ImageImageImageImageImage

Who starts?

Moderators: Sleepy51, Chris Porter's Hair, floppymoose

Starters

Melton
18
13%
Wiggins
34
25%
Podz
15
11%
Kuminga
29
21%
Moody
7
5%
Loon
4
3%
Hield
4
3%
Tjd
26
19%
 
Total votes: 137

Crazy-Canuck
RealGM
Posts: 29,129
And1: 7,288
Joined: Nov 24, 2003

Who starts? 

Post#1 » by Crazy-Canuck » Fri Sep 20, 2024 1:11 pm

We have 2 guys locked in steph and dray.

Melton is my sg if healthy

Great defender at poa and he's hovered around 40% from 3 the last 4 years at around 5 3pta per game.

Wiggins is my SF

We now know why he's been mentally checked out the last 2 years. I want to believe kerr left him at poa so he can be more engaged instead of thinking about his dad.

Great off ball wing stopper. He's also shot near 40% from 3 the last 4 years at 5 3pta per game.

Tjd is my C

Only rim protector we have and is a vertical floor spacer. We can't have dray be a full time C all season.
User avatar
Onus
RealGM
Posts: 22,808
And1: 6,911
Joined: May 12, 2008
Location: NOA

Re: Who starts? 

Post#2 » by Onus » Fri Sep 20, 2024 3:56 pm

Who starts?
Wiggins, Podz, TJD

Who should start?
Wiggins, TJD, Melton

Who should close?
I really want to see Wiggins, 2 of these 3 Melton, Moody or JK, unless Podz really is able to get up 8 3s a game and maintain his percentage then maybe add him to the mix as well.
Most 4th Quarter Points in Final since 1991
1995 Shaquille O'Neal 11.5
2000 Shaquille O'Neal 11.5 (61.1% TS)
2015 Stephen Curry 10.8 (75.1% TS)
1997 Michael Jordan 10.7 (55.1% TS)
1998 Michael Jordan 10.6 (50.6% TS)
2011 Dirk Nowitzki 10.3 (68.0% TS)
S-Gorilla86
Sophomore
Posts: 100
And1: 73
Joined: Aug 27, 2020
       

Re: Who starts? 

Post#3 » by S-Gorilla86 » Fri Sep 20, 2024 4:17 pm

Steph
Melton
Wiggins
JK
Dray

Sent from my SM-S906U using RealGM mobile app
User avatar
whatisacenter
RealGM
Posts: 12,797
And1: 14,988
Joined: Aug 05, 2013
 

Re: Who starts? 

Post#4 » by whatisacenter » Fri Sep 20, 2024 4:32 pm

what a depressing exercise.

I would go:

Steph
Wiggins
Moody
Jk
TJD

What I think it will be:

Steph
Podz
Wiggins
Dray
TJD
Madvillain been as high as Kathmandu
And tilted to the side like that fat man's shoe
User avatar
B-King
Rookie
Posts: 1,100
And1: 233
Joined: Jan 05, 2015
       

Re: Who starts? 

Post#5 » by B-King » Fri Sep 20, 2024 6:21 pm

Melton, Kuminga and TJD. I would bring Wiggins off the bench for now. It would be a shame to see Kuminga take a nose dive starting the game on the bench. He's been here and deserves the opportunity/support to earn the big bag or maybe realize he needs to take a slightly smaller bag.
User avatar
Jester_
General Manager
Posts: 9,898
And1: 1,485
Joined: Mar 25, 2011

Re: Who starts? 

Post#6 » by Jester_ » Fri Sep 20, 2024 7:11 pm

if we aren't starting kumbuckets this season is pointless
GQ Hot Dog wrote:Kerr has done more with the least talent available of any coach in the history of the game.
CDM_Stats
General Manager
Posts: 9,055
And1: 2,811
Joined: Oct 03, 2022
 

Re: Who starts? 

Post#7 » by CDM_Stats » Fri Sep 20, 2024 7:32 pm

If they want to win:

Steph
Melton
Wiggins
Dray
TJD
(Note that although Podz/JK would be off the bench, they’d likely get more mins than 1-3 starters


What I expect due to Kerr being as vanilla as possible:

Curry
Podz
Wiggins
Kuminga
Dray
jaymo123
Veteran
Posts: 2,730
And1: 1,016
Joined: Mar 10, 2012

Re: Who starts? 

Post#8 » by jaymo123 » Fri Sep 20, 2024 7:42 pm

Curry
Kuminga
Wiggins
Draymond
TJD
CDM_Stats
General Manager
Posts: 9,055
And1: 2,811
Joined: Oct 03, 2022
 

Re: Who starts? 

Post#9 » by CDM_Stats » Fri Sep 20, 2024 8:05 pm

As far as a full rotation, I think it should be basically a decision tree, especially at backup SF and backup C.. but ideally for me, for both halves:

Curry/Melton/Wiggins/Dray/TJD to start

at Q1 6:00, bring in Podz for Melton and bring in JK for Dray
Curry/Podz/Wiggins/JK/TJD

at 3:00, bring in SloMo for TJD, Moody for Wiggins, Hield for Curry
Podz/Hield/Moody/JK/SloMo

at Q2 9:00 bring in Dray for JK, Melton for Hield
Podz/Melton/Moody/Dray/SloMo

at 6:00 bring in Steph for Podz, GP2 for Moody, JK for Looney
Curry/Melton/GP2/JK/Dray

at 3:00 bring in Wiggins for GP2,and Podz for Melton
Curry/Podz/Wiggins/JK/Dray

If rigidly following this, full-game minutes are

Curry (30) / Podz (18)
Melton (24) / Hield (12) / Podz (12)
Wiggins (24) / Moody (18) / GP2 (6)
Dray (18) / Kuminga (30)
TJD (18) / SloMo (18) / Dray (12)

The C position (TJD/SloMo/Looney) and the SF position (Wiggins/Moody/GP2) should be more of a hot-hand approach. But the 4 guys leading in minutes would be Curry/Dray/Podz/JK with Melton and Wiggins in the 2nd tier. 3rd tier is Moody, TJD, SloMo and Hield. 5th tier is GP2/Looney
all left
Ballboy
Posts: 26
And1: 16
Joined: Aug 28, 2014
 

Re: Who starts? 

Post#10 » by all left » Fri Sep 20, 2024 9:18 pm

CDM_Stats wrote:As far as a full rotation, I think it should be basically a decision tree, especially at backup SF and backup C.. but ideally for me, for both halves:

Curry/Melton/Wiggins/Dray/TJD to start

at Q1 6:00, bring in Podz for Melton and bring in JK for Dray
Curry/Podz/Wiggins/JK/TJD

at 3:00, bring in SloMo for TJD, Moody for Wiggins, Hield for Curry
Podz/Hield/Moody/JK/SloMo

at Q2 9:00 bring in Dray for JK, Melton for Hield
Podz/Melton/Moody/Dray/SloMo

at 6:00 bring in Steph for Podz, GP2 for Moody, JK for Looney
Curry/Melton/GP2/JK/Dray

at 3:00 bring in Wiggins for GP2,and Podz for Melton
Curry/Podz/Wiggins/JK/Dray

If rigidly following this, full-game minutes are

Curry (30) / Podz (18)
Melton (24) / Hield (12) / Podz (12)
Wiggins (24) / Moody (18) / GP2 (6)
Dray (18) / Kuminga (30)
TJD (18) / SloMo (18) / Dray (12)

The C position (TJD/SloMo/Looney) and the SF position (Wiggins/Moody/GP2) should be more of a hot-hand approach. But the 4 guys leading in minutes would be Curry/Dray/Podz/JK with Melton and Wiggins in the 2nd tier. 3rd tier is Moody, TJD, SloMo and Hield. 5th tier is GP2/Looney


I like these rotations, except maybe for that which begins at 3 minutes left in the first quarter. That's the only lineup that lacks Steph but also doesn't have three proven top level defensive players. Perhaps the assumption is that that lineup mostly will face similar mixes of starters and rotation players at that time in most games. Or maybe you have more confidence in Moody than I have, but he hasn't quite shown me enough yet (not his fault, perhaps, but nonetheless).

If they are hoping for a playoff spot in a tough West, I would find a way to get Melton a few more minutes than you have allotted in the first part of the season, if he is healthy. He is a proven defender and his 3 point shooting hovers close to 40%. Then see which among the young guys really is taking a step up, particularly on the defensive end, and then perhaps remix.
watch1958
General Manager
Posts: 8,602
And1: 1,368
Joined: Aug 03, 2001

Re: Who starts? 

Post#11 » by watch1958 » Sat Sep 21, 2024 2:46 am

I’d rotate Moody Wiggins and Melton as starters at 2-3. Have each start 2/3 games, then totally sit out the third. Lets each get real run when starting, and gives you a more useful bench if you aren’t trying to squeeze Moses in for 18 minutes.

Lets you see who is really doing well. Also lets you prop up trade value in the first couple of months for a bunch of guys.

Won’t ever happen,
This movie is like the Rocky Horror Picture Show where everyone knows all the lines.
CDM_Stats
General Manager
Posts: 9,055
And1: 2,811
Joined: Oct 03, 2022
 

Re: Who starts? 

Post#12 » by CDM_Stats » Sat Sep 21, 2024 2:52 am

all left wrote:
CDM_Stats wrote:As far as a full rotation, I think it should be basically a decision tree, especially at backup SF and backup C.. but ideally for me, for both halves:

Curry/Melton/Wiggins/Dray/TJD to start

at Q1 6:00, bring in Podz for Melton and bring in JK for Dray
Curry/Podz/Wiggins/JK/TJD

at 3:00, bring in SloMo for TJD, Moody for Wiggins, Hield for Curry
Podz/Hield/Moody/JK/SloMo

at Q2 9:00 bring in Dray for JK, Melton for Hield
Podz/Melton/Moody/Dray/SloMo

at 6:00 bring in Steph for Podz, GP2 for Moody, JK for Looney
Curry/Melton/GP2/JK/Dray

at 3:00 bring in Wiggins for GP2,and Podz for Melton
Curry/Podz/Wiggins/JK/Dray

If rigidly following this, full-game minutes are

Curry (30) / Podz (18)
Melton (24) / Hield (12) / Podz (12)
Wiggins (24) / Moody (18) / GP2 (6)
Dray (18) / Kuminga (30)
TJD (18) / SloMo (18) / Dray (12)

The C position (TJD/SloMo/Looney) and the SF position (Wiggins/Moody/GP2) should be more of a hot-hand approach. But the 4 guys leading in minutes would be Curry/Dray/Podz/JK with Melton and Wiggins in the 2nd tier. 3rd tier is Moody, TJD, SloMo and Hield. 5th tier is GP2/Looney


I like these rotations, except maybe for that which begins at 3 minutes left in the first quarter. That's the only lineup that lacks Steph but also doesn't have three proven top level defensive players. Perhaps the assumption is that that lineup mostly will face similar mixes of starters and rotation players at that time in most games. Or maybe you have more confidence in Moody than I have, but he hasn't quite shown me enough yet (not his fault, perhaps, but nonetheless).

If they are hoping for a playoff spot in a tough West, I would find a way to get Melton a few more minutes than you have allotted in the first part of the season, if he is healthy. He is a proven defender and his 3 point shooting hovers close to 40%. Then see which among the young guys really is taking a step up, particularly on the defensive end, and then perhaps remix.


There's probably a way around it, but I like having a chunk of time where younger/less appreciated players can step up. That would be Podz, Moody and JK's time to step up while having a spacer in Hield and a good floor guy like SloMo there. Moody is one of the more underappreciated guys in the league - per minute, he's brought more +/- impact than JK, yet he's always fighting for minutes. Good to great off-ball defender, excellent rebounder for a wing (above average for a forward). His usage is one of the more baffling things about Kerr, and that says a lot because there are plenty of choices

I like Melton too, but he's a 3&D guy with some handles. Ironically if the team makes it in the playoffs, he'll be way more important, but regular season.. he's more of a luxury. System is designed to tolerate bad on-ball defenders (see #1 defense with Jordan Poole at POA) and his off-ball defense is slightly above average per metrics. I think somewhere in the 24-28mpg is about right for him, unless he develops an offensive game inside the arc somehow. Not much of a playmaker or finisher.. funny enough, he profiles a lot like Moody - an above average role player that can shoot well enough to stay on the court for 20+ minutes and hustles like hell
Crazy-Canuck
RealGM
Posts: 29,129
And1: 7,288
Joined: Nov 24, 2003

Re: Who starts? 

Post#13 » by Crazy-Canuck » Sat Sep 21, 2024 3:33 am

CDM_Stats wrote:As far as a full rotation, I think it should be basically a decision tree, especially at backup SF and backup C.. but ideally for me, for both halves:

Curry/Melton/Wiggins/Dray/TJD to start

at Q1 6:00, bring in Podz for Melton and bring in JK for Dray
Curry/Podz/Wiggins/JK/TJD

at 3:00, bring in SloMo for TJD, Moody for Wiggins, Hield for Curry
Podz/Hield/Moody/JK/SloMo

at Q2 9:00 bring in Dray for JK, Melton for Hield
Podz/Melton/Moody/Dray/SloMo

at 6:00 bring in Steph for Podz, GP2 for Moody, JK for Looney
Curry/Melton/GP2/JK/Dray

at 3:00 bring in Wiggins for GP2,and Podz for Melton
Curry/Podz/Wiggins/JK/Dray

If rigidly following this, full-game minutes are

Curry (30) / Podz (18)
Melton (24) / Hield (12) / Podz (12)
Wiggins (24) / Moody (18) / GP2 (6)
Dray (18) / Kuminga (30)
TJD (18) / SloMo (18) / Dray (12)

The C position (TJD/SloMo/Looney) and the SF position (Wiggins/Moody/GP2) should be more of a hot-hand approach. But the 4 guys leading in minutes would be Curry/Dray/Podz/JK with Melton and Wiggins in the 2nd tier. 3rd tier is Moody, TJD, SloMo and Hield. 5th tier is GP2/Looney


Jk considers himself a sf in his latest interview with tk. Slomo might be getting more minutes while wiggins, moody, and gp2 get even less.
vagelis
Starter
Posts: 2,245
And1: 979
Joined: Jan 04, 2015

Re: Who starts? 

Post#14 » by vagelis » Sat Sep 21, 2024 3:37 pm

I would like to see

Curry
Wiggins
Kuminga
Green
TJD
all left
Ballboy
Posts: 26
And1: 16
Joined: Aug 28, 2014
 

Re: Who starts? 

Post#15 » by all left » Sat Sep 21, 2024 4:43 pm

CDM_Stats wrote:
all left wrote:
CDM_Stats wrote:As far as a full rotation, I think it should be basically a decision tree, especially at backup SF and backup C.. but ideally for me, for both halves:

Curry/Melton/Wiggins/Dray/TJD to start

at Q1 6:00, bring in Podz for Melton and bring in JK for Dray
Curry/Podz/Wiggins/JK/TJD

at 3:00, bring in SloMo for TJD, Moody for Wiggins, Hield for Curry
Podz/Hield/Moody/JK/SloMo

at Q2 9:00 bring in Dray for JK, Melton for Hield
Podz/Melton/Moody/Dray/SloMo

at 6:00 bring in Steph for Podz, GP2 for Moody, JK for Looney
Curry/Melton/GP2/JK/Dray

at 3:00 bring in Wiggins for GP2,and Podz for Melton
Curry/Podz/Wiggins/JK/Dray

If rigidly following this, full-game minutes are

Curry (30) / Podz (18)
Melton (24) / Hield (12) / Podz (12)
Wiggins (24) / Moody (18) / GP2 (6)
Dray (18) / Kuminga (30)
TJD (18) / SloMo (18) / Dray (12)

The C position (TJD/SloMo/Looney) and the SF position (Wiggins/Moody/GP2) should be more of a hot-hand approach. But the 4 guys leading in minutes would be Curry/Dray/Podz/JK with Melton and Wiggins in the 2nd tier. 3rd tier is Moody, TJD, SloMo and Hield. 5th tier is GP2/Looney


I like these rotations, except maybe for that which begins at 3 minutes left in the first quarter. That's the only lineup that lacks Steph but also doesn't have three proven top level defensive players. Perhaps the assumption is that that lineup mostly will face similar mixes of starters and rotation players at that time in most games. Or maybe you have more confidence in Moody than I have, but he hasn't quite shown me enough yet (not his fault, perhaps, but nonetheless).

If they are hoping for a playoff spot in a tough West, I would find a way to get Melton a few more minutes than you have allotted in the first part of the season, if he is healthy. He is a proven defender and his 3 point shooting hovers close to 40%. Then see which among the young guys really is taking a step up, particularly on the defensive end, and then perhaps remix.


There's probably a way around it, but I like having a chunk of time where younger/less appreciated players can step up. That would be Podz, Moody and JK's time to step up while having a spacer in Hield and a good floor guy like SloMo there. Moody is one of the more underappreciated guys in the league - per minute, he's brought more +/- impact than JK, yet he's always fighting for minutes. Good to great off-ball defender, excellent rebounder for a wing (above average for a forward). His usage is one of the more baffling things about Kerr, and that says a lot because there are plenty of choices

I like Melton too, but he's a 3&D guy with some handles. Ironically if the team makes it in the playoffs, he'll be way more important, but regular season.. he's more of a luxury. System is designed to tolerate bad on-ball defenders (see #1 defense with Jordan Poole at POA) and his off-ball defense is slightly above average per metrics. I think somewhere in the 24-28mpg is about right for him, unless he develops an offensive game inside the arc somehow. Not much of a playmaker or finisher.. funny enough, he profiles a lot like Moody - an above average role player that can shoot well enough to stay on the court for 20+ minutes and hustles like hell


That all makes sense to me-- particularly because Moody and JK are at the point where they need to step up. One thing that makes that a least somewhat more likely is if the coach is showing confidence in your ability to step up, enough so that you can rely on your place in the rotation and just go out and play, even if there are some bumps in the road. I'm less down on Kerr than many on this board seem to be, but his weaknesses have to do with being somewhat conservative/risk averse, and that's the kind of thing he seems to find hardest to do.
HiRez
RealGM
Posts: 14,760
And1: 4,025
Joined: Dec 29, 2011

Re: Who starts? 

Post#16 » by HiRez » Sun Sep 22, 2024 10:29 pm

It's Kerr. It doesn't matter and outside of Steph and Draymond is going to change a dozen times throughout the year anyway due to matchups, experimentation, performance, and injuries/availability.
donkeylips
Analyst
Posts: 3,105
And1: 1,467
Joined: Apr 22, 2010

Re: Who starts? 

Post#17 » by donkeylips » Mon Sep 23, 2024 1:39 am

wiggins kuminga podz
I can hawk a loogie eight feet in the air and catch it with my tongue.
DevinVassell
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,532
And1: 913
Joined: Sep 28, 2020
 

Re: Who starts? 

Post#18 » by DevinVassell » Mon Sep 23, 2024 3:26 am

Moody?

lol
Romulus
Rookie
Posts: 1,035
And1: 624
Joined: Dec 08, 2021
     

Re: Who starts? 

Post#19 » by Romulus » Mon Sep 23, 2024 3:27 am

My starting 5:

Curry
Podz
Corey Joseph
Nico Manion
Chiozza

Kerr about to teach the basketball world a lesson: small ball works, especially with this group -- his all-time favorite Warrior players.
Twinkie defense
RealGM
Posts: 20,146
And1: 1,602
Joined: Jul 15, 2005

Re: Who starts? 

Post#20 » by Twinkie defense » Mon Sep 23, 2024 8:16 pm

People sleeping on Podz again...

Return to Golden State Warriors