torry Holt on your bench? I know him and Ocho Cinco have had rough starts, but id rather have them than Chambers.

And Portis is like a top 3-5 back right now. The fact you have Gore/Portis tells me your league is either dumb, or you traded for one. And slaton is HUGE right now.

I would not do this trade man. I mean, you are washing with Rivers/Warner, but you have to look at it this way : Portis/Royal or Holt/Rudi Johnson for MJD/Williams/Chambers.

I would take the 1st combo. And i would start Holt in for Rudi Johnson.